Experts Warn Wearables May Disconnect Users From Bodily Sensations

Wearable fitness trackers generate an estimated $80 billion industry, but growing skepticism over biometric accuracy and consumer burnout have sparked a debate over whether these devices help users or foster unhealthy reliance.

Commercial smartwatches, fitness trackers, and biometric rings have entered mainstream life less than 20 years after first becoming available. However, recent legal scrutiny and rising user frustration have brought questions of measurement accuracy to the forefront.

“Every time we purchase a new piece of technology, we must kick the tyres,” said Dr Dale Esliger, Professor of Digital Health Technologies at Loughborough University, noting that consumers expect manufacturers to deliver on promised metrics.

Esliger emphasized that fitness gadgets deserve the same technical scrutiny applied to medical instruments, warning that “if they lose faith in that validity, that fitness tracker ends up in the sock drawer and so do our interventions as healthcare professionals,” he told Wits University.

Beyond technical precision, researchers point out that outsourcing bodily data can detach users from their physical sensations and natural instincts.

“My problem with sleep devices, for instance, is that they can become a behavioural barrier,” said Professor Georgia Torres, Head of the Department of Exercise Science and Sports Medicine at Wits, pointing out that algorithm-driven metrics can override how rested a person actually feels.

“You can wake up feeling refreshed and rejuvenated but if your smartwatch says you haven’t slept well, your brain will convince you that you haven’t slept well,” Torres told Wits University.

Professor Jon Patricios, Director of Wits Sport and Health (WiSH), added that human sleep requirements naturally vary across individuals. “There is no one sleep pattern that is best for everyone. Some thrive more on deep sleep, others on REM,” Patricios told Wits University.

Despite debates over exact metrics, clinical experts stress that tracking tools retain value if they motivate users to increase physical activity.

“It’s not about the actual figure, it’s about understanding the trend. Regardless of the value, if the intervention inspired by the wearable device helps to increase physical activity, that’s what matters,” Torres said.

Patricios published a study showing that as little as 60 minutes of weekly exercise before a cancer diagnosis reduced disease progression risk by 27 percent and death by 47 percent.

“The low levels of exercise required for at least some benefits are easily achievable by anyone. We should all be encouraged to use exercise as medicine!” Patricios said.

Photo of author

Priya Deshmukh - Senior Editor, Health

Priya Deshmukh Senior Editor, Health Deshmukh is a practicing physician and renowned medical journalist, honored for her investigative reporting on public health. She is dedicated to delivering accurate, evidence-based coverage on health, wellness, and medical innovations.

Robertson Says Scotland Do Not Have Time to Turn Things Around After Loss