Farmer Sues Tax Office Over Farm Succession Dispute

Each of her two daughters received more than 3,000 square metres of farmland — yet the tax office still treated the handover of the whole farm as a business closure.

The farmer has now taken that income tax assessment before a German tax court, turning the family handover into a farm succession tax dispute. At stake in her case is the difference between two very different tax outcomes: a farm that legally continues, or a farm that legally ends.

Her position, argued before the court, is narrow. The operation was not shut down at all, she says — only one plot, the one given to the daughter who stepped aside from the inheritance, should count as a taxable withdrawal. The rest simply carries on, smaller than before.

What the farmer argued

According to her submissions, she transferred a separate agricultural partial business to each daughter under § 6 (3) of the German Income Tax Act (EStG), the provision governing the split of a farm among successors. Each daughter’s parcel exceeded 3,000 square metres, she argued, satisfying the transfer.

One daughter received the agricultural operation itself. The second daughter, described in the proceedings as the heir stepping aside, was to be compensated for renouncing her share: the farmer withdrew a plot from the business and then transferred it to her.

On that reading, there was no closure of the business. Only the plot handed to the second daughter constituted a withdrawal subject to income tax, the farmer told the court. The remaining farm, though reduced in area, was not broken up — she described it as dormant rather than dissolved, and said it went to the other daughter.

Why the tax office disagreed

The tax office saw the same handover very differently. Its assessment treated the transfer as a full business closure — in the authority’s view, the farm had been split up among the daughters rather than continued by one of them.

That classification is where the money sits. A closure pulls the entire operation into the income tax calculation at once, while a single taxable withdrawal covers only the item taken out of the business. The farmer’s income tax assessment, as issued, reflects the closure view; her lawsuit challenges exactly that framing.

The dispute therefore turns on a single legal question: whether a farm divided between two heirs, with one continuing the operation and the other receiving land as compensation, still counts as a continuing business under the Income Tax Act — or whether the division itself ends it.

Keeping the farm in the family

The farmer also explained to the court why she structured the handover this way. It mattered to her, she said, that the farm stay in the family and that the transfer not lead to disputes between her daughters after her death.

The arrangement, as she described it, followed an understanding between the sisters: one daughter was to take over her care in old age and, for that, receive the farm. The other daughter had originally wanted to waive her share of the inheritance altogether — but the mother insisted she receive something as well, which is how the withdrawn plot entered the arrangement.

Everything in the case flows from that family logic. The daughters were in agreement, the farmer told the court; the division of land was meant to settle the succession while she was still alive, not to dissolve the business she had built.

On that basis, her request to the tax court is specific: the contested income tax assessment should be changed so that only the plot transferred to the second daughter is recorded as a taxable withdrawal. The remaining, smaller farm — the one the other daughter received — should be left out of the assessment entirely, contrary to the tax office’s reading that the operation was broken up.

The case now rests with the tax court, which must weigh the closure finding against the farmer’s account of a continued, if reduced, family farm. Its decision will determine whether the assessment stands as issued — or is narrowed to a single withdrawn plot, exactly as the farmer has requested.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Albuquerque Public Schools Demonstrates Visitor ID Scans and Wearable Panic Badges at 142 Campuses

Liverpool Internationals Return to Training as Gravenberch Misses Session