| Archyde — Omar El Sayed, World Editor |
ANTALYA, Türkiye — Joan Carling counts among the world’s most prominent Indigenous rights advocates, and on the sidelines of COP31 she delivered a stark warning: the clean energy transition is being planned over the heads of the communities whose land holds most of the minerals it needs.
“It’s our resources; it’s going to be our minerals, and our lands will be used for the transition. We’re not at the table. We’re not the ones taking the decisions,” Carling told Global Issues.
Her warning goes to the heart of the Just Transition Mechanism currently under negotiation in Antalya, Türkiye, where the two-week climate summit runs through November 20. The mechanism,expected to be one of the summit’s principal outcomes, is meant to translate broad commitments on fairness and jobs into practical action as governments negotiate how to move away from fossil fuels.
Yet the minerals that make that transition possible — lithium, nickel, cobalt, graphite and rare earths — remain largely absent from the political declaration being drafted at COP31, Global Issues reported.
The Minerals Behind the Climate Negotiations
Wind turbines, electric vehicles, batteries and solar grids cannot be built without critical minerals. Demand is rising fast, but much of it is coming from outside the energy sector.
According to forthcoming research by Anabel Marin and Phil Johnstone for the Transition Security Project, cited by the Institute of Development Studies (IDS), only 29 percent of copper, 17 percent of nickel and 20 percent of rare earths went into energy technologies in 2024, based on International Energy Agency data.
Military applications accounted for roughly 10 percent of global copper consumption, while defence and aerospace took 33 percent of chromium and 17 percent of beryllium, IDS wrote ahead of the summit.
“Despite being extracted in the name of the transition, critical minerals are increasingly used for other agendas, including data centres, and fossil fuel infrastructure and – most concerningly – in defence,” said Anabel Marin of IDS in the institute’s pre-summit statement.
Her colleague Johnstone’s co-authorship of the research makes the wider point sharper: drones require all 36 rare minerals used in strategic technologies, against around a dozen each for solar panels and wind turbines, according to figures IDS cites. Marin argued that military use of minerals should be part of the climate discussion in Antalya, and that leaders needed to recognise the scale of the transition “cannot be achieved without peace.”

Carling, executive director of Indigenous Peoples Rights International (IPRI) and a 2024 Right Livelihood Award laureate, puts a number on the stakes: Indigenous territories hold an estimated 54 percent of critical mineral deposits. Whether or not Indigenous communities take part in decisions, they sit on the physical ground of the transition.
She acknowledged a milestone from last year’s summit in Belém, where negotiators at COP30 recognised Indigenous peoples’ rights to land, territories, resources, self-determination and free, prior and informed consent. Recognition alone, she said, is not enough. Indigenous peoples are still treated mainly as stakeholders to consult, not as rights-holders with decision-making authority, Global Issues reported from her remarks in Antalya.
“Just moving away from fossil-fuel extractivism to extractivism again for critical minerals.”
Carling said of the risk she sees replacing one extraction model with another. The consequences, she argued, are already visible: “We’ve already seen the legacy of mining, which has completely devastated our territories, destroyed our livelihoods and our food systems, and polluted rivers and water bodies,” she said.

The tension is visible inside the negotiating rooms. Lexie Greene, a graduate student at the School of Policy and International Affairs who observed two Just Transition sessions at COP31, described on her blog how energy-intensive nations defended business as usual while mineral-rich delegations pressed for alternatives to current extraction systems.
She said that Fiji, speaking for the Alliance of Small Island States, called out gaps in implementing a just transition for women, young and Indigenous peoples and workers, while Japan argued in more technical terms for streamlining the work programme and using existing mechanisms rather than creating new bodies.
Producer Countries Want More Than Extraction
For mineral-producing states, the issue is economic structure, not only rights. Brazil has large reserves of graphite, nickel, lithium, niobium and rare earths, and in September it adopted a National Policy on Critical and Strategic Minerals and created a dedicated council within the Presidency, Global Issues reported. Gabriella Salazar, a Brazilian mining law specialist, put the dilemma plainly: “There is no energy transition without mining.”

Salazar said COP31 outcomes should formally recognise critical minerals as an integral part of the energy transition supply chain, a step she argued would unlock investment, technical cooperation and capacity-building to move producer countries beyond raw extraction into refining, processing and manufacturing. That question of who captures the value has become a recurring theme among developing countries at the talks.
Annabella Rosemberg, senior adviser on just transition at Climate Action Network, said the draft Just Transition Mechanism does include references to mineral extraction, Indigenous rights, local participation and value addition. The harder fight, she told Global Issues, is social justice getting equal weight with technology deployment: “There is much more talk about electrification than there is about just transition.”
She warned that language alone will not deliver outcomes. “We’re getting great language on just transition. But we need to have something that has some teeth to make it happen.”
A Rulebook Taking Shape Outside the COP
While negotiators debate principles, mineral diplomacy is advancing elsewhere. An analysis by the International Institute for Sustainable Development of more than 200 recent trade and economic agreements found 139 contained critical-mineral provisions, Global Issues reported.
Among them is a France-Malaysia agreement on critical minerals cooperation signed ahead of COP31, and critical minerals have featured prominently in Quad discussions — Japanese Prime Minister attended the Quad summit during the week his environment minister, Hiroyoshi Sasagawa, spoke on implementation in Antalya.
On November 17, leaders gathered for the 46th ASEAN Summit in Manila, where critical minerals were expected on the agenda — Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said as much. But the summit’s official outcome statement gave minerals no prominent place, unlike artificial intelligence and regional economic cooperation, Global Issues reported. Supply-chain security is instead being pursued through bilateral deals and strategic partnerships rather than any dedicated multilateral framework.
That fragmentation is what concerns Michael Franczak, an economic governance researcher at the United Nations University Centre for Policy Research and co-author of the recent report Governing Critical Minerals: Advancing Global Cooperation in a Fragmented Landscape.
“Critical minerals may be absent from the official COP31 agenda, but they are hovering over everything,” Franczak said. No single institution governs the intersection of mining, energy, trade, investment and industrial strategy, yet all of it shapes whether the transition succeeds.
Franczak does not call for a new treaty. His proposal is more pragmatic: stronger coordination among existing institutions to improve transparency, widen participation by producing countries and handle cross-border problems no single body can manage. The goal, he argued, is not slowing the transition but ensuring it unfolds fairly and accountably.
Negotiators in Antalya have three days left. The Just Transition Work Programme is widely expected to be extended, but how powers are devolved, how producing communities get a share of value, and whether rights provisions gain what Rosemberg calls teeth — those fights remain open as the talks move into their final days.