Good Food Ranks Sydney’s Top Five Pancakes, A.P Bread and Wine’s A.Pancake No.1

Good Food ranked Sydney's top five pancakes, naming A.P Bread and Wine's A.Pancake No.1, and is inviting readers to vote for their favourite.

Sydney’s best pancake is now a plate-sized, oven-baked hotcake with a crackling brulee-style crust, according to Good Food’s new ranking of the city’s top five pancakes, published by SMH Good Food this week.

The A.Pancake at Darlinghurst’s A.P Bread and Wine claimed the top spot, ahead of new entrants in Dawes Point and established favourites in Potts Point, Lewisham and Marrickville.

The ranking is the work of Bianca Hrovat, Good Food’s Sydney eating out and restaurant editor, who tried the winning dish when the Good Food team visited A.P Bread and Wine for brunch in October. She wrote that she thought she had “experienced everything pancakes had to offer” before that meal — but there had “never been a pancake in Sydney quite like this.”

The A.Pancake, priced at $22, is round, thick and as large as the plate it sits on. It is lacquered in toffee-brown kithul syrup — a reduced floral sap from the Sri Lankan kithul palm — and topped with a scoop of whipped honey butter that slowly melts down one side. Beneath a crust that “crackles like brulee beneath your fork,” the interior is fluffy and sunshine-yellow, SMH Good Food reported.

What pushed it to the top was texture. Hrovat credited “that unexpected play on texture, that contrast of biscuity crunch, smoky-sweet syrup and baked batter” for the number-one placement. She noted one drawback: a side of berries costs an additional $6.50.

Good food ranks sydneys five pancakes topped by one
Photo: khanlist.com

The dish was developed about six months ago by chef Mat Lindsay, co-founder of the A.P Bakery empire and the man behind Sydney venues including Poly in Surry Hills, Ester in Chippendale and the new neighbouring dine-in bar Pig Mary.

Lindsay told SMH Good Food he was inspired by the Golden Diner pancakes, which drew queues of up to two hours when they debuted at chef Sam Yoo’s New York cafe in 2019.

Both versions use a pre-fermented yeast batter and are briefly cooked on the stove before going into the oven. “It’s more of a hotcake as opposed to a pancake,” Lindsay said. Where his version goes further is on the stove: he uses clarified butter to shallow-fry the batter and set the crust, aiming for something crisp yet fluffy and “substantial without being a day-ender.”

Good Food ranks Sydney’s top five pancakes, topped by one like we’ve never seen before
Photo: newsfiledaily.com

Sydney’s pancake innovation has a long run-up. Bill Granger’s amorphous ricotta hotcakes appeared at his eponymous Darlinghurst cafe more than 30 years ago, and the supersized sourdough pancake at Pina debuted in Potts Point in 2020.

This week, another contender entered the fray: the creme brulee pancake at Jinius, a cafe-bakery in Dawes Point led in partnership by Yeongjin Park, former head baker at Tenacious Bakehouse, and Jerry Jeong, former chef at Quay and Saint Peter.

Park repurposes chiffon cake batter to build a pancake that is as light as can be without sacrificing substance. He told SMH Good Food that souffle pancakes “err too far from the original,” and he did not want to serve something that could disappear within a few bites.

The result, priced at $26, is two slabs of pancake layered over house-made strawberry jam and bruleed vanilla custard, glazed in maple brown-butter syrup, with a fridge-cold square of butter torched on top. Hrovat described it as “the pancake emoji sprung to life, if it tasted like burnished caramel with a hint of vanilla.” Savoury variations are set to debut in coming weeks.

The full list, with prices

Rank Dish and venue Price
1 A.Pancake, A.P Bread and Wine, Darlinghurst $22
3 Sourdough pancake, Pina, Potts Point $24

The Pina sourdough pancake is described as imposingly large and not nearly as sweet as the norm, offered with bacon or berries, with maple syrup on the side.

At Lewi, the $20 buttermilk pancake comes topped with house-made rhubarb compote, maple syrup, creme fraiche and lime zest — macerated berries cost another $8. And at SIT in Marrickville, a theatrical $26 diner-style pancake arrives with a whisper-thin sheet of butter that disappears within moments of reaching the table.

Hrovat also flagged three more for readers to try: the ricotta pancake at End of King in Newtown ($23, served with Mapo stracciatella, house-made cherry jam, date caramel and pistachios); the frangipani skillet pancake at The Borrowed Table in Kellyville Ridge ($24, with blueberry compote, lemon custard and ricotta); and the $17 smoked maple pancakes at Cafe Diner, an all-day pop-up in Surry Hills on Sunday, November 22.

Good Food is also inviting readers to cast their vote for their No.1.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Columbus Rock Band Brute Sun Announces Debut Album Release and Hometown Shows

Colts Rule Out 5 Players vs. Texans; Starting Tackles, Cornerback Among Absences