An Indian man was sentenced to more than 19 years in a US federal prison on Friday for orchestrating a failed assassination plot against a Sikh separatist leader in New York.
US District Judge Victor Marrero handed down the 235-month sentence in Manhattan federal court against Nikhil Gupta, 55, following his guilty plea in February to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Prosecutors with the Manhattan US Attorney’s office had recommended a sentence of about 24 years.
“This case cuts to the very core of American values,” prosecutor Ashley Nicolas said in court, adding that the justice system does not condone violence to silence voices in the country. According to court papers reported by the Los Angeles Times, Gupta faces deportation to India once he completes his sentence.
The case centers on a conspiracy targeting Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a dual US-Canadian citizen and lawyer at Sikhs for Justice in New York who advocates for a sovereign Sikh state named Khalistan in northern India. Prosecutors said that Gupta arranged the plot with an Indian government official identified as Vikash Yadav, wiring $15,000 in online payments in 2023 to a purported hitman who was actually an undercover US law enforcement officer.
Courtroom Apologies and Allegations
Addressing the court, Gupta expressed regret for straying from the nonviolent path of Indian independence leader Mahatma Gandhi.
“I’m sorry to Mr. Pannun, I’m sorry to the communities I hurt, I’m sorry to my own family, which always loved me, even when I did not deserve it,” Gupta said, according to the Los Angeles Times.
Pannun delivered a lengthy speech during the proceedings, telling the court that he viewed Gupta as a subordinate acting under orders from Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. “Because I lead the campaign openly, defy threats and intimidation,” Pannun said, Modi’s administration wants him dead.
Gupta’s defense attorney, Isabelle Kirshner, argued in court that her client was not the mastermind of the operation. Kirshner described Gupta as a hardworking husband and father who volunteered at an orphanage and animal shelter before becoming entangled in the conspiracy, urging the judge to issue a punishment based solely on Gupta’s actions rather than as a rebuke to India.
Yadav remains charged in connection with the case but is not in US custody, and it remains unclear whether he has secured defense representation.
Diplomatic Strains and Next Steps
The discovery of assassination plots against Sikh separatists in the United States and Canada has heavily strained diplomatic relations between Western nations and New Delhi. The Indian government has consistently dissociated itself from any plot against Pannun, maintaining that such actions violate official state policy.
Outside the Manhattan federal courthouse on Friday, demonstrators gathered holding blue and yellow flags representing an independent Punjab, marching around a makeshift prison cell installation featuring photographic illustrations of Modi and Indian Home Affairs Minister Amit Shah in orange jumpsuits.
Pannun told the assembled court that the legal proceedings would not deter his political activism. “Self-determination for my people and my homeland, Punjab, is my lifetime goal,” he said.
Sikhs for Justice, the group Pannun leads, was founded in 2007 by the lawyer himself in the United States after Indian courts failed to convict those responsible for the 1984 anti-Sikh massacres following Indira Gandhi’s assassination.
India banned the organization as an unlawful association in 2019. It is known for staging unofficial referendums on Khalistan independence, starting with a London vote in October 2021 that drew about 2,000 participants, followed by larger turnouts reported in Switzerland, Italy, Canada and Australia.
“willing to take India's bullet if that is the price for attaining freedom for my people,” Pannun said.