German Court Rejects BSW Election Challenge, No Recount

„Jetzt ist es amtlich: Deutschland hat die Wahlprüfung einer Bananenrepublik – mit höchstrichterlicher Billigung“, erklärte Sahra Wagenknecht nach dem Urteil, according to Spiegel.

Das Bundesverfassungsgericht in Karlsruhe on Wednesday rejected her party’s challenge to the February 2025 Bundestag election as inadmissible, and the votes will not be recounted.”

The decision, published Wednesday by the court’s Second Senate, ends the BSW’s 21-month fight over an agonizingly narrow result. The party, now called the Bündnis Soziale Gerechtigkeit und Wirtschaftliche Vernunft, took 4.981 percent of the second votes – 9,529 short of the five-percent threshold. A nationwide recount, which Wagenknecht and others had demanded, is off the table. According to BILD, the court ruled unanimously.

The stakes were high: the BSW maintains that counting errors cost it representation, and that it should actually hold 35 seats in parliament. Had it cleared the threshold, WELT reported, all mandates would have been redistributed – and the current black-red coalition would no longer hold a majority on its own.

Four voters stood behind the complaint. They first lodged an objection with the Bundestag, which rejected it in December 2025, then turned to the constitutional court. The court was unmoved. „Die Wahlprüfungsbeschwerde ist unzulässig“, erklärte das Gericht in einer Pressemitteilung zu dem nun veröffentlichten Beschluss vom 20. Oktober, according to FAZ. The complainants, it found, failed to meet the requirements for substantiating such a challenge.”

German Court Rejects BSW Election Challenge, No Recount
Photo: BILD

The BSW had argued its votes were disproportionately often wrongly marked invalid, and that counting errors piled up against it. It also flagged the name similarity between the BSW and “Bündnis Deutschland” as making ballot confusion especially likely.

The judges disagreed on both counts, FAZ reported, adding that post-election corrections after the preliminary result are a sign the process works – not evidence that more corrections are needed. BILD noted the court’s principle: however narrow the result, a complaint must always be equally well founded.

The party’s response was scathing. She warned that real electoral fraud could now go unchallenged and said the party would examine further legal steps.””

Sahra Wagenknecht erklärte, die Richter des Bundesverfassungsgerichts seien von Parteien ins Amt gebracht worden, deren Macht und Mandate sie mit diesem Urteil sicherten.

German Court Rejects BSW Election Challenge, No Recount
Photo: WELT

That accusation, which BILD quoted Wagenknecht making, went further than her co-chair’s. The party’s Saxony state chapter went further still, declaring that Karlsruhe was abolishing itself, Deutschlandfunk reported.”

Germany’s electoral review runs on two tracks: the Bundestag examines objections first, and only then can a complaint reach Karlsruhe. Full or partial reruns are rare – the only precedent came when Berlin’s 2021 federal vote was partially repeated in February 2024, without changing the overall outcome, as UNTERNEHMEN-HEUTE.de noted.

The ruling lands on a party already struggling. WELT reported the BSW’s poll numbers have slipped, two of three state elections this autumn went against it, and only Sachsen-Anhalt delivered a seat in parliament. There, its cooperation with the AfD has stirred internal conflict.

For now, the arithmetic of the Bundestag stands as certified in 2025. Amira Mohamed Ali erklärte, es bleibe ungeklärt, ob der Bundestag korrekt zusammengesetzt ist, remains, in her party’s view, an open question – one Karlsruhe has declined to answer.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Ukraine Still Counts 129,000 Sq Km as Potentially Mined, Officials Say