Returning from a life-altering experience leaves a hero in a precarious position: the individual has changed, but the ordinary world remains exactly as they left it, according to Forbes.
The Burden of the Return
In his book The Writer’s Journey: Mythic Structure for Writers, Christopher Vogler notes that while the allure of a special world is strong, most heroes choose to return home or set off toward a final destination. This tenth stage of the hero’s journey, the “road back,” often requires the protagonist to reconcile their new perspective with a reality that has not evolved alongside them, Forbes reports.
This conflict is illustrated by the myth of the cave from Plato’s Republic. A prisoner who discovers the true world and attempts to share his knowledge with those still in the dark is often met with hostility, viewed as someone who has simply gone blind or is disrupting the status quo, Forbes explains.
Artistic and Historical Reflections
The tension between internal transformation and external reality appears across various narratives. In the 1984 film Amadeus, directed by Miloš Forman, the court composer Antonio Salieri struggles to accept that genius is not necessarily a reward for piety or hard work. Upon reviewing Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s manuscripts, Salieri realizes that divine inspiration does not follow human rules of fairness, a truth he ultimately cannot withstand, Forbes notes.
Survival also forces a return to a world that no longer recognizes the hero. In Roman Polanski’s 2002 film The Pianist, Władysław Szpilman emerges from hiding in a German military coat. Because he wears the uniform of the enemy, the Polish soldiers he encounters do not see the musician underneath, forcing him to prove his identity once again, Forbes reports.
The Persistence of Old Patterns
Even when a hero begins to see the world differently, past conditioning can prevent a clean break. In Taika Waititi’s 2019 film Jojo Rabbit, the young protagonist hides a Jewish girl named Elsa.
Despite realizing she is a human being, Jojo continues to lie to her about the state of the war, attempting to trap her within his old, invented picture of the world to avoid his own fear of loneliness, according to Forbes.