In a column for The Atlantic published this week, a self-described lifelong Bond reader argues that Robert Pattinson is the wrong choice for James Bond — days after Jeff Bezos said he was “heavily involved” in selecting the new 007.
The column, headlined “A Moody Vampire Makes a Bad James Bond,” appeared as the casting continued to divide fans and critics. Pattinson, 40, was announced as the seventh actor to play Bond on Nov. 16, with Denis Villeneuve attached to direct for Amazon MGM Studios, Fox News reported.
if you have a job rn that’s because Rob Pattinson doesn’t want it😭
The Atlantic’s author, who says he has read the Ian Fleming novels closely enough to know Bond’s full name, Miles Messervy, and his maid May’s breakfast menu, puts his objection bluntly. “James Bond is a friend of mine. And Robert Pattinson, you are no James Bond,” he writes.
Not everyone agrees. A counter-column in the Toronto Star argues Pattinson is exactly “the Bond we need now,” urging readers to ignore the naysayers. The split opinion pages capture a fandom still processing the end of Daniel Craig’s 15-year reign as 007.
no hace falta que vengais al KFC a hacer entrevistas de trabajo. Ya se llevó todos los puestos el Robert Pattinson. Incluido el mio.
Bezos Reviewed Finalists Before Pattinson Casting
- Bezos says he personally reviewed screen tests of five finalists before approving Pattinson, The Guardian reported.
- The Atlantic’s column calls the casting a mistake; the Toronto Star’s says Pattinson is the right Bond for now.
- Page Six, citing Puck News, reports Pattinson negotiated a shorter commitment — three films — than rivals Jack Lowden and Josh O’Connor, who were reportedly asked for four.
Bezos Picked His Bond in Person
The Guardian reported that Bezos, speaking at Semafor’s Silicon Valley & The World event, described an unusually hands-on casting process for a man who runs a company worth more than most film studios combined. Amazon paid more than $1bn last year for creative control of the franchise, after acquiring MGM in an $8.5bn purchase in 2022.
“There was a big group initially, and we down-selected to five finalists. We did real, old-fashioned screen tests of those five finalists,” Bezos said. He said he and Villeneuve were initially biased against Pattinson because they wanted an unknown, but the tests settled the question. “But in the screen tests, it was so obvious he is James Bond,” he said.
.@JeffBezos tells @lizrhoffman he was "heavily involved" in selecting Robert Pattinson as the next James Bond. "Initially, we were slightly biased against him just because he's already so famous … but in the screen tests, it was so obvious he is James Bond." pic.twitter.com/1ro4R8meYO
The catch: the man Bezos picked already has a day job as another iconic character. Pattinson plays Batman, and Page Six, citing Puck News sources, reports that production delays on “The Batman: Part II” may make that film his “last turn in the cape and cowl.”
Three Films Versus Four
The contract details, as reported by Page Six citing Puck News, explain at least part of why Pattinson won. His test deal “was so difficult to close,” sources told Puck News, suggesting Amazon MGM would not have bothered unless he was the top pick.
Shaun the Sheep has parodied the Robert Pattinson as James Bond casting reveal. pic.twitter.com/qMtvSPrRV5
| Actor | Age | Reported film commitment |
|---|---|---|
| Robert Pattinson | 40 | Three films |
| Jack Lowden | 36 | Four films |
| Josh O’Connor | 36 | Four films |
Page Six also reports Pattinson was offered significantly more money than Lowden or O’Connor, and had already worked with Villeneuve. O’Connor screen-tested for the role, according to Page Six; People.com reports Nicholas Hoult also screen-tested in early November, having previously lost the Batman role to Pattinson in 2022.
The Case Against the Moody Vampire
The Atlantic’s author traces his argument through the franchise’s casting history, crediting Sean Connery’s violent physicality, calling Timothy Dalton an underappreciated Shakespearean, and noting Roger Moore “was a decent Bond, but stayed with the role too long.” He even takes aim at Craig, arguing the series “went off the rails” when the scripts turned Bond into “a brawler with deep, complicated feelings.”

His worry about Pattinson is tonal. “I imagine that when the mad criminal offers him a mint julep, Pattinson will scowl and explain that alcohol and sugar are bad for you,” he writes. The column rests on the author’s own admission that he has not seen much of Pattinson’s work, and he frames his piece explicitly as opinion.
Fox News contributor Raymond Arroyo made a similar case to Fox News Digital, saying that as a fan of the Fleming novels, “Pattinson isn’t quite what I envisioned or what I think fans were hoping for.”
Florence Pugh sent a text to Denis Villeneuve after Robert Pattinson was cast as James Bond: “Congratulations on finding your Bond. Nice catch. Any villains with the size of 5'4, female…?” pic.twitter.com/uv4iNRmnt2
The Case for Pattinson
The Toronto Star’s column argues the opposite: that the naysayers are misreading both the actor and the moment. The piece positions Pattinson’s post-Twilight career — The Lost City of Z, Tenet, The Batman — as evidence he can carry a franchise without being consumed by it.
Villeneuve, for his part, has publicly committed to the choice. “I am overjoyed to welcome Robert Pattinson as our new James Bond. He has the timeless soul of 007 and brings a spirit that is completely new. I cannot wait to begin,” the director said in a statement quoted by Fox News.
Jeff Bezos says it was “obvious” Robert Pattinson was the right choice to play James Bond after his screen tests: “We ran a really tight process and made the final decision on Friday. There was a big group initially and we down-selected to five finalists. We did real,… pic.twitter.com/YBGyZ8HhL8”
Pattinson called the role “the honor of a lifetime” in a statement released Monday, Fox News reported. Villeneuve told GQ Magazine in a November 2026 interview, per Page Six, that the pressure is real: “We cannot f–k it up. We do not have the choice.”
Why the Fight Matters Beyond the Fandom
The backlash and the memes tell the same story from different angles. Yahoo reported that social media users joked Pattinson is taking “every job on the planet,” with KFC Spain, NFL teams and the Lakers all drafted into the bit. One X user put it this way: “If you have job rn it’s because Robert Pattinson doesn’t want it.”
Underneath the jokes sits a genuine industry question: what Amazon plans to do with Bond. The Guardian notes fans and film critics have speculated the company may build a Marvel-style universe of spinoffs, a prospect that worried many when the creative-control deal was struck.
Casting a 40-year-old established star, rather than an unknown who could be locked into a decade of sequels, cuts against that read — as does the shorter contract Page Six reports.
Whether the Atlantic’s skepticism or the Toronto Star’s enthusiasm ages better will be settled on screen, not on opinion pages. Pierce Brosnan has already predicted fans will be “blown away,” according to Fox News. As Arroyo put it to Fox News Digital: “We’ll see if audiences wish this new Bond to ‘Live or Let Die.'”
More on Jeff Bezos
Jeff Bezos Says He Was ‘Heavily Involved’ In Robert Pattinson’s Casting As James Bondhttps://t.co/c9I89cttmA pic.twitter.com/nRKVPyxMi2
JUST IN: Jeff Bezos reveals he was “heavily involved” in casting Robert Pattinson as the next James Bond for Amazon MGM’s upcoming 007 film. pic.twitter.com/iGm9CJy0kN