Evander Leads FC Cincinnati Past Orlando City Into MLS Playoffs First Round

“We played a playoff game,” Evander said after FC Cincinnati stunned Orlando City 3-1 on the road to book a first-round date with Nashville SC.

Cincinnati entered the wild-card match as the East’s ninth seed, fresh off a Decision Day loss to Nashville that dropped them into the play-in round. Orlando, the eighth seed, hosted the game at Inter&Co Stadium on the night Antoine Griezmann made his postseason debut.

The Lions led 1-0 through Martín Ojeda’s 28th-minute strike — his first goal since winning the AT&T Goal of the Year award earlier that day — and looked set to advance until Evander converted a penalty in first-half stoppage time.

Tom Barlow found the Brazilian for the go-ahead goal moments after the restart. With Orlando pushing for an equalizer, Evander sprung the counterattack that ended with a third Cincinnati goal. The visitors finished with three goals on target; Orlando managed 27 shots but only three on frame. Roman Celentano made six saves to preserve the upset.

“We knew how to suffer, how to handle pressure in the favorite’s house,” Evander told MLSSoccer.com. “We made a very solid game.”

The result rewrites the Eastern Conference bracket. Cincinnati now travels to GEODIS Park for Game 1 of a best-of-three series against Nashville, the Supporters’ Shield winner that beat them on Decision Day, according to mlssoccer. Kickoff is set for Sunday, November 22 at 4 p.m. ET on Apple TV and FOX Deportes.

Evander finished the regular season with 14 goals and 17 assists, becoming the highest-scoring Brazilian in MLS history. His two goals and one assist in Orlando marked his first postseason contributions. Griezmann, who arrived mid-season and tallied 14 goals and eight assists in 18 regular-season games, went scoreless in his playoff debut.

FC Cincinnati began as a United Soccer League franchise announced on August 12, 2015, and played its first three seasons at Nippert Stadium, where it repeatedly broke USL attendance records — including 35,061 for a 2016 exhibition against Crystal Palace and 30,187 for its first playoff match. The club won the 2018 USL regular-season title before Major League Soccer awarded it an expansion franchise on May 29, 2018, with MLS play starting March 2, 2019.

Metric FC Cincinnati Orlando City
Wild-card result 3-1 win 1-3 loss
Next opponent Nashville SC (Supporters’ Shield winner)
Series format Best of three
Game 1 date Sunday, November 22, 4 p.m. ET

“If we play like we did today, we can reach the final,” Evander said. The underdog from Ohio now has nine days to prepare for the conference’s top seed.

Evander GOAL 50' | Orlando City SC — FC Cincinnati

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

I Discovered My Dad Was a Killer on the Run – And Turned Him