Kochi CBI Court Delivers Verdict in Ariyil Shukkoor Murder Case; CPM Leaders Among 31 Accused

KOCHI — A special CBI court in Kochi delivered its verdict on Thursday in the Ariyil Shukkoor murder case, the 2012 killing that roiled Kerala politics, with 31 accused — including CPM leaders P, according to Asianet News Malayalam.

Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh — standing trial.

The verdict, News18 Malayalam reported, closes a chapter in one of Kannur’s most politically charged criminal cases. Shukkoor, a 23-year-old Muslim League (MSF) activist, was killed on February 12, 2012 at Chulliyode near Thaliparamba, in what the case describes as a “party court” execution carried out in reprisal for an attack on Jayarajan’s vehicle convoy.

Manorama News reported the verdict followed a trial lasting 17 months. Of the 33 accused named in the chargesheet, two died during the proceedings, leaving 31 to face trial.

“The accused will be punished in the Ariyil Shukkoor murder case,” Kerala Minister K.M. Shaji said ahead of the verdict, per Pathanamthitta Media. He added: “I am 100 percent sure that P. Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh conspired.”

How the killing unfolded

According to the case as Asianet News Malayalam lays it out, Muslim League workers blocked and attacked the convoy of P. Jayarajan, then Kannur district secretary of the CPM. The retaliation followed hours later.

Shukkoor and fellow League workers were detained, photographed and their images sent by text message to confirm identities. Once Shukkoor and Zakariya Ayub were confirmed, the two were attacked at Chulliyode field. Shukkoor died at the scene.

The first and second accused are K.V. Sumesh and Ganeshan P., DYFI workers in Thaliparamba. C.N. Mohanan is the 11th accused, and Shyamjith, son of former CPM state secretary M.V. Govinan, is also among the accused, Asianet News Malayalam reported.

Jayarajan, now a CPM central committee member, figures as the 32nd accused; T.V. Rajesh, then an MLA, is the 33rd. Both face conspiracy charges. The CBI’s position, per Asianet News Malayalam, was that the conspiracy took place at Thaliparamba cooperative hospital, where Jayarajan had been admitted.

The courtroom split over evidence

Manorama News detailed the arguments that shaped the trial. The defense leaned on gaps in the first information statement: the FIS names none of the accused whom first witness Zakariya already knew before the incident, and key facts about the Chulliyode field attack were never recorded in it.

The prosecution countered that a first information report is not an encyclopedia of the incident — its purpose is to set criminal law in motion. Zakariya, it argued, told the court that shock left much unsaid and that police omitted points he had raised. The officer who recorded the statement confirmed the omissions were deliberate, on the expectation the details could be added later.

Zakariya explained, per Manorama News, that he withheld the names of accused 6, 24 and 29 — Umesh, Rajeevan and K. Babu — because they were local political leaders he feared would attack him again. The prosecution also argued the wounds on Zakariya and the second witness match the doctors’ wound certificates, and invoked Supreme Court precedent that memories of witnessing a friend’s murder endure.

On the conspiracy count against the two senior leaders, Asianet News Malayalam noted the prosecution faced a structural weakness: the key witnesses named to prove Jayarajan’s and Rajesh’s role did not appear in court to testify, according to News18 Malayalam.

Why the verdict shakes Kerala

Kannur’s political violence has a long ledger, and this case sat near the top of it. The killing ignited statewide protest in 2012 and the investigation was later handed to the Central Bureau of Investigation, which filed the chargesheet naming the district leadership.

A verdict touching sitting or former lawmakers of the ruling party carries consequences well beyond the courtroom — for the accused, for the League’s constituency in Kannur, and for how “party court” justice is prosecuted in the district.

Shaji also addressed reports he had cancelled a trip to Russia. “Those who made the news should explain it,” he said.

The prosecution’s closing position, as Manorama News framed it, was collective: unlawful assembly pursuing a common object from Valluvankadav through the confinement at Muhammad Kunju’s house to the fatal assault at Chulliyode meant no single accused’s individual blow needed proving — membership of the unlawful assembly itself suffices for liability under IPC Section 149.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Italian Biologists’ Federation President: Biologist Nutritionists Address Nutritional Needs of Already Diagnosed Patients