EU Member States Decline Vote on Lifting Brazilian Poultry, Honey Import Ban

Brussels has kept Brazilian poultry and honey out of the European Union for now.

EU member state experts this week again declined to vote on a Commission proposal to lift the import ban, imposed in late August over antimicrobial residues, afz.fleischwirtschaft.de reported.

The stall in the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed — known in Brussels shorthand as SCoPAFF — means Brazil, one of the world’s largest poultry exporters, remains locked out of the 27-nation bloc a full three months after the provisional stop. For importers, retailers and Brazil’s farm ministry, the wait continues.

What makes this round different is who is holding the door shut. The European Commission, after an audit mission at the end of August, judged Brazil’s controls on antimicrobial use to be in line with EU requirements and moved in September to put the country back on the list of approved exporters.

The member states see it differently — and, according to what Commission circles told the news agency Agra Europe, France and Romania were the loudest voices against readmission, with numerous other capitals raising concerns as well.

The industry lobby on the European side had already called for exactly this outcome. “The audit does not provide sufficient guarantees that poultry meat exported from Brazil complies with EU rules on the use of antimicrobial agents,” said Birthe Steenberg, secretary general of the European poultry association AVEC, ahead of the committee meeting, according to Fleischwirtschaft.

Here is why that matters beyond the committee room. When SCoPAFF experts decline even to vote, the political weight in Brussels shifts visibly from the Commission’s technical assessment to the capitals’ risk appetite. A qualified majority of member states would be needed to adopt the proposal whenever it does come to a vote — and after this week, the arithmetic looks uncertain.

Brasília, for its part, is worried. Brazil’s agriculture ministry, MAPA, stressed that the country has fulfilled all the technical requirements the European Union set. The ministry also pointed to the Commission’s own audit mission at the end of August, which rated the Brazilian controls on antimicrobial agents as conforming with EU requirements.

So the two sides are looking at the same audit and drawing opposite conclusions. The Commission found conformity; the member states want more. Specifically, they are demanding additional explanations about the control system Brazil has set up — the machinery meant to guarantee that antimicrobial use in Brazilian poultry farms matches what EU law allows at home.

Brasília waits, Paris and Bucharest press

The disagreement now has a date attached. A Commission spokesperson said the notes and questions from the capitals would be examined and, hopefully, clarified, and that the discussion would continue at the committee’s next session on December 7 and 8 — where a vote is possible.

That December session is where the standoff either breaks or hardens. If the member states still withhold a qualified majority, the Commission faces a choice: keep negotiating with the capitals, or find another route to restore the trade. Neither path is quick, and the provisional stop from late August keeps running in the meantime.

The substance of the dispute is narrower than the headlines suggest. This is not a quarrel over bird flu or a safety scandal — it is about veterinary pharmaceuticals, the antimicrobial agents used in livestock production, and whether Brazil’s monitoring system can prove, to the satisfaction of every relevant capital, that residues in exported meat meet the EU’s strict limits.

Honey is caught in the same net. The proposal the member states declined to vote on covered both poultry meat and honey, so Brazilian beekeepers are waiting on the same December session as the poultry sector.

But there is a catch for the Commission, too. Its own audit cleared Brazil, and Brasília has made that finding the centerpiece of its case. Every week the ban outlives the audit, the gap between Brussels’ technical judgment and its political process widens — and Brazil’s agriculture ministry has made clear it regards the delay as worrying rather than warranted.

For European buyers, the practical picture is unchanged: no Brazilian poultry, no Brazilian honey, until the committee moves. For Brazil, the stakes run beyond this one file, because the EU is one of the most demanding export markets in the world for animal products and a precedent here shapes how future approvals are handled.

The European Commission, the executive that proposed Brazil’s readmission, traces its roots to 1951, when it began life as the nine-member “High Authority” of the European Coal and Steel Community under President Jean Monnet, taking office in Luxembourg City in August 1952.

Today it has one commissioner per member state — 27 in all, including the president — who are bound by oath to represent the EU as a whole rather than their home capitals, a rule with obvious relevance when Paris and Bucharest clash with Brussels over a file like this one. The current cabinet, the second von der Leyen Commission, took office in December 2024 and oversees an administrative body of some 32,000 civil servants.

The next word belongs to the committee. The Commission spokesperson said the discussion would be continued at the December 7 and 8 session — and a vote there is possible.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

GTA 6 Sells 24.5M Units, Earns $2.36B, Sensor Tower Estimates

US Ambassador Kevin Kim Pledges Deeper ASEAN-US Ties Amid Trust Dip