Italy’s highest court upheld a life sentence for former ophthalmologist Giampaolo Amato on Wednesday, ending a five-year legal battle over the poisoning deaths of his wife and mother-in-law in Bologna.
The Court of Cassation’s first criminal section rejected the defense appeal after nearly seven hours of deliberation, confirming convictions handed down in two prior trials.
Prosecutors argued Amato, 67, used his medical access to administer a lethal combination of sevoflurane and midazolam — an inhaled anesthetic and a benzodiazepine sedative — to eliminate obstacles to a new relationship and secure his inheritance rights. ANSA reported the ruling finalizes the “ergastolo” sentence Amato has been serving since 2023.
Prosecutors framed mother-in-law’s death as rehearsal
Giulia Tateo, 87, was found dead on October 9, 2021, according to Ansa. Investigators later characterized the event as a “prova generale” — a dress rehearsal — for the killing of Amato’s wife, Isabella Linsalata, a 62-year-old gynecologist, who died in the night between October 30 and 31, 2021, according to Sky.
Both women died at the family home in Bologna. Autopsy findings and toxicological analysis detected the anesthetic agents in biological samples, forming the core of the circumstantial case.

Drug access and pharmacological mechanism central to case
Amato’s status as a practicing ophthalmologist and former team doctor for the Virtus Bologna basketball club granted him professional access to controlled substances. Sevoflurane, a volatile halogenated ether used for induction and maintenance of general anesthesia, requires specialized vaporizers and scavenging systems typically restricted to operating rooms.
Midazolam, a short-acting benzodiazepine, is a Schedule IV controlled substance used for sedation and anxiolysis. The prosecution contended Amato diverted these agents and exploited their synergistic respiratory depressant effects — sevoflurane’s rapid onset via inhalation combined with midazolam’s potentiation of GABAergic inhibition — to cause death without macroscopic trauma.
Sevoflurane and midazolam lethal outside clinical settings
- Sevoflurane and midazolam are legitimate, life-saving anesthetic drugs when administered by trained professionals in monitored settings.
- Outside a clinical environment, their combined respiratory depressant effects are lethal and difficult to detect without targeted toxicology.
- Diversion of controlled anesthetic agents by healthcare workers is a recognized patient safety and drug security risk globally.
Appellate judges cited “granitic” circumstantial evidence
The Bologna Court of Assizes of Appeal described the evidentiary framework as “granitico” — granitic — emphasizing the premeditated and calculated nature of the acts. Judges wrote the murders were “dictated exclusively by selfish motivations, defining a personality trait devoid of humanly or ethically understandable profiles.”
The ruling identified a dual motive: the desire to freely pursue a relationship with a younger woman and the financial imperative to inherit Linsalata’s substantial estate before a potential divorce settlement could diminish his share. Sky TG24 reported the prosecution argued Amato sought to “close his past, eliminating those who could represent an obstacle.”
Son maintains innocence claim despite final verdict
Nicola Amato, the couple’s son and also a physician, defended his father on the eve of the Cassation hearing. In an interview with la Repubblica, he stated his father “is innocent because there is no direct evidence against him and the case should not be closed.”
He added that he and his sister “have not been subjugated” by their father. The defense, led by prominent attorneys Franco Coppi and Valerio Spigarelli, had argued the toxicological findings were insufficient to prove homicide beyond a reasonable doubt, suggesting alternative medical explanations for the deaths.
Bologna, the capital of Emilia-Romagna and Italy’s seventh-largest city with 391,473 inhabitants, is home to the University of Bologna, established in AD 1088 as the oldest university in continuous operation. The city’s well-preserved historical centre, famous for its lengthy porticoes, was recognized as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2021.
Deputy prosecutor called prior ruling “unassailable”
Deputy Prosecutor General Simone Perelli, in his closing requisition, defined the appealed sentence as “inattaccabile” — unassailable. “The trial judges ascertained the criminal responsibility of the defendant beyond any reasonable doubt,” Perelli told the court. The Cassation’s rejection of the appeal exhausts all ordinary judicial remedies. Amato remains incarcerated.
Contraindications for sevoflurane and midazolam use
- Sevoflurane: Contraindicated in patients with known susceptibility to malignant hyperthermia or hypersensitivity to halogenated anesthetics. Must only be administered in facilities equipped for general anesthesia, including mechanical ventilation and cardiovascular monitoring.
- Midazolam: Contraindicated in acute narrow-angle glaucoma (relative to ophthalmology practice) and severe respiratory depression. Requires dose adjustment in renal/hepatic impairment and extreme caution with opioids or alcohol due to synergistic CNS depression.
- Immediate medical attention: Any suspected exposure to anesthetic gases outside a clinical setting, or unexplained profound sedation/respiratory arrest in a household contact of healthcare workers with drug access, warrants emergency services activation (112 in Italy / 911 in US).
| Agent | Class | Primary Clinical Use | Key Risk in Diversion Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sevoflurane | Volatile Inhalational Anesthetic | Induction/Maintenance of General Anesthesia | Rapid unconsciousness; requires vaporizer; lethal hypoxia risk without airway management |
| Midazolam | Benzodiazepine (Schedule IV) | Procedural Sedation, Anxiolysis, ICU Sedation | Respiratory depression; potentiates other sedatives; amnesia effects |
| Combination | Adjunctive Anesthesia Protocol | Balanced Anesthesia (Controlled Setting) | Synergistic respiratory arrest; difficult post-mortem detection without specific toxicology panel |
References
- Sky TG24. “Bologna, uccise moglie e suocera: ergastolo definitivo per il medico Giampaolo Amato.” 2026.
- ANSA. “Uccise moglie e suocera, ergastolo definitivo per Amato.” November 19, 2026.
- Italian Court of Cassation, First Criminal Section. Judgment No. Record Number Pending Publication, November 19, 2026.
- Bologna Court of Assizes of Appeal. Sentencing Motivation, Date of Appeal Ruling.