Harvard Strike Workers Misread the Labor Dispute, Argues Undergraduate

Graduate and academic workers at Harvard University entered a fourth week of strike action, and the unions have framed the dispute in sweeping moral terms — with an undergraduate editorial now arguing the strikers have misread the economics entirely.

The Harvard Graduate Student Union-United Auto Workers has been striking for four weeks, and the Harvard Academic Workers-United Auto Workers threw its weight behind the action last week. Both unions frame the standoff as a moral struggle against exploitation by a corporate behemoth.

That is how HGSU vice president Evan R. Lemire put it in the union’s strike announcement.

Strikers have chanted “no justice, no peace” in front of academic buildings, blared air horns outside a GenEd midterm — leaving students scrambling for earplugs and noise-canceling headphones — and picketed a panel with Stephen Colbert and Yo-Yo Ma ’76 after they refused to move the event off campus. Author John Green delivered his Harvard lecture over Zoom rather than cross the picket line.

Striking UAW Units Anchor Case to Endowment's Scale

  • Two UAW-affiliated units are now on strike at Harvard, in week four.
  • The unions anchor their case to the endowment’s scale — nearly $68 billion — while critics argue the endowment grows through investment returns, not from teaching labor.
  • Graduate compensation is a bundled transaction: education and roughly $50,000 in annual payment combined, a structure the editorial argues obscures the true subsidy.

Benjamin Isaac’s Case Against the “Exploitation” Frame

The argument drawing attention on campus comes from Benjamin Isaac ’27, an Associate Editorial Editor and a double concentrator in Government and Economics in Eliot House. His column, published as the strike entered its fourth week, contends the unions have imposed “the conventions of industrial labor disputes on the intellectual life of a university.”

Isaac’s core claim is economic, not rhetorical. According to his writing, academic employment is exceptionally sought-after — reading, writing, and debating ideas all day used to be reserved for those of leisure, whereas Harvard now funds people to do exactly that.

Competition for these positions is fierce, with far more qualified aspirants than permanent openings, which is why workers accept relatively low wages and uncertain prospects in exchange for non-monetary benefits and the possibility of tenure.

But the bundling problem is where his analysis gets specific. Graduate students are paid to receive years of expensive education while simultaneously selling labor as teaching fellows and research assistants. The net result is an annual payment of around $50,000 — a figure that, Isaac argues, looks like a modest stipend in a bank account while hiding the full scale of Harvard’s investment.

His milk-and-eggs analogy makes the incentive distortion plain: if you can only buy milk and eggs together, you end up with more eggs than you wanted, less milk than you needed, or both. Tying graduate employment to educational funding, he writes, risks Harvard hiring more teaching fellows than it needs, creating “pedagogically dubious sections” while excluding otherwise qualified instructors — including undergraduates.

He also flags a distributional complaint the strikers rarely raise: rather than subsidizing every Ph.D. student equally through bundled pay, Harvard could charge tuition and distribute financial aid according to need — an arrangement Isaac describes as potentially more equitable.

Endowment Grows Through Investment Returns

The unions’ strongest talking point is the endowment’s size. Isaac’s counter is accounting logic. Harvard is a nonprofit university, not a corporation enriching shareholders through the appropriation of workers’ labor.

Even under a Marxist definition of exploitation — an employer keeping the “surplus value” workers produced — the analogy fails, he argues, because a company profits from its workers’ productive labor while the endowment grows through investment returns, not through teaching and research.

That distinction has real budgetary consequences. Money spent on higher salaries is money unavailable for financial aid, research, teaching or other institutional priorities. Isaac further suggests that because Harvard trains scholars who will mostly go on to careers at other institutions, the university has reason to preserve employment practices that its own workers are protesting.

Non-tenure-track faculty face different circumstances, he concedes, but they too pursue a competitive profession whose rewards extend beyond monetary compensation. The result, in his framing, is “a peculiar form of false class consciousness”: highly educated professionals pursuing desirable careers who have come to see themselves as an exploited proletariat.

Figure in dispute Value Source and framing
Harvard endowment ~$68 billion Cited by HGSU vice president Evan R. Lemire in strike announcement
Annual graduate payment ~$50,000 Net of bundled education and labor transactions, per Isaac’s column
Strike duration Week four HGSU strike, joined by Harvard Academic Workers-UAW last week

Strike Disrupts Academic Events

The operational costs are already visible. A GenEd midterm was disrupted by air horns and chanting. A panel event with Stephen Colbert and Yo-Yo Ma ’76 went ahead under picket lines after organizers refused to relocate it off campus. John Green moved his lecture to Zoom — a decision Isaac cites as evidence of the dispute’s reach into ordinary academic life.

The disagreement, reduced to its simplest terms: the unions call it a fight against exploitation; Isaac calls it “an ordinary disagreement over compensation.” The strike continues.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Sutton Residents Petition to Ban $16 Billion Data Center Proposal

Tom Dillmann Named Ford Racing Hypercar Reserve Driver for 2027 WEC Season