Former Iowa State Players Demand Independent Review, Allege Abuse Under Bill Fennelly

Six former Iowa State women’s basketball players demanded Friday that the university commission an independent, trauma-informed review of the program, alleging a culture of verbal, emotional and psychological abuse under longtime head coach Bill Fennelly.

The letter, sent to Iowa State President David Cook and Athletic Director Jared Benko, arrives days after Fennelly served a one-game suspension for nudging guard Sienna Harvey’s head during a timeout in a Nov. 14 victory over UIC. The former players, represented by Des Moines attorney Lori Bullock, say the incident reflects a longstanding pattern the administration failed to address.

An Iowa State spokesperson confirmed the university received the letter Friday but declined further comment. Fennelly, 69, announced last month he will retire after this season, his 32nd at the helm.

“We experienced or witnessed conduct we considered to be verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse from Coach Fennelly,” the players wrote. “We reported this and what we believed was inappropriate physical contact to members of the coaching staff and Iowa State athletic administration, but we do not believe our concerns were taken seriously.”

AMES, IOWA - NOVEMBER 15: Head coach Bill Fennelly of the Iowa State Cyclones looks on during the second quarter against
Photo: kcci.com

Two players go public with names

Maggie Espenmiller-McGraw, an Indianola native who played from 2019 to 2023, and Izabella Zingaro, a team member from 2020 to 2023, signed the statement publicly. Four others remain anonymous. Both Espenmiller-McGraw and Zingaro transferred out of the program to finish their careers, according to KCCI.

Espenmiller-McGraw earned All-Big 12 Freshman Team honors in 2020 and is now an assistant coach at Division II Fort Lewis College. Zingaro was an All-Horizon League selection at Cleveland State last season, USA Today reported.

“Our individual experiences may differ, but we are united in our concerns about an environment where intimidation, humiliation, and fear became normalized,” the statement reads.

6 former Iowa State women's basketball players call for independent review of program — KCCI

Suspension prompts renewed scrutiny

Fennelly was suspended by Benko, who took over as athletic director in October following Jamie Pollard’s retirement. The coach sat out Wednesday’s 72-57 win at Northern Iowa. In a postgame news conference after that game, Harvey defended her coach.

“I can see how it was perceived on the internet, but he loves us and cares about us more than anyone,” said Harvey, who transferred from Washington. “And I like being coached hard, so I think it was perceived differently than what it was.”

Teammate Mya Babbitt echoed that sentiment. Fennelly apologized after the UIC game for “allowing my emotions to get the best of me.”

Former players detail lasting impact

The letter describes consequences extending beyond playing careers: “For some of us, the consequences did not end with our playing careers. We continue to deal with anxiety, depression, diminished self-worth, and lasting distress that we associate with our time in the program.”

Former Iowa State Players Demand Independent Review, Allege Abuse Under Bill Fennelly
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

The players also allege systemic failures: “We also believe the systems and supports meant to protect student-athletes repeatedly failed. Some of us felt dismissed, discouraged from speaking openly, or afraid of the consequences of raising concerns.”

A spokesperson for the group told USA Today they are not considering legal action at this time but are seeking accountability, protection against retaliation, and reforms to protect current and future athletes.

Program history includes prior lawsuit

This is not the first time Fennelly’s program has faced formal complaints. In 2017, Iowa State settled a lawsuit for $60,000 with former guard Nikki Moody, who played from 2011 to 2015. Moody sued Fennelly, the university and the state of Iowa for racial discrimination and retaliation, alleging she was repeatedly called a “thug” and labeled a selfish player. Fennelly was dismissed from that suit before it settled.

Fennelly took over a program in 1995 that had never reached the NCAA tournament. He leaves with a 662-335 record, 24 tournament appearances and three Big 12 tournament titles (2000, 2001, 2023). The Cyclones are 6-0 this season with a roster almost entirely rebuilt after nine players transferred following last season, including top scorers Audi Crooks, Jada Williams and Addy Brown.

University response awaited

The letter calls on Iowa State to investigate whether previous complaints were properly handled and to publicly acknowledge the seriousness of the allegations. As of Friday evening, the university had not indicated whether it would commission the requested review.

“We do not speak for every woman who has worn an Iowa State uniform,” the former players wrote. “We speak from our own experiences. For years, many of us felt unable to speak. Today, we are choosing to speak together. Winning does not excuse mistreatment. Loyalty to a program should never require silence.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

SEC Investigates Nvidia Over Singapore Revenue Reclassification and Round-Trip Financing