Just one day after its debut on Thursday Grand Theft Auto 6 faced a massive wave of negative user ratings on Metacritic that dragged its user score down to 5.3, Omelete reported.
The title launched on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S. Its setting is Vice City, a fictional version of Miami that debuted in the first Grand Theft Auto and later received its own entry with Grand Theft Auto: Vice City in 2002. The story follows a couple with a criminal history, Jason and Lucia, who function as a modern Bonnie and Clyde moving through the underworld of Vice City.
Critics praised the open-world title with a 99 percent approval rating, matching The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, according to Terra. The professional score is based on 152 reviews, Última Ficha reported. Users disagreed sharply in more than 10,000 reviews submitted on launch day, Última Ficha reported. Approximately 50 percent of those user scores were negative, falling below 49 points.
At the peak of the influx, Metacritic registered 300 reviews per minute, a volume nearly impossible for a game that requires at least 40 hours to complete the main story, according to Rockstar Games, Radio Geek reported. Data analysts identified bot patterns, including copied text and random score switching between 0 and 2 to maximize visual impact, Radio Geek reported.

Social Media Backlash
Frustrated players targeted the game’s narrative choices, mechanics, and technical limitations. Many reviewers labeled the title a “simp-ulador” because protagonist Jason prepares a house for the return of his partner Lucia, Omelete reported, according to Terra. The term “simp” is American slang for men who do everything to please women. That house-repair segment is completely optional, as is the romance, Omelete reported.
Other user reviews attacked the frame rate and development cycle. “Simulador de pautas progressistas, diálogos constrangedores, 13 anos de desenvolvimento, sem lançamento para PC, 30 fps,” complained one user review cited by Omelete. A considerable portion of users criticized the heavy influence of Red Dead Redemption mechanics on GTA 6’s structure, suggesting the pacing fails to meet expectations for a more agile experience, Última Ficha reported.
Recurring terms in the negative reviews included “greed,” “loot box in disguise,” and “modern slavery,” referencing allegations of 100-hour workweeks during the final stretch of Red Dead Redemption 2 development, Radio Geek reported. Technical complaints cited performance issues and bugs that erased mission progress, Última Ficha reported. Among the 20 largest gaming channels on Twitch, 12 adopted “0/10” as a running joke, creating a cascade effect, Radio Geek reported.
Record Sales Despite Protests
Rockstar Games sold 32 million copies and grossed 3.79 billion dollars at launch, cementing the title as the largest entertainment launch in history, Omelete reported. Reviewers across platforms also noted the removal of solicitation mechanics present since Grand Theft Auto 3 in 2001, Terra reported. The mechanic had featured in previous titles such as Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, Grand Theft Auto 4, and Grand Theft Auto 5, Terra reported, according to Omelete.
Vice City first appeared in the original Grand Theft Auto and returned as the setting of the 2002 title Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, which sold 17.5 million copies overall and became the best-selling game of that year. The 2002 entry was set in 1986, drew heavily on the film Scarface and the series Miami Vice, and was built after the development team conducted field research in Miami to shape its two main islands.
“Many aspects of the previous titles are not present in GTA 6, but we believe that the elements we included are all necessary and complementary to the feeling and motivations that we wanted to emphasize while playing the story of Jason and Lucia,” Rockstar Games said in a communication to Shacknews. Players can still visit strip clubs and flirt with non-player characters, but Jason cannot hire sex workers, Terra reported.
Rob Nelson of Rockstar Games explained that “the relationship is your to cultivate or your to lose,” according to an interview with The Guardian cited by Terra. On Backloggd, the game holds a 3.9 out of 5 rating, with 15 percent of users assigning the minimum score, Última Ficha reported. The protest movement also targets the full price of 399 reais, downloadable content announced before release, and long-standing crunch accusations, Radio Geek reported.
