US Floated Ukraine Ceding Donbas for NATO Membership, Zelensky Says

US negotiators have asked whether Ukraine would give up Donbas in exchange for joining NATO, President Volodymyr Zelensky said on Saturday — the first time the question has been raised.

“The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?’ This was the first time this had been raised,” Zelensky told reporters, according to remarks released by his office. Zelensky made the comments after US envoys visited Moscow and an EU summit in Dublin as part of ongoing efforts to end the fighting.

The stakes could hardly be higher. Kyiv has sought NATO membership as a condition of any peace deal to deter future Russian attacks, while Moscow has called another alliance member on its border unacceptable — a grievance Putin cited in launching the full-scale invasion in 2022.

Zelensky also said the proposal made him believe that “NATO is back on the agenda,” though he cautioned: “You have also heard Putin’s signals, and this is an extremely difficult conversation.”

US has floated Ukraine ceding Donbas for Nato membership — Rewire Your Life Daily

A referendum — but only with specifics

Zelensky stopped short of accepting any land swap. He said Ukraine would not give up sovereign territory, but that a comprehensive package could change the calculus — security guarantees, no constraints on Ukraine’s military, and funds to rebuild the country.

If the Americans confirmed such terms “together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks: do we accept it or not?” he said. “I have no right to make that decision on my own. But we need specifics, and we don’t have them yet.”

He told US negotiators that protections modeled on NATO’s Article 5 collective defense provision — an attack on one member treated as an attack on all — would be the “absolute minimum” Ukraine could accept.

Here lies the proposal’s central weakness. Bringing a new country into the alliance requires unanimous consent from every existing member, a point former US Ambassador to Ukraine William Taylor pressed in an interview with CNN’s Jessica Dean.

“Every NATO member state has a say. Most would agree. There may be, however, a couple of nation member states in NATO who would not agree,” Taylor said. “So it’s not a firm offer at this point.”

Shuttle diplomacy spanned three capitals

The question emerged from a burst of shuttle diplomacy. Kushner and Witkoff mediated two days of US-brokered talks between Ukrainian and Russian officials in Abu Dhabi on Tuesday and Wednesday — the first direct talks between the parties in months. The rounds ended without a breakthrough, though Zelensky said the sides agreed in principle to a prisoner exchange involving more than 1,000 people, with final numbers still under discussion.

The envoys then met Putin in Moscow on Thursday — where they had pledged to raise an energy ceasefire, Zelensky said, though no progress was reported — before flying to Ireland to meet Zelensky the same day.

Kushner acknowledged on social media Saturday that “several new ideas emerged from these discussions and are now being explored,” without addressing the NATO-for-territory proposal directly. “NATO will remain a critical pillar of European security,” he wrote, adding that President Trump would “only support arrangements that strengthen Ukraine’s and Europe’s security.”

One concrete sign of movement did emerge: Zelensky said US negotiators told him all sides had agreed to give Europe a seat at the negotiating table in forthcoming peace talks.

European delegates attended the Abu Dhabi meetings but did not sit at the table with Russia — a sidelining that has persisted for nearly two years even as Europe became Ukraine’s largest financial and military backer. At the Dublin summit, EU leaders agreed their team for any peace talks would comprise Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland, along with EU officials.

US Floated Ukraine Ceding Donbas for NATO Membership, Zelensky Says
Photo: cnn.com

Moscow’s position hasn’t budged

Any optimism should be weighed against what Russia is actually saying. Kremlin comments suggest Moscow’s demands — territorial concessions, limits on the size of Ukraine’s military, and guaranteed neutrality — continue to far exceed what Kyiv is prepared to consider. Ukraine has rejected those constraints, arguing they would leave it unable to repel any future invasion.

Zelensky also dismissed Putin’s call for a broad agreement on European security architecture before the war’s specifics are settled — a framework he suggested was a Russian ploy to redistribute influence across the continent.

“We cannot turn everything upside down and start by talking about changing the security framework in the world or across the continent overall, and only then talk about ending this war,” he said. “This war must be ended first.”

He was equally blunt about Putin’s suggested humanitarian ceasefire in Kostiantynivka, a contested city in Donetsk: “Putin simply wants us to leave Kostiantynivka so that they can move in and occupy the entire city that way.” Ukraine has proposed seven or eight other frontline settlements for humanitarian truces, he said; Russia, he claimed, prefers to use them as military targets. Moscow denies deliberately targeting civilians.

Why ceding Donbas cuts so deep

Russia occupies roughly a fifth of Ukrainian territory, including most of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions that make up the Donbas. Formally ceding the small portions Ukraine still controls would be a modest concession in practical terms — Moscow’s grinding ground offensive there has largely stalled. But it would carry enormous symbolic weight: it would amount to Ukraine accepting, on paper, that the Donbas is Russian.

US has floated Ukraine ceding Donbas for Nato membership, Zelensky says — Frontion News
What each side demands Position
United States (floated idea) Ukraine withdraws from remaining Donbas territory in exchange for NATO membership
Ukraine No territorial concessions; NATO-style Article 5 guarantees as the “absolute minimum”; no limits on its military
Russia Territorial concessions, a capped Ukrainian military, guaranteed neutrality — and historically, no NATO membership

There has been at least one recent proof that deals are possible: last month, Melania Trump brokered a temporary ceasefire in the Russian-occupied city of Oleshky to allow evacuations and aid deliveries. Whether that spirit can scale up to a map and an alliance treaty is another matter entirely.

The next test comes quickly: any formal proposal would head straight to a Ukrainian referendum, and Zelensky has made clear he will not bring one until the Americans put specifics on the table. “But we need specifics, and we don’t have them yet,” he said.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Blood Eosinophil Counts as Predictive Biomarkers for Inhaled Corticosteroid Response in Non-Cystic Fibrosis Bronchiectasis: A Systematic Review

Deep-Sea Mining Targets Hide Unique Microbial Ecosystems, Study Warns