Musk Urges Sympathy for Russian Soldiers, Accuses Zelensky of Lying Over Starshield

Elon Musk called for sympathy toward Russian soldiers as well as for Ukrainians dying on the front line, Ukrainian Pravda reported on Saturday.

He was answering a question about why Starlink runs at reduced speed in Ukraine, speaking by video link at the New York Times DealBook summit in New York.

“And you should feel sympathy not only for the Ukrainian guys who are dying, but also for the Russians, because they are conscripted and forced to go to this front line,” Musk said. “Nobody goes to the front line voluntarily just to die from a drone strike.”

The remarks matter because Musk’s company, SpaceX, controls the satellite network Ukraine’s military depends on for battlefield communications and drone operations — and because he spent much of the interview defending that control.

He said he was troubled that “thousands of children are sent to death every day, and the borders do not change.” The children of the dead will never see their parents again, he added: “Imagine if it were your son or your father.”

Musk said there had been too much of a “Ukraine good, Russia bad” attitude under which “everything done to Russians can be justified,” and he called that position “terrible.” In the same breath, he declared Russia “the aggressor” — and claimed the United States had “organized a coup to overthrow a democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine,” saying it would not have happened without the State Department.

“It sounds like I’m looking for excuses for Russia here, but I’m not,” he said.

Musk Urges Sympathy for Russian Soldiers, Accuses Zelensky of Lying Over Starshield
Photo: NV

Accusations Fly Over Starshield

Interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin of The New York Times raised President Volodymyr Zelensky’s account of restricted Starshield service, according to Украинская правда. Musk accused the Ukrainian president of lying and claimed Kyiv was asking permission to use the commercial Starlink network for offensive operations. He offered no evidence, and did not clarify whether Ukraine has access to Starshield at all, Ukrainian Pravda reported.

He cast himself, instead, as Ukraine’s biggest private benefactor. “I think it would be quite fair to say that no private individual has helped Ukraine more than I have,” Musk said in the same interview, according to NV.

When Russia launched its full-scale invasion, he argued, it knocked out cellular towers, fiber lines and other satellite systems. “There was only one system they failed to disable — Starlink,” he said. “If not for Starlink, the entire defense line would have collapsed… and Russia would have won. And does that look pro-Russian to you?”

Musk also denied a well-known account that he had cut Starlink over Crimea during Ukrainian strikes on Russia’s Black Sea fleet early in the war. “We did not disable Starlink. That is not true,” he said, arguing that signals over Crimea did not work because Russia is under sanctions and switching them on without State Department approval would have been illegal.

Who Actually Slowed the Network

Zelensky’s complaint is specific. On October 16 he said Starlink and Starshield equipment on various front-line sectors stopped working when terminals moved faster than 130 to 161 km/h, complicating logistics and drone use, Ukrainian Pravda reported.

Musk Urges Sympathy for Russian Soldiers, Accuses Zelensky of Lying Over Starshield

On November 12 he said the throttling was back, again at 161 km/h — roughly 100 mph — and that Ukraine’s interceptor drones, which chase down Russian strike drones, were suffering. “Artificial restrictions do not serve peace,” Zelensky said, according to RTVI’s report.

Musk, for his part, compared the cap to a road speed limit of “about 80 miles per hour” (129 km/h) before pivoting to the war itself. “I can tell you a lot about this war, its origins and history,” he said. “Far more than, I think, almost anyone can tell you.”

Who ordered the slowdown remains disputed. The Wall Street Journal reported in October that Musk personally ordered the military version’s speed reduced, leaving Ukrainian forces barely able to use some strike and interceptor drones. Musk wrote on X on October 21 that the decision rests with the US military and, ultimately, the president. Trump said the White House played no part.

Other officials split as well. Pete Hegseth allowed that SpaceX may impose some limits under its terms of service, and Marco Rubio likewise pointed to the company’s authority over access, RTVI reported. Financial Times, citing senior Ukrainian officials, reported that Washington may have throttled Starshield deliberately to pressure Kyiv during talks with Russia in Abu Dhabi on November 10-11, according to NV.

A Month of Throttled Speeds

  • October 14 — Ukraine reported Starshield connections cutting out above 160 km/h, NV reported.
  • October 16 — Zelensky described front-line outages at speeds of 130-161 km/h.
  • October 21 — Trump denied White House involvement; Musk said the US military and the president decide.
  • October 22 — The Wall Street Journal reported Trump had phoned Musk to ask for the limits’ removal.
  • October 24 — Zelensky said the restrictions were lifted; Musk claimed Ukrainian forces had violated Starlink’s terms and that “this loophole was closed last week.”
  • November 12 — Zelensky said throttling had resumed; Financial Times reported possible US pressure during the Abu Dhabi talks.

Senators and NATO Step In

The dispute has moved into American politics. On November 13, US senators sent Musk a formal letter demanding SpaceX preserve all documents and correspondence connected to Starlink and Starshield operations in Ukraine, RTVI reported.

Republican Senator Jerry Moran was blunter. “Restricting Ukraine’s full access to Starshield capabilities prevents it from defending itself against Russian air attacks,” he said in a call for immediate restoration, according to Radio Svoboda.

Zelensky appealed publicly to the United States and to Musk on November 15, saying lives and the power grid depended on it before winter. Ukraine’s chargé d’affaires in Washington, Denys Senik, confirmed to Radio Svoboda that Starshield outages had by then lasted a seventh day.

David McGinty said the issue would come up when Mark Carney met Trump, and called it one reason Canada is building its own satellite capacity, Radio Svoboda reported of his remarks to Reuters.

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said “interested parties” were working to restore the system’s normal operation as soon as possible.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Brazil’s SUS Begins Bowel Cancer Screening at Age 50 Amid Rise in Young Adults

Wiener Börse ATX Rebounds 1.06% on Anthropic IPO, Strong Earnings