Human Rights Watch Opposes Proposed Swedish Law Changes Regarding Landmines and Cluster Munitions

Human Rights Watch has weighed in against proposed changes to Sweden’s criminal law that would let Swedish troops handle antipersonnel mines and cluster munitions during joint military operations, warning in a submission to the Swedish government that the amendments would breach two treaties Stockholm joined decades ago and risk unraveling a disarmament framework that has saved countless lives.

The submission, Human Rights Watch reported, targets the Swedish government’s review of crimes of unlawful possession of mines and unlawful possession of cluster munitions. The review, drafted after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 and the withdrawal of some of Sweden’s allies from those treaties, argues the changes would clarify national law and shield Swedish soldiers from unpredictable criminal liability in coalition operations.

Here is why that matters beyond Stockholm’s ministries. Sweden has been a state party to the Mine Ban Treaty since 1999 and to the Convention on Cluster Munitions since 2012, adopting domestic penal sanctions when it acceded. Human Rights Watch says the review’s proposed exceptions go further than either treaty permits — and would put Sweden out of step with how most states parties read their obligations.

“International Humanitarian Law is not made for the hopeful days of peacetime. It is made for humanity’s darkest days, when armed conflict rages and people are in grave danger,” the president of the International Committee of the Red Cross said in 2024, as quoted in the submission.

What the proposal would allow

The core of the dispute is language. Proposed Penal Code Chapter 22, Section 6b states that it shall not constitute an offense to use, stockpile or transfer antipersonnel mines within the framework of international military cooperation — provided the dealing does not constitute the laying of mines.

Only a person who has participated in laying mines to a substantial extent would be held liable. A near-identical Section 6d would replace Sweden’s stand-alone cluster munition law with comparable exceptions.

Human Rights Watch opposes both. The Mine Ban Treaty bans use, stockpiling and transfer of antipersonnel mines “under any circumstances,” the organization says, so carve-outs for coalition warfare permit what the treaty forbids. Under the review’s reading, a Swedish soldier could even take part in laying mines, so long as the participation falls short of “substantial.”

The review also lists activities that should not lead to criminal liability: transporting another state’s mines or cluster munitions, guarding a base where they are stored, joint stockpiling on a common base, commanding a foreign force equipped with them, planning operations with states not party, protecting a unit ordered to lay mines, and benefiting indirectly when others use them.

Human Rights Watch calls this permissive approach out of step with most states parties.

How far out of step? The organization’s own monitoring gives the numbers, and they are stark.

Treaty commitment (Sweden) Date
Acceded to the Mine Ban Treaty 1999
Acceded to the Convention on Cluster Munitions 2012
States parties that would not participate in planning or use of antipersonnel mines in joint operations with states not party at least 44
States parties that prohibit transit or foreign stockpiling on their territory at least 33

Those counts come from the Landmine Monitor, which Human Rights Watch says also records a general, albeit informal, understanding that providing security, storage or transportation for antipersonnel mines is off-limits in joint operations. “transporting or guarding units that possess and subsequently lay anti-personnel mines.” The review, by contrast, says Swedish troops could lawfully transport or guard units that possess and subsequently lay mines.

It also treats the transit of banned weapons through Swedish territory as permissible; Human Rights Watch points out the review never addresses the argument that transit can itself amount to assistance with a prohibited transfer or use.

The Article 21 argument, and why it does not settle the case

But there is a catch the review’s defenders will reach for: Article 21 of the Convention on Cluster Munitions, which governs relations with states not party. Some states have argued its opening “notwithstanding” phrase creates an exception to Article 1’s prohibition on assistance.

The majority view — and Human Rights Watch’s — is that Article 21(3) primarily removes doubt that mere participation in joint military operations is allowed, a reading consistent with the convention’s object and purpose of ending, for all time, the suffering cluster munitions cause.

Even on the review’s own reading, Human Rights Watch argues, the amendment fails: Article 21(4) explicitly bars a state party from itself using, stockpiling or transferring the weapons during joint operations with a state not party. And the organization adds that it would be internally contradictory for the convention to require states to discourage use while letting them assist with it.

Why Sweden’s position carries weight

Sweden matters here because of what it has been. A state party for over a quarter century on landmines and over a decade on cluster munitions, it helped anchor the humanitarian disarmament consensus in northern Europe.

The review itself surveys other states parties as models, and Human Rights Watch observes that in some — though not all — cases their positions diverged from the review’s proposed interpretation. Canada, like Sweden, has expressed a [sic], the submission notes.

The geopolitical backdrop sharpens the stakes. Russia’s 2022 invasion pushed several of Sweden’s allies out of the Mine Ban Treaty, and the review frames its amendments as a way to keep Swedish troops deployable alongside them.

Human Rights Watch does not dispute the national interest or the value of legal clarity; it argues Sweden can protect its troops and join coalitions while upholding the treaties, and points to alternative, less problematic solutions it identifies at the end of its submission.

For investors and defense planners watching Europe’s security realignment, the episode is a signal of a quieter kind: the pressure on alliance members to harmonize weapons law with partners who never signed the same treaties. Whether interoperability can be achieved through legal exceptions or through narrower tools is the question now before Swedish officials reviewing the submission.

What the government decides — and whether it accepts Human Rights Watch’s alternatives instead of the review’s exceptions — is not yet known. The organization, which has served as an editor of the annual Landmine and Cluster Munition Monitors from the publications’ inception, has made its case in writing; the response now rests with Stockholm.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Anthropic IPO Expected to Mint New Trillion-Dollar Company