Forensic Experts Claim Jeffrey Epstein’s Death Was Homicide, Not Suicide

Three forensic specialists said Monday in London that Jeffrey Epstein’s injuries, documented after his death in a Manhattan jail in August 2019, point to homicide rather than suicide, contesting the official ruling of the New York City medical examiner’s office.

The finding comes from Michael Freeman, a forensic scientist and editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, Anders Eriksson, a professor of forensic medicine at Umea University in Sweden, and Itiel Dror, a researcher specializing in identifying bias in forensic decision making.

Documents obtained by Al Jazeera show their report describes the injuries on Epstein’s body as “most consistent with homicidal strangulation” and not, as the city’s medical examiner concluded, the result of hanging.

Jeffrey Epstein was likely killed: Forensic expert's new report — NewsNation

“The pattern, distribution, and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,” the report states, according to Al Jazeera’s reporting. The three believe Epstein was first assaulted and then strangled, most likely with a narrow knotted fabric ligature used from behind.

The claim matters because it is the second outside forensic review to challenge the city’s determination. In 2020, Epstein’s brother Mark hired forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden, who told 60 Minutes the neck injuries he examined pointed more toward murder than suicide, CBS News reported. The official ruling, by medical examiner Kristin Roman and Chief Medical Examiner Barbara Sampson, has remained unchanged since 2019.

What the new report claims examiners missed

He added that injuries attributed to causes other than a struggle were simply overlooked.

The report also takes aim at the investigation itself, Al Jazeera reported. Prison staff who found the body photographed nothing before moving it. Investigators never identified the ligature itself. The guard who first found Epstein initially refused to be interviewed, and the medical examiner who ruled the death a suicide was not permitted to visit the prison where he died.

Jeffrey Epstein's death may not have been suicide, forensic expert says — CBS Mornings

The authors say bruising on Epstein’s back, shoulder and neck was never acknowledged in the original autopsy statements, and that the ligature marks did not slant as they would had Epstein hanged from the bedpost in his cell. They believe either the guard lied about finding the body hanging, or the body was arranged afterward to stage a suicide.

Dror: politics shaped the examination

Dror, whose research centers on bias in forensic decision-making, told Al Jazeera he believes the political weight of the Epstein case distorted the autopsy work.

Epstein’s prominence gave the case its charge. The financier’s network spanned politics, industry, academia and the arts, and included US presidents Bill Clinton and Donald Trump. That range of contacts has fed years of questions about whether his crimes were covered up or whether associates looked away.

Why a trio of experts alleges Jeffrey Epstein did not die by suicide
Photo: stluciachronicle.com

Freeman’s own record gives the claim earlier cases to stand beside. He has consulted for families who disputed law-enforcement accounts of how their relatives died, including in the murder of George Floyd, and served last year on the Maryland Attorney General’s audit team reviewing dozens of in-custody deaths, CBS News reported.

Why the official ruling still has defenders

The medical examiner’s office has not shifted. Asked by CBS News about Freeman’s conclusions, a spokesperson said only: “Our office stands by its determination.”

Homicide, not suicide? Forensic expert Michael Freeman examined photos of Jeffrey #Epstein’s death — Nancy Grace

Other experts and reporting have backed that position. A New York Times investigation published in June, built on tens of thousands of pages of newly released documents and Epstein’s own handwritten jail notes, found indications he intended to end his life.

The paper reported that, of the forensic experts it interviewed, almost none believed the manner of death could be conclusively settled on the medical evidence alone, CBS News noted.

Where the two accounts stand

The disagreement turns on how the same evidence is read. The city’s medical examiner holds that hanging fits the injuries, and that a strange scene is not proof of anything else; Freeman, Eriksson and Dror hold that the bruising, the ligature marks and the gaps in the investigation point to an assault followed by strangulation.

Forensic pathology, as CBS News noted, is not an exact science, and neck injuries from hanging or strangulation can be especially ambiguous.

Freeman’s access came through Mark Epstein, who has doubted the suicide ruling since his brother’s death and gave the researcher the autopsy records and photos, CBS News reported. Freeman said he concluded that, in August 2019, the man he called the world’s most notorious sex abuser was likely attacked and killed by another person.

In 2008 he pleaded guilty to the solicitation of a minor for sex and served 13 months behind bars.

Forensic expert questions Epstein death, weighs in on Ken Urker case — NewsNation

The medical examiner’s office, for now, holds its line. “Our office stands by its determination,” the spokesperson said.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Ohio Beats Morehead State 91-77 Behind Hot Shooting, Foul Trouble