Cape Town Seller Loses R3m Court Bid Over 1965 Mercedes-Benz Defects

A Cape Town seller who demanded R3 million plus interest for a 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600 has lost his Western Cape High Court bid after a judge found the buyer was entitled to cancel the sale because the car was not delivered in the condition in which it had been inspected.

Acting Judge TJ Mgengwana dismissed the application and ordered the seller to pay the costs.

The ruling, reported by IOL, ends a dispute between seller Geoffrey Leighton Ashmead and buyer Herman-Bosman Brand. Ashmead had asked the court to declare the sale agreement valid and binding and to order Brand to pay the R3 million purchase price, together with interest at 11.25% from May 29, 2025.

The judge refused. His reasoning turns on a single contractual promise — that the vehicle be delivered as inspected — and on WhatsApp messages that undercut the seller’s version of events.

The Bottom Line

  • The Western Cape High Court found Ashmead breached an express term of the sale agreement by failing to deliver the Mercedes-Benz 600 in its inspected condition.
  • The court held the “no warranties” clause did not protect the seller, because the buyer relied on an express delivery obligation.

How a R3.5 million asking price became a R3 million fight

The dispute dates back to October 2024, when Ashmead approached car dealer Dean Knoep to sell his 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600 for R3.5 million, IOL reported. Knoep introduced Brand as a potential buyer. After inspecting and test-driving the vehicle, Brand offered R3 million.

The parties signed a written sale agreement on April 22, 2025. Payment was to be made into Ashmead’s bank account against the signing and delivery of transfer documents together with the vehicle.

Cape Town Seller Loses R3m Court Bid Over 1965 Mercedes-Benz Defects
Photo: globeverge.com

The contract stated the car was sold without warranties and in the condition in which it had originally been inspected. It also required Ashmead to deliver the vehicle in that same condition, and to arrange a mechanical report through Central Garage, which had serviced the car for years.

The defects that surfaced in May 2025

Brand inspected the vehicle again in May 2025 and, according to his account, found problems he said had not been present earlier.

Among these, the front air vent below the windscreen refused to shut, oil could be seen leaking beneath the car, none of the windows would open or shut, the car appeared to ride unusually low due to what he believed was a suspension fault, and the boot lid would not shut as it should.

He argued the presence of these defects indicated faults in the vehicle’s hydraulic, pneumatic and air suspension systems.

Brand raised the concerns with Knoep in WhatsApp messages between May 12 and 13, 2025. The vehicle was collected, returned to Central Garage for repairs, and delivered back to Brand on May 28. When Brand inspected it the next day, he said the same defects remained. He cancelled the agreement, arguing Ashmead had materially breached the contract.

Why the roadworthy certificate did not help the seller

Ashmead rejected the cancellation. He argued he had fulfilled his obligations, that a car of roughly 60 years had never been represented as being in showroom condition, and that Brand had known of earlier defects through a snag list compiled before the transaction. His team also pointed out the vehicle had passed its roadworthy test on May 26, 2025, and had been registered.

Judge Mgengwana was not persuaded. A roadworthy certificate, he explained, confirms only compliance with minimum statutory safety requirements. It does not certify that every mechanical component works correctly.

The correspondence did more damage. The judge said that correspondence indicated a proposal to return the vehicle to Central Garage to attend to the front air vent and address a suspension leak so it could be restored to the condition in which Brand had originally agreed to purchase it. The judge said this correspondence undermined the argument that the buyer’s complaints were fabricated.

The snag list that arrived too late

The snag list was the seller’s second problem, and it was procedural as much as factual. The court found the list and several other allegations had been introduced for the first time in Ashmead’s replying affidavit. An applicant in motion proceedings, the judge held, must make out their case in the founding affidavit and cannot present a new or improved case in reply.

The document itself also cut both ways. Dated December 6, 2023, it was compiled more than 10 months before Brand’s initial inspection, so it could not establish the car’s condition in October 2024 or at delivery in May 2025. It listed troubles — a hydraulic fluid leak, a suspension control that was inoperative, and a hydraulic vent flap that could open but would not shut — matching the complaints Brand would later raise.

The clause that could not override the contract

Ashmead’s final argument was the no-warranties clause. The judge rejected it on narrow, contractual grounds. Brand was not relying on an implied warranty against latent defects; he was relying on an express obligation to deliver the vehicle as inspected. The clause did not remove the seller’s duty to comply with that specific term.

The court accepted Brand’s version of the vehicle’s condition at the original inspection, found Ashmead had breached the express terms of the agreement, and held Brand was entitled to cancel on May 29, 2025. The application was dismissed with costs.

Ashmead has been ordered to pay the costs.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Deep-Sea Mining Targets Hide Unique Microbial Ecosystems, Study Warns

DP World Tour Signs 9 ex-LIV Golfers for 2027; DeChambeau Takes Category 1 Membership