Exercise Modest for Weight Loss but Key for Keeping Pounds off, Research Shows

Exercise delivers only modest weight loss on the scale, but research shows that physical activity plays an important role in keeping the pounds off after reaching a goal weight.

For patients using weight loss drugs such as Saxenda, combining exercise with the medication may help people maintain their weight loss better than using the drug alone.

Research draws together the evidence on why exercise doesn’t always result in huge amounts of weight loss.

Why the scale barely moves

At its heart, losing weight comes down to a simple rule: take in fewer calories than you expend and the weight will come off. In practice though, this isn’t usually so easy or simple. The report documents ways the body quietly undoes the deficit that exercise creates.

Exercise can stimulate appetite, leading to increased food intake. Workouts can also cause people to unknowingly cut back on how much they move for the remainder of the day, weakening the effect exercise has on their total calorie gap.

The body also becomes more efficient over time – burning fewer calories while doing the same activity. This process, sometimes called “metabolic adaptation”, reflects the body’s tendency to defend against weight loss.

Exercise shows modest weight loss effects

  • Exercise may only have modest effects on weight loss.
  • Doing higher levels of activity after losing weight was strongly linked to maintaining the weight loss.
  • Physical activity has also been linked to clear health gains – such as improved cholesterol, reduced inflammation, plus improved blood sugar control and insulin sensitivity.

A study of who kept weight off

Research involving more than 1,100 participants found that being physically active made little difference to how much weight someone shed at first. However, doing higher levels of activity after losing weight was strongly linked to maintaining the weight loss.

Physical activity has also been linked to clear health gains – such as improved cholesterol, reduced inflammation, plus improved blood sugar control and insulin sensitivity, all of which are associated with lower risk of health problems, such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes. Evidence also suggests that pairing exercise with weight loss drugs (such as Saxenda) might support long-term weight maintenance more effectively than relying on the medication by itself.

How activity guards against regain

It may seem confusing that exercise isn’t especially effective for losing weight but can help prevent regain. The reasons behind this paradox aren’t fully understood, but several mechanisms may offer an explanation.

First, when we lose weight, the energy we burn at rest drops further than the weight lost alone would account for. This is thought to contribute to weight regain. But exercise raises total daily energy expenditure, which can help to partially offset this.

Second, weight loss usually results in the loss of both fat and muscle. Losing muscle lowers resting energy expenditure, which can contribute to weight regain. But exercise, especially resistance training (such as Pilates or lifting weights), can help retain or even restore muscle.

Third, after losing weight, the body often becomes less efficient at using fat for energy. But vigorous workouts can boost fat oxidation and metabolic flexibility – the capacity to alternate between carb and fat burning based on available fuel. Exercise improves insulin sensitivity as well. This reduces the amount of insulin required to regulate blood sugar. This is beneficial as higher insulin levels can promote fat storage and reduce fat breakdown.

Exercise has many indirect effects on us that can aid in weight maintenance. For instance, exercise can improve sleep, mood and reduce stress levels. Together, these can bring down cortisol – the stress hormone – potentially decreasing how much fat the body holds onto. Staying active on a routine basis may likewise steadier appetite and blood sugar, potentially easing cravings and curbing excess eating.

Mechanisms at a glance

Mechanism Effect on weight loss Effect on weight maintenance
Appetite stimulation and reduced daily movement Stimulates appetite, leads to increased food intake; subconsciously move less Regulate appetite and blood glucose, help reduce cravings and limit overeating
Metabolic adaptation (increased efficiency) Body becomes more efficient over time – burning fewer calories while doing the same activity Raises total daily energy expenditure
Muscle loss vs. resistance training Weight loss usually results in the loss of both fat and muscle, lowering resting energy expenditure Help preserve or even rebuild muscle mass, boost metabolism
Fat oxidation and insulin sensitivity Improves fat burning and metabolic flexibility Improves insulin sensitivity, reduces insulin required to regulate blood sugar

Different bodies, different responses

It’s important to acknowledge that everyone is different. Each of us reacts to exercise in our own way, whether in the calories we expend or in how much a session makes our appetite grow afterward.

Cardio activities (like fast walking, biking or jogging) use up calories and, when done more vigorously, may also boost how well the body uses fat as energy. Resistance training, on the other hand, helps build and preserve muscle mass. The reasons behind this paradox aren’t fully understood, but several mechanisms may offer an explanation.

Who funds the evidence, and the open questions

The reasons behind this paradox aren’t fully understood, but several mechanisms may offer an explanation.

Contraindications & When to Consult a Doctor

It’s important to acknowledge that everyone is different.

Exercise might not be the strongest lever for shedding pounds, yet it may play a key part in holding on to weight you worked hard to lose. Above all, it provides a wide range of physical and mental health gains that stretch well beyond what the bathroom scale shows.

References

  • Modest effects of exercise on weight loss — Obesity (Nature Portfolio): https://doi.org/10.1038/s41366-022-01247-4
  • Reduced non-exercise activity after workouts — Obesity Reviews: https://doi.org/10.1111/obr.12507
  • Metabolic adaptation to weight loss — Nutrition & Metabolism: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12986-021-00587-8

This article is for general information and is not a substitute for advice from a qualified clinician.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Carl Lewis at 65: Olympic Legend Coaches in Houston, Champions Veganism and Politics

U.S. Expands Iran Blockade to Target Ship-to-Ship Transfers at Sea