Pay equity campaigners won in the High Court on Thursday: Justice Paul Radich ruled the coalition’s 2025 rewrite of the Equal Pay Act unjustifiably discriminates against women.
The declaration does not strike the law down, and the Crown may still appeal.
The judgment found the main driver behind the changes was money. Justice Radich wrote that there was “nothing tangible” in official papers to support ministers’ arguments that the old system was broken. The amended act passed under urgency in May 2025, with all three readings on one day and no select committee process, cancelling 33 live pay equity claims.
Five unions brought the case, representing health staff, teachers, public servants and tertiary education staff. In his ruling, the judge found the amended Equal Pay Act breached the Bill of Rights Act, the statute shielding people from discrimination on the basis of sex.
The changes also raised the threshold for a “female dominated” workforce from 60% to 70% for at least 10 consecutive years, and limited claimants to comparators within their own industry or sector.
“They have, for the reasons I have given, been the subject of unjustified discrimination on the basis of their sex. A declaration vindicates their positions. They deserve to have the importance of the right, and the fact of its breach, recognised by the court,” Justice Radich said in the decision.
A $12.8 billion saving, a court’s scepticism
The stakes were high. The overhaul was projected to cut roughly $12.8 billion in costs across a four-year period, and much of that money flowed into the 2025 Budget’s coffers. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon dismissed arguments against the reforms at the time as “disingenuous” and said there was some “scaremongering going on”.
Lawyers for the Crown argued the changes secured the long-term sustainability of the pay equity system, saying ministers wanted to keep pay equity but control costs that had previously been committed outside the yearly Budget process. The Crown said the old regime had low thresholds, little guidance and broadly scoped claims, and that frequent pay reviews made it hard to tell whether gaps came from sex-based discrimination or other factors.
Justice Radich examined the official advice behind the decision and drew a different conclusion. “The documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal,” he said. “More proportionate changes could have been used”, the judge said, and even if the measures succeeded in delivering the Budget savings projected in the lead-in papers, they “are not proportionate to the stated objectives.”
In the judge’s view, the claim that the old framework was unworkable only surfaced once ministers had already resolved to pass the law ahead of Budget 2025. The judgment described the reason as “strictly financial”.
The unions lost two other arguments: the court found the Government had not acted unlawfully by passing the law under urgency without consultation, and that cancelling claims did not breach rights to natural justice.
Workers who lost claims overnight
More than 150,000 women had their claims cancelled when the law changed suddenly. Under the amended rules, women working in female-dominated occupations found it tougher — and sometimes outright impossible — to lodge fresh claims aimed at correcting the undervaluing of their work on gender grounds.
“Today we’ve been heard,” said Lisa Marriner, an aged care health care assistant and Nurses Organisation delegate. “The court today said what we’ve known all along. What the Government did to us was wrong. They robbed low-paid women and their whānau so they could balance their books while caregivers are left struggling to pay their bills.”
Marriner told RNZ that a lot of the preparatory work for her claim had already been done before all 33 claims were cancelled. She also wanted the next government to reinstate the former system and to consider compensatory payments for care and support workers and early childhood teachers.
Plunket nurse and NZNO delegate Hannah Cook told RNZ the government had replaced a world-leading pay equity system with a “sham scheme”. As proof of how the new law operated, she said the union had lodged claims on behalf of Plunket, Hospice and Bupa nurses, only to have Health New Zealand shut those claims down.
Union leader demands parties reinstate pay framework
The ruling lands mid-negotiation, with the make-up of the next government still unknown. Public Service Association national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons called on parties to “take leadership” on the issue, and singled out possible kingmaker the Opportunity Party.
“The next Government whoever they are must reinstate the previous framework without delay and settle the 33 claims that were cancelled,” Fitzsimons said.
“Every party negotiating to form a government should commit to it and we call on the Opportunity Party to take leadership on this if it is in a position to help form a government. "No coalition deal should leave this egregious law on the books," she said. She called the ruling a "historic decision" but said the fight was not over.”
Opportunity opposed the Government’s 2025 overhaul, but restoring pay equity was not among the party’s five so-called “bottom lines” expected to drive coalition talks. Meanwhile, Labour leader Chris Hipkins has promised to reinstate pay equity within 100 days of taking power if elected.
Outgoing Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden, who led the reforms, said in a statement the decision was being “carefully considered” by officials.
“The Crown needs to consider whether to appeal, so that limits what I or any government minister can say. This Government committed to a well-functioning pay equity regime. We didn’t think the previous legislative regime got the settings right.” She said that given the possibility of appeal and the government operating in a caretaker capacity, she did not intend to comment further.
What the declaration can and cannot do
The declaration is a formal finding that the law breaches a protected right, but it does not cancel the law or restore the extinguished claims.
After the declaration becomes final, the Attorney-General is required to inform Parliament, and the government of the day then has six months to set out a formal response. A group of organisations is also asking the United Nations to investigate whether the changes amount to systemic discrimination against women.
Post Primary Teachers’ Association president Chris Abercrombie told RNZ that every party seeking to form the next government needed to take the judgment seriously: “Women’s right to pay equity must never again be treated as a cost to be engineered away.”
Luxon, born in Christchurch in 1970, spent most of his career in business before entering politics. He worked for Unilever from 1993 to 2011, with postings in Sydney, London, Chicago and Toronto, where he led the company’s Canadian operations, before returning to New Zealand after 16 years overseas.
As chief executive of Air New Zealand from 2013 to 2019, he presided over record profits. He entered Parliament in 2020 as MP for Botany, took the National Party leadership unopposed in November 2021, and was sworn in as prime minister on 27 November 2023 after signing a coalition deal with ACT New Zealand and New Zealand First.
Whether the Crown appeals, and whether any incoming government reinstates the scheme, remain the open questions. The law, for now, stays on the books.
Worth a look
- Trump Calls Putin ‘My Friend’ at G20 in Miami; Doctors Split on GLP-1s for Kids
- Bogalusa Bookkeeper Pleads Guilty to Embezzling Over $200,000
- Bogong Moths Use Earth’s Magnetic Field as Compass, Study Finds (time.news)
- UK Parliament Receives Bill to Overhaul Feudal Leasehold System Affecting 5 Million Homes (archynewsy.com)