Judge Acquits Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in $25M Ethereum Case

Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, former MIT students charged with a $25 million cryptocurrency heist, have been acquitted by US District Judge Jessica Clarke.

The decision, delivered one year after a mistrial, effectively ends the government’s attempt to prosecute the brothers for a sophisticated scheme that drained funds from the Ethereum blockchain in approximately 12 seconds.

The case hinged on whether the brothers’ actions constituted wire fraud under existing federal statutes. While prosecutors argued the pair manipulated blockchain transaction validation processes to siphon assets, Judge Clarke determined the government failed to meet the necessary legal threshold.

“The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” the judge said in her written decision. “It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the Government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case.”

The alleged scheme, which federal investigators detailed in their original indictment, targeted the Maximum Extractable Value (MEV) ecosystem. Prosecutors claimed the brothers exploited a vulnerability in the MEV-Boost relay code, which is designed to allow validators to outsource block construction. By forcing the relay to release the full content of a proposed block prematurely, the brothers allegedly reordered transactions to their advantage, effectively front-running victim traders.

Newsmax.com - Breaking news from around the globe
Photo: newsmax.com

The brothers reportedly began studying their victims’ trading behaviors in December 2022, deploying “bait transactions” to identify high-value targets before executing the exploit. They were arrested in Boston and New York in May 2024, facing charges of wire fraud and money laundering that carried a potential 20-year prison sentence per count.

Judge Clarke’s ruling focused on the absence of “material misrepresentations.” In standard wire fraud cases, the government must prove the defendant deceived a victim to obtain money or property. Because the brothers utilized the blockchain’s own protocols to reorder transactions—rather than lying to the victims directly—the court found the government’s theory of fraud insufficient.

Newsmax reported that the acquittal follows a previous mistrial where jurors were unable to reach a consensus on the charges. The defense successfully argued that the brothers’ actions, while aggressive, did not fit the traditional definition of wire fraud. The prosecution’s case was built on the premise that the brothers hid their identities and moved stolen proceeds through multiple exchanges and shell companies to obscure the source of the funds.

While the Peraire-Bueno brothers walk free, the case involves a scheme that exploited a bug in the Ethereum blockchain.

Photo of author

Sophie Lin - Technology Editor

Sophie is a tech innovator and acclaimed tech writer recognized by the Online News Association. She translates the fast-paced world of technology, AI, and digital trends into compelling stories for readers of all backgrounds.

How Evanescent Interactions With Strangers Foster Belonging

Ukraine Hits Kerch Bridge With Unprecedented Missile and Drone Attack