Hong Kong’s Court of Appeal has raised the penalty on the operator of the Prudential Hotel in Jordan from HK$104,000 to HK$950,000, ruling on Wednesday that the original fine failed to reflect how serious the hotel’s price-fixing role really was.
The Competition Commission had appealed the Competition Tribunal’s original order against Prudential Hotel (BVI) Limited, the owner and operator of the Kowloon hotel, arguing the sum was too low to deter anyone, according to ON. The appeal court agreed on November 19 and lifted the fine more than ninefold, per on.cc’s report of the ruling.
The stakes go beyond one hotel. The judges sided with the commission on a point of principle: a company that merely “facilitates” collusion between competitors — without ever selling the tickets itself — can still face a penalty sized to the gravity of the scheme, not the size of its own takings.
The commission welcomed the ruling, saying it sends a message that third parties who help supposedly rival businesses break the competition law bear legal consequences and fines themselves, and that the judgment reflects the seriousness of the conduct, according to HK01.
Why the original fine looked so small
The appeal court’s mathematics did the damage. HK$104,000 worked out to roughly 0.06 percent of the respondent’s annual turnover in the case period — a sum the judges said could not achieve either specific or general deterrence, on.cc reported. Sing Tao noted the fine was even smaller than the rent income the hotel earned during the conduct.

Prudential’s position had been that HK$104,000 already reflected its culpability. It stressed it did not start the scheme; it acted only as a facilitator. The tribunal had accepted a structured-fines approach, but the commission argued that method does not fit a facilitator who is not an active operator in the relevant market — and the appeal court agreed, HK01 reported.
The judges instead endorsed benchmarking the fine against what other participants in the same conspiracy had paid.
How the scheme worked, per the court record
The underlying conduct ran from May 2016 to May 2017. Two travel service suppliers — Kam Lun Travel and Tink Labs Limited — fixed the prices of sightseeing tickets and transport tickets sold across nine hotel groups in Hong Kong, including Harbour Plaza 8 Degrees, the Prudential Hotel and the Harbour Grand Kowloon, according to on.cc’s account of the case.
The hotels and an in-house tour counter operator acted as conduits, passing pricing information between the two suppliers and actively helping put the arrangement into effect. The commission had reasonable cause to believe the arrangement breached the First Conduct Rule of the Competition Ordinance.

Sing Tao’s report added texture on motive: Kam Lun’s managing director, former Travel Industry Council chairman Ricky胡兆英 (Hu Chao-ying), was unhappy that a rival was selling tickets in hotels at lower prices, and pressed hotels repeatedly to lock in matching pricing with his competitor.
The Prudential, the judges found, was no passive bystander — it relayed Kam Lun’s prices to Tink Labs and asked Tink Labs to follow them, prompting the court to question whether the conspiracy could have operated at all without its coordination.
The cooperation gap that shaped the outcome
There is a contrast in this case the commission itself drew. Before going to the tribunal in a case filed on January 20, 2022 against the hotel and five other respondents, the commission issued infringement notices to every facilitator involved — the hotel groups and the tour counter operators. Some cooperated early, accepted the notices, admitted liability, avoided trial and came away with no fine and no costs, HK01 reported.
The Prudential refused the infringement notice, refused to cooperate, was sued, was found in breach, and on Wednesday saw its penalty multiplied.

The court ordered the company to pay the HK$950,000 within 42 days, plus the commission’s costs of both the appeal and the earlier tribunal proceedings, Sing Tao reported.
What the ruling means for facilitators
For Hong Kong’s hospitality and travel trade, the practical reading is blunt. Renting a hotel counter to a tour operator does not insulate a hotel group from competition liability; if the arrangement becomes a price-signalling channel between rivals, the landlord can be fined as though it participated.
The case number is CACV 218/2025, and the written judgment now stands as the appellate benchmark the commission asked for — one that treats price collusion as what the judges called the archetypal infringement of price competition, a mechanism on.cc’s summary of the judgment likened to the central nervous system of the market economy.
The Prudential Hotel itself is a four-star property in Tsim Sha Tsui, rated No. 13 among four-star select hotels in Kowloon by one booking platform, with an outdoor rooftop pool and a shopping mall directly beneath it. It sits above the Jordan MTR station, a placement the hotel’s own marketing presents as its defining convenience for business and leisure guests alike.
What remains unresolved is where the ceiling sits for facilitator fines in future cases, since the court endorsed departing from the commission’s usual fine-setting policy rather than writing a new formula. The question the record leaves open: with nine hotel groups named in the scheme and only some having settled early, how many others will now wait to see how the next tribunal sizes their penalty.