Fossil Reefs Guide Caribbean Coral Conservation, Study Finds

Ancient fossil reefs sitting just meters from living coral colonies in the Caribbean may point scientists toward locations where marine ecosystems can persist through future warming, according to research published by University of Texas at Austin scientists.

Reefs across the Caribbean have declined sharply over the past 70 years. Researchers studying already damaged modern ecosystems found themselves missing a clear baseline of what a healthy reef used to look like and lacked complete data regarding biological resilience.

“Because we were studying already damaged reefs (in the modern-day Caribbean), we had a limited baseline of what a healthy reef used to look like and were missing understandings of things like resilience,” Claire Williams said, who led research on the fossil and modern reefs while earning a doctorate at the UT Jackson School of Geosciences, phys.org reported.

“So, my theory was that by bringing in the fossil record, we could get a richer picture of coral tolerances and make better predictions for the future,” Williams told phys.org.

Fossil Evidence From Jamaica

In two new papers published in Palaios and Conservation Biology, researchers identified which coral species dominated ancient reefs in northeastern Jamaica to help guide future rehabilitation efforts.

Studying modern corals
Photo: news.utexas.edu

The team analyzed corals found in fossil reefs at two sites in Jamaica dating from 125,000 to 130,000 years ago during the Late Pleistocene epoch, a time characterized by interglacial warming periods. Williams said that these past warming periods serve as strong analogs for conditions the planet is projected to experience in 50 to 100 years.

Because the fossil reefs now sit above sea level, researchers adapted modern coral monitoring transect methods. Instead of swimming above the formations, scientists walked along them and photographed the fossils to estimate coral numbers and distribution in the area.

At fossil fore-reef assemblages located at Navy Island and Dragon Point, branching corals known as Acropora cervicornis dominated at approximately 50 percent relative coral abundance, according to the Palaios study. At Dragon Point, fossil Acropora palmata comprised roughly 40 percent of the community, while at Navy Island it appeared less prevalent at roughly 10 percent, alongside higher abundances of Orbicella species at roughly 20 percent and Pseudodiploria strigosa at roughly 15 percent.

Decline of Branching Species

Modern reefs in East Portland surveyed between 2017 and 2024 exhibit approximately 1 percent live coral cover as of 2024, according to the Palaios study. Those modern sites are dominated by stress-tolerant taxa including Porites astreoides, Orbicella species, Agaricia species, and branching Porites species.

Researchers found that branching corals like Acropora palmata and Acropora cervicornis, which thrived during the Pleistocene, are now largely dead and covered by algae. Meanwhile, most remaining corals consist of Porites astreoides, a globular species that Williams noted can recover quickly following disturbances but fails to provide helpful reef structure.

“These big branching species provide a lot of habitat and offshore protection. With that gone, we’ve lost that function on the reef,” Williams said, according to phys.org.

Rebuilding these damaged environments requires more than simply planting additional Acropora corals into degraded spaces, explained Rowan Martindale, an associate professor at the Jackson School’s Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences and co-author on the papers, as reported by phys.org.

“We can nurture and transplant new, healthy corals from nurseries to damaged reefs, often referred to as coral gardening, but if they are in a place that’s too hot in the future, they’re not going to survive,” Martindale told phys.org.

She added that many corals transplanted by the Alligator Head Foundation, a marine conservation group in East Portland, Jamaica, died off during the heat-induced bleaching event in the summer of 2023.

Mapping Future Refuges

To pinpoint survival zones, researchers investigated the ecological niches of ancient corals by analyzing the water temperatures and salinity those organisms could tolerate. The analysis incorporated mid-Holocene fossil records to add data points from a more recent period spanning 5,000 to 7,000 years ago.

This historical baseline fed into predictive models alongside climate projections to identify Caribbean reef areas anticipated to maintain suitable sea-surface temperatures and salinity levels. The study identified parts of the northern Caribbean, the Florida Keys, and the Yucatan Peninsula as optimal spots for future conservation efforts.

Williams emphasized that these findings represent a starting point rather than a standalone fix, noting that environments must undergo consistent monitoring for threats like disease, pollution, and natural disasters. Conservation efforts must remain adaptive and continuously incorporate new data.

“The fossil record can improve our predictions and provide best-case ideas of where things might be able to survive,” Williams said, according to phys.org. “Conservation needs to be adaptive and to keep learning new information.”

The University of Texas at Austin, founded in 1883 as the flagship of the University of Texas System, operates the Jackson School of Geosciences where Williams completed her doctorate. The university is a major center for academic research with expenditures totaling $1.06 billion in fiscal year 2023 and has been a member of the Association of American Universities since 1929.

Martindale said that safeguarding reef ecosystems remains vital for human communities relying on them for fisheries and protection against hurricanes. “There are people that need the reefs for fish and protection from hurricanes. You can’t just abandon the places that rely on those functions,” Martindale said, according to phys.org.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Trump Urges Nvidia to Give Jensen Huang Second Chance

Bogdan-Martin Wins Second ITU Term; Leosk Elected as First Female BDT Chief