FCC Orders California to Halt AT&T Landline Rules, Allowing Cutoff of 184,000 Residential and 15,000 Business Customers

The Federal Communications Commission ordered California to stop enforcing its carrier-of-last-resort rules against AT&T on Thursday, clearing the path for the carrier to cut off 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers by June 1, 2027.

The order grants AT&T federal preemption over state regulations that require it to serve any customer in its territory, a mandate the FCC Chairman Brendan Carr called designed for a “bygone era.”

It reverses a July federal court decision that had blocked the same move, and it makes California the lone holdout in AT&T’s 21-state wireline footprint where the carrier has not shed its obligation to provide basic copper service.

“California’s Carrier of Last Resort framework may have made sense when it was established 30 years ago,” Carr said in the statement accompanying the order. “But those rules were designed for a bygone era and no longer make sense in today’s competitive, advanced marketplace.”

AT&T plans to replace the copper plant with a wireless home phone product that connects to its cellular network and IP-based voice alternatives.

The company argued, and the commission agreed, that the wireless product satisfies the universal service mandate; California countered that its rules permit wireless replacements only if the carrier proves the service meets specific standards, including flat-rate unlimited calling, discounted Lifeline rates for low-income users, and telephone relay service for the deaf and hard of hearing.

Court loss forces regulatory end-run

AT&T had pursued the same result in the Northern District of California, but a federal judge rejected its request to invalidate the state rules in July, Ars Technica reported.

With the judicial route closed, the carrier petitioned the FCC for preemption under Section 253 of the Communications Act, arguing state rules blocked a federally authorized network transition. The commission’s Wireline Competition Bureau and Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau granted that petition Thursday.

Trump FCC Declares It Cannot Enforce California Phone Service Rules
Photo: hitechub.com

The decision affects 184,000 residential lines and 15,000 business lines still eligible for service under the COLR designation, according to figures California submitted to the FCC. Hitechub said that AT&T has already secured reduced COLR obligations in 20 of the other 21 states in its wireline territory, leaving California as the sole exception until Thursday’s order.

Copper retirement vs. fiber reality

The order does not require AT&T to deploy fiber to the affected addresses. If the carrier retires the copper loops, many homes and businesses would lose access to a facilities-based wireline connection entirely, relying instead on fixed wireless access (FWA) over LTE or 5G spectrum.

California’s Public Utilities Commission maintains that its COLR rules already allow wireless substitution — provided AT&T demonstrates compliance with the state’s service-quality metrics. The CPUC filing archived at the FCC shows the state demanded AT&T submit network performance data, outage reporting procedures, and battery-backup specifications for the wireless home phone units before approving any transition. The FCC order effectively waives that state-level review.

Preemption precedent expands

California can still sue the commission to challenge the preemption order. The CPUC has not announced litigation plans as of Thursday evening. The next procedural milestone is June 1, 2027 — the date AT&T has targeted to disconnect the remaining COLR customers unless a court stays the FCC order.

“The FCC has granted AT&T’s applications to replace legacy voice service with a modern, IP-based alternative in certain areas of the state,” Carr said. “California’s state requirements are blocking AT&T from proceeding with a federally authorized transition.”

AT&T traces its roots to the American Telephone and Telegraph Company, formed in 1885 as a long-distance subsidiary of Alexander Graham Bell’s telephone venture. For much of the 20th century it operated the Bell System monopoly, known as “Ma Bell,” until a 1982 antitrust settlement broke it into seven “Baby Bells.”

The modern AT&T emerged when the smallest of those, Southwestern Bell Corporation, acquired the original AT&T Corp. in 2005 and adopted its name. Today it is the nation’s largest fiber internet provider and the third-largest wireless carrier, serving more than 240 million subscribers worldwide.

The FCC says yes. California says prove it.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Boston Celtics Shamrock Foundation, New Balance and Project 351 Host Playbook Initiative Workshop for Massachusetts Students