Irish Tánaiste Simon Harris has called for direct talks with London to define the criteria for a border poll, challenging the British government’s insistence that the decision rests solely with the Northern Ireland Secretary.
Speaking on The View programme, Harris said a “shared understanding” between Dublin and London would be “useful” and constitute “good governance.”
The intervention comes after Secretary of State Chris Bryant told RTÉ’s Morning Ireland he would “only bring forward a border poll at such time” as it appears likely a majority would vote for a united Ireland.
Pressed repeatedly on what metrics he would use to judge that likelihood, Bryant replied: “When it appears likely.” He insisted the Good Friday Agreement makes the call his alone, a position Harris does not dispute legally but argues requires practical clarity.
“The commitment in the Good Friday Agreement is exactly as Chris Bryant read out, there’s no disputing of that,” Harris told BBC News. “But the application of that is something that would be good to have a greater understanding.” He confirmed he and Taoiseach Micheál Martin are aligned on the issue and suggested joint government proposals on unity preparation could emerge by year-end.
The exchange exposes a widening gap between the two co-guarantors of the 1998 accord. Bryant, speaking before the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference in Dublin, dismissed the idea that Stormont’s current budget and power-sharing difficulties strengthen the case for unity.
“I don’t accept the premise of the argument that because there are problems in setting a budget that Northern Ireland should immediately be part of a united Ireland,” he said. He added that he does not “detect a mood” for constitutional change.

Harris, who is due to become Taoiseach in November 2027 under the coalition’s rotating agreement, has meanwhile advanced a detailed “blueprint” for unity preparations. Fine Gael proposals include appointing a junior minister for north-south relations and establishing an independent, inter-party consultative forum. That forum would examine institutional reform, public services, taxation, and healthcare on an all-island basis.
The economic stakes are substantial. A document published by Fine Gael, authored by an economist advising Harris, estimated the first-year cost of reunification to the Irish exchequer at between €3 billion (£2.5 billion) and €25 billion (£20.8 billion). The wide range shows the uncertainty over subvention levels and public service harmonisation.
Unionist reaction has been uniformly hostile. DUP leader Gavin Robinson said his party has “absolutely no interest in a discussion about the destruction of our own country.” UUP leader Jon Burrows labelled the Fine Gael plans a “constitutional pet project” and vowed his party “will not participate in any project designed to dismantle the United Kingdom.”
TUV leader Jim Allister told Harris to “butt out of the affairs and future of those pleased to be part of a larger and more prosperous United Kingdom.”
Alliance leader Naomi Long struck a different tone, saying her party would “engage respectfully” in conversations about Northern Ireland’s future “without prejudice to how we might decide the constitutional question.” SDLP leader Claire Hanna welcomed the initiative, arguing a “New Ireland must mean precisely that: an opportunity to build a new nation, not simply reverse partition.”
The Good Friday Agreement stipulates the Secretary of State “shall” call a poll if it appears likely a majority would vote for a united Ireland. However, it does not define the evidentiary threshold — whether that rests on opinion polls, election results, demographic data, or a combination. Bryant’s refusal to elaborate on his methodology leaves Dublin seeking a formal intergovernmental mechanism to interpret the trigger.
“We no longer live on an island where one constitutional view has greater value than the other,” Harris said. “Both views are legitimate and just like nationalists have lived in a Northern Ireland that has been part of the United Kingdom, it is possible in the future that unionists will live in a Northern Ireland that is part of a united Ireland.”
Simon Harris, born in 1986 in Greystones, County Wicklow, was elected to Dáil Éireann in 2011 at age 24, becoming the “baby of the Dáil.”
He entered Cabinet in 2016 as Minister for Health and, after succeeding Leo Varadkar as Fine Gael leader in March 2024, was appointed Taoiseach on 9 April 2024 at age 37, the youngest in the state’s history. He served as Taoiseach until 2025 before assuming his current roles as Tánaiste and Minister for Finance.
The next meeting of the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference will test whether “good governance” can bridge the gap between a legal discretion held in London and a political imperative felt in Dublin.
Keep reading
- Trump Declares Summit With Putin and Xi a Success
- UK, EU Agree to Link Carbon Markets, Ease Food Trade, Launch Youth Scheme
- UK, French, and German Security Advisers May Visit Moscow for Ukraine Peace Talks (world-today-news.com)
- Sources: Brady in Talks to Buy Chelsea Stake After Birmingham Exit (time.news)