Italy’s Chamber of Deputies Passes Antisemitism Law Adopting IHRA Definition

Italy’s Chamber of Deputies passed a law against antisemitism on Tuesday evening after heated and emotional discussions, adopting the IHRA definition despite left-wing objections.

The bill cleared the house with 147 votes in favor, 93 against and five abstentions from the center-left Democratic Party, making the proposal law.

The law carries no new criminal offenses. Its five articles deal with prevention, education and monitoring — yet the fight over it was anything but technical. What changed on Tuesday night is not the penal code but the official vocabulary of Italian politics, and that vocabulary now binds the government to a definition that some of Italy’s allies in Europe have adopted and others have pointedly refused to touch.

The first article states that Italy rejects antisemitism and adopts the working definition of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), the intergovernmental body that has become the reference point for how dozens of countries classify Jew-hatred, according to De Telegraaf. That is where the trouble starts.

Italy Approves Antisemitism Law Amid Free-Speech Debate — The Global report

The IHRA framework counts comparing Israel’s current policies with Nazism as a form of antisemitism. Left-wing opposition parties argue that under this definition, fierce criticism of the Israeli government could be branded antisemitic. The center-right majority backing Giorgia Meloni’s government denies any intent to censor criticism of Israel.

“A gag law,” said Bonelli. “a cover-up,” they replied

Angelo Bonelli, leader of the Green-Left Alliance (AVS), did not mince words during the debate.

Italy's Chamber of Deputies Passes Antisemitism Law Adopting IHRA Definition
Photo: Newsmonkey – –

“It is a gag law to cover up the crimes of the Netanyahu government and the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians,” said Angelo Bonelli, leader of the Green-Left Alliance.

“Antisemitism, like every form of racism, is a plague that must be fought with every possible means. Precisely for that reason, it is serious that the right is making ideological use of it to silence criticism of a government — that of Israel — that has committed crimes against humanity.”

Here is why that framing matters. The vote did not split along the usual government-versus-opposition lines. The center-left Democratic Party abstained rather than voted against — a sign of internal disagreement within the party over how far criticism of Israel can go.

The liberal parties Azione and Italia Viva voted in favor. And the radical-right party Futuro Nazionale of General Vannacci voted against — not because it found the law too harsh, but because it considers it an infringement on free speech.

Vannacci’s position carries its own baggage. On a popular television program recently, he declined to pass judgment on Hitler and Nazism. “I do not judge history, I leave that to moral crusaders, like you,” he told the show’s presenter, Corrado Formigli. A man who will not condemn Hitler helped sink a law condemning antisemitism — on free-speech grounds.

Italy Approves Antisemitism Law Amid Fierce Debate #shorts — Veruna Global

Government cites quadrupled antisemitic incidents

Meloni’s coalition argues the law answers a measurable problem. According to data from the Italian Observatory on Antisemitism, reported incidents nearly quadrupled between 2022 and 2025, with a marked rise in physical violence. Livia Ottolenghi, representing the Union of Italian Jewish Communities, praised the law as an important step in strengthening Italy's democratic resilience against hate.

The timing is no accident. Since Hamas’s terror attacks against Israel on October 7, 2023, and Israel’s harsh military response against the Palestinians, antisemitism has spread widely across Italian social media. Pro-Palestinian demonstrations have sometimes been linked by the government to public order disruptions.

Italy passes law listing some criticism of Israel as anti-semitic · 09:00 GMT 18 Nov — The Night Watch

But there is a catch in how that online hatred manifests. Hitler’s name is deliberately absent from Italian social media discussions of Israel, because an existing Italian law already criminalizes the glorification of Hitler, fascism and Nazism. So users dodge moderation filters and prosecution with coded phrases — examples include “the Austrian painter unfortunately never finished his work” or “the little mustache was right.”

The government coalition rejected every opposition amendment, including proposals to adjust the antisemitism definition. Representatives of Forza Italia insisted the legislation poses no threat to democratic freedoms and that legitimate political criticism remains legally protected. That is the core dispute, and neither side moved an inch.

La Camera approva: ddl Antisemitismo diventa legge — VD

What the law actually does

Strip away the parliamentary fireworks, and the substance is administrative. Article 2 obliges the Italian Council of Ministers to adopt a three-year national strategy against antisemitism. Article 3 directs police to monitor incidents, targets online hate speech, and mandates awareness programs in specific sectors: schools, universities, the military, the judiciary and the world of sports.

The final two articles appoint a National Coordinator for the fight against antisemitism and stipulate that implementing the law must cost the Italian state nothing extra. No fines, no new crimes, no prosecutions. The battle, in other words, is entirely over interpretation — over who gets to define the boundary between legitimate criticism of a foreign government and hatred of a people.

That boundary question is now live across Europe, where the IHRA definition has been adopted by some governments and contested by others for precisely the same reason: it places Israel’s conduct inside the framework of European antisemitism law. Italy, under Meloni, has now chosen a side in that argument.

Vote on the antisemitism law, Italian Chamber of Deputies Count
Votes in favor 147
Votes against 93
Abstentions (center-left Democratic Party) 5
Reported antisemitic incidents, 2022–2025 Nearly quadrupled

What happens next is largely up to implementation. The national strategy must be written, the coordinator appointed, the monitoring rolled out — all under a definition the opposition has already branded as censorship.

The government says no one will be silenced for criticizing Israel. Bonelli and his allies say the law exists precisely to do that. One of them will be proven right in practice, and no vote on Tuesday evening settled which.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

US War Secretary Hegseth to Meet Colombia Minister, Hand Over First C-130 Hércules