A court in Yogyakarta on Thursday sentenced Anita Palupi, principal of the Little Arefa daycare centre, to five years in prison for child abuse — half the ten-year term prosecutors had demanded, in a case that has sparked national outrage in Indonesia since police found young children tied up during a raid in late April.
Judges also ordered Palupi to pay 510 million rupiah in fines, about US$27,900, CNA reported. She was found “legally and convincingly guilty” of child neglect, running an educational facility without a permit, and “allowing violence against children to be carried out continuously”, according to judge Sunaryanto, who like many Indonesians goes by one name, speaking at the Yogyakarta District Court.
The gap between what prosecutors sought and what the court delivered is the story’s sharpest edge. Prosecutors asked for ten years. The judges gave five. And Palupi is not the only defendant whose sentence came in lighter than the state’s demand.
Outside the courthouse, the contrast was felt personally. “The sentence is not adequate for what they have done to our children,” said Tri Susilawati, a parent at the court, according to AFP. She said she hoped prosecutors would file an appeal.
How the case came to light
The Little Arefa Daycare Centre in Yogyakarta province was raided by police in late April. Officers found dozens of children aged two to six with their hands and feet bound together, CNA reported.
What pushed the case into national view was footage, not the raid itself. CCTV recordings circulating on social media showed toddlers lying on the floor wearing only nappies, their hands and feet bound with rags, The Straits Times reported. The centre was closed soon afterwards.
The scale of what police uncovered was stark. They found 20 children crammed into a room just three metres by three metres, and estimated that more than half of the roughly 100 children at the daycare had been maltreated, The Straits Times reported.
City police chief Eva Guna Pandia said at the time that the women had told police they tied up some children to prevent them from disturbing others, and that the centre was understaffed, without enough personnel to bathe and dress the children.
Prosecutors alleged that Little Arefa operated without a licence and that caregivers routinely tied up, slapped and pinched children to make them easier to manage. The investigation identified 144 child victims, and police named 32 suspects overall, CNA reported.
The sentences, side by side
Palupi was arrested in April along with 11 daycare workers and the head of the foundation running the centre, The Straits Times reported. The workers — all women — were sentenced in late October to prison terms of two to three years, each fined 60 million rupiah, local media reported. Prosecutors had asked for five years for each of them. Again, the court came in below the demand.
| Defendant group | Sentence | Fine | Prosecutors sought |
|---|---|---|---|
| Principal Anita Palupi | 5 years | 510 million rupiah | 10 years |
| 11 caregivers (October) | 2–3 years each | 60 million rupiah each | 5 years each |
| Chairperson Diyah Kusumastuti | pending | 900 million rupiah sought | 10 years |
One case remains open. Daycare centre chairperson Diyah Kusumastuti has been charged with directing the abuse and operating an unlicensed facility from 2022 to 2026, CNA reported. She faces a 10-year prison sentence and a 900 million rupiah fine, along with 1.2 billion rupiah — about US$65,700 — in restitution for 83 children, according to local media reports.
Why the lighter sentences sting
The pattern is hard to miss. In every sentencing so far, judges have handed down roughly half of what prosecutors demanded. For the caregivers, five became two to three. For the principal, ten became five.
Whether that reflects judicial discretion, the quality of evidence, or Indonesian sentencing norms is something the court rulings themselves have not explained in the available reporting — and it is the question parents like Susilawati want answered before the appeals window closes.
Reuters could not immediately contact the defendant’s legal representatives for comment, CNA reported. What Palupi’s defence team intends to do — appeal or accept — is therefore unknown.
The case has also called into question Indonesia's daycare oversight. The facility ran without a licence for years, according to the charges, and the abuse was discovered by viral footage rather than by any regulator. Prosecutors’ charge sheet against Kusumastuti dates the unlicensed operation back to 2022, meaning at least four years passed before the state intervened.

For now, the count stands at 144 identified child victims, 32 suspects, and three sentencing rounds in which every punishment landed below the prosecution’s demand. The heaviest penalty in the entire case — ten years — is still only a request, not a ruling, and it awaits Kusumastuti.
The case has unfolded in Yogyakarta, the capital city of the Special Region of Yogyakarta in south-central Java and the only Indonesian royal city still ruled by a monarchy. Known as a centre of classical Javanese arts such as batik and wayang puppetry, the city is also renowned for education, hosting dozens of schools and universities including Gadjah Mada University, the country’s largest institute of higher education.
Yogyakarta, named after the Indian city of Ayodhya, even served as Indonesia’s capital from 1946 to 1948 during the National Revolution.
Whether prosecutors appeal Palupi’s five-year sentence, as Susilawati hopes, will decide whether that gap between demand and verdict closes or stands.