Facinelli, Michaely Push Sony for ‘Can’t Hardly Wait’ 30th-anniversary Sequel in 2028

Peter Facinelli and Joel Michaely are pressing Sony Pictures for a Can’t Hardly Wait legacy sequel timed to the film’s 30th anniversary in 2028, citing viral fan demand after Facinelli’s Halloween reprise of Mike Dexter drew more than 80,000 likes.

The actors, joined by producer Johnny Ryan Jr. and Saturday Night Live star Kenan Thompson, say they have been trying to revive the 1998 cult comedy for years and are now asking fans to lobby the studio or a streaming partner such as Netflix or Amazon.

Facinelli, who played the loud-mouthed jock Mike Dexter, told TMZ this week that the internet is still buzzing weeks after he posted a video of himself walking into the film’s iconic graduation party in character. “A Can’t Hardly Wait sequel is the one high school reunion everyone actually wants to go to,” Facinelli said.

“Would be so fun to get the whole gang back together and see where they ended up.” He added a personal pitch for his character: “If we’re lucky, LoveBurger might finally play a song — and maybe, just maybe, if I play my cards right I can finally get Amanda Beckett back.”

Michaely, who portrayed one of the “X-Phile” nerds, appeared in Facinelli’s Halloween clip and echoed the call for a 2028 reunion. “People have been clamoring for us to do a reunion movie for years. Now is the time for our 30th anniversary in 2028. While we all still look hot,” Michaely said.

“We need Sony to make it or partner with a streaming service like Netflix or Amazon, so tell them you want to see it.”

Ryan Jr., a producer on 2023’s Good Burger 2, told TMZ that he and Thompson have spoken to cast members about producing a reunion film.

“Sony told us they weren’t sure if fans would want to see a reunion but the fans have spoken and they want it as much as we do,” Ryan Jr. said. Entertainment Weekly has reached out to Sony Pictures, the film’s producer, and representatives for Facinelli and Thompson.

The ensemble of the original film — a graduation-night house party centered on Preston Meyers (Ethan Embry) and his crush Amanda Beckett (Jennifer Love Hewitt) — also included Lauren Ambrose, Seth Green, Melissa Joan Hart, Charlie Korsmo, Selma Blair, Jason Segel, Jerry O’Connell, Donald Faison, Jaime Pressly, Clea DuVall, Leslie Grossman, Breckin Meyer, Sara Rue, Sean Patrick Thomas, Amber Benson, Marisol Nichols and Jennifer Elise Cox.

Hewitt told the Everything Iconic podcast in May 2019 that she was eager to return. “I’m dying to,” Hewitt said of making a sequel. “So I really, really, really want to, and I wanna direct it.” She noted the film’s enduring Halloween popularity: “It’s so funny, how many people who, right around Halloween, are always like, ‘Oh, me and my friends, we’re all going as the cast of Can’t Hardly Wait.”

Facinelli, born in 1973 in Ozone Park, Queens, to Italian immigrants from Trentino, made his feature debut in Rebecca Miller’s Angela (1995) and drew critical notice that year in the TV movie The Price of Love.

He co-starred with Ethan Embry and Breckin Meyer in two 1998 releases, Dancer, Texas Pop. 81 and Can’t Hardly Wait, before playing Dr. Carlisle Cullen across the five Twilight Saga films and Dr. Fitch “Coop” Cooper for seven seasons on Nurse Jackie.

Seth Green, Lauren Ambrose, Ethan Embry, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Peter Facinelli and Charlie Korsmo in 'Can't Hardly Wait'
Photo: deadline.com

Any continuation would have to reckon with the original’s post-script, which revealed that Dexter peaked in high school, drank too much in college, lost his football scholarship and was later fired from a car wash after “incriminating Polaroids surfaced.” Facinelli remains optimistic. “I brought Mike Dexter back for Halloween, and weeks later the internet is still talking about it,” he said.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Sources: Osimhen Open to Man Utd Move; Pochettino Wants Striker