“What they’ve done in the review is got one of their bureaucratic mates to do the review and to make sure that they covered their own arses,” Chris Dillon said.
The Southland Federated Farmers executive member was reacting to the Emergency Management Southland review into the October 2025 storm that battered the region with winds up to 180km/h, causing widespread damage and prolonged power cuts. The review, released this week, concluded formal emergency procedures were largely followed, but Dillon said it failed to address the core failures on the ground.
“They haven’t addressed any of the main shortcomings in the whole event and that’s why they’ve done nothing to restore public trust,” Dillon told RNZ.
The review found that people in governance roles during the emergency were not getting the right information at the right time, or in the right format to do their jobs effectively. It made several recommendations aimed at improving information flows and inter-agency coordination for future events.
Dillon argued the process was flawed from the start, criticizing the decision to appoint an internal reviewer rather than an independent authority. He said Emergency Management Southland ignored farmers and contractors with local knowledge who could have directed resources to the hardest-hit areas faster.
“We had people on the ground who knew where the trees were down, who knew where the power lines were down, who knew which roads were blocked,” Dillon said. “And they were basically told to stand down and let the professionals handle it. The professionals didn’t have a clue.”
The October storm left thousands of households without power for days, some for over a week, as crews struggled to access damaged lines across the region’s hill country.
Dillon said farmers would be watching closely to see if the recommendations translated into actual changes before the next severe weather event.
Federated Farmers traces its roots to the New Zealand Farmers Union, incorporated in 1902, before the current federation was registered in November 1944. The organisation grew to a peak of 43,000 members in 1971 and today operates as a voluntary body with over 13,000 members across 24 regional provinces and six industry groups, including a high country section.
It is known for high-profile advocacy, notably opposing a proposed agricultural emissions research levy in 2003 — a campaign that popularised the term “fart tax” — and for successfully lobbying against the initial National Animal Identification and Tracing scheme.
“We’ll believe it when we see it,” he said.