Musk Accuses Zelenskyy of Lying Over Starshield Disruptions at DealBook Summit

Elon Musk said Wednesday that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is lying about disruptions to the military-grade Starshield satellite network, and accused Kyiv of trying to press SpaceX’s civilian Starlink service into offensive war work.

Musk made the remarks at The New York Times’ DealBook Summit. The clash has drawn in Washington, NATO capitals and, now, congressional investigators.

“From the beginning, I’ve said that Starlink is a civilian system,” Musk said at the summit. “It is not meant to be used for offensive drone strikes that kill people. If you want to do that, you need to do Starshield, which is a separate system that is controlled by the US government. But do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions.”

When interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin told Musk that Zelenskyy refers to the disrupted system as Starshield, Musk was blunt. “That’s false,” he said, calling Zelenskyy “not always truthful.” Pressed on whether the Ukrainian president was lying, Musk answered: “He is lying. What he is actually saying is he wants to use Starlink for offensive military operations.”

Who controls the slowdown

The dispute over who imposed the restrictions has produced a tangle of contradictory accounts. Musk said the US government was responsible, since Starshield is controlled by it — and that President Donald Trump denied any involvement, saying he had told Musk to “put it back.” Ukrainian forces say the restrictions returned anyway.

The BBC reports its own understanding that the service disruptions did not come from the White House or the Trump administration. Trump, for his part, said Monday: “I haven’t heard that.” The origin of the order remains disputed: Reuters reported that people “inside the White House” directed the Pentagon to impose speed limits, while Bloomberg reported that Trump did not personally order any such restriction.

What is not in dispute is the practical effect. Ukrainian interceptor drones flying at roughly 100 miles per hour — the 161 km/h cap Zelenskyy cited on Telegram — lose their Starshield connection and, in some cases, drop out of the sky.

“There have already been strikes that got through because our interception systems cannot reach sufficient speeds and are unable to intercept in time,” Zelenskyy wrote in an X post on Tuesday, according to CNBC. SpaceX did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Zelenskyy’s warning before winter

Zelenskyy has framed the restriction as a matter of survival heading into the cold months. “We are counting on these restrictions being lifted. The protection of lives and Ukraine’s energy infrastructure ahead of winter directly depends on this,” he said. “It is important to be on the right side of history.”

Musk Accuses Zelenskyy of Lying Over Starshield Disruptions at DealBook Summit
Photo: CityNews Montreal

“If someone in America is making decisions that essentially treat Ukrainian territories as if they don’t belong to Ukraine, then that tells us where things are heading,” Zelenskyy said Thursday. “We must be clear and never, under any circumstances, recognize the Russian occupation of Ukrainian territory.”

Allies start building their own networks

The standoff is accelerating a search for alternatives. Canadian Defence Minister David McGuinty said this week, on his way into NATO headquarters in Brussels, that Ottawa is following Ukraine’s Starshield difficulties “very closely” and expects Prime Minister Mark Carney to raise the matter with Trump, CityNews Montreal reported. Canada is pursuing its own sovereign low-Earth orbit satellite network, which McGuinty said the episode shows the need for.

Other countries are moving too. Ukraine itself is developing a remote drone network of “flying modems” — used this week to partially destroy the bridge linking Russia with occupied Crimea, according to the Financial Times — while Indian billionaire Mukesh Ambani is seeking manufacturing partners for an Indian-controlled alternative to Starlink, Bloomberg reported.

Back home, the political reckoning has begun. Democratic senators have told Musk to preserve all records related to SpaceX’s restrictions on Ukraine’s use of Starlink and Starshield, according to a letter reviewed by The Wall Street Journal.

The Democrats plan a series of investigations into the administration’s handling of the Ukraine war when they take control of Congress in January, following last week’s midterm elections. A bipartisan group of senators has also called for a Pentagon investigation into whether American officials or SpaceX personnel were responsible.

Musk’s attempt to explain himself on Wednesday did little to settle the core question. The Ukrainians say the cap is back and cannot intercept Russia’s jet-powered Shahed drones without full speed; Musk says Zelenskyy is lying and wants civilian internet for killing; Trump says he ordered nothing and knows nothing.

The company has not said publicly who set the throttle. That is the question Congress has now chosen to ask in writing.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Vietnam: 4,110 Cervical Cancer Deaths in 2024 Despite Available Vaccines, Low Screening

Minister Robert Troy Criticises Delay After Credit Union Data Breach Exposes Payee Details