Karen Read saw a central part of her civil litigation pared back this week as a Massachusetts judge dismissed her conspiracy claim against the town of Canton, NBC Boston reported.
- Plymouth Superior Court Judge Mark Gildea dismissed Read’s civil conspiracy claim against Canton on Monday, November 16, 2026.
- The judge allowed her negligence claim against the town to move forward, rejecting town arguments over deadlines and notice.
- Read previously agreed to a $100,000 judgment with the Massachusetts State Police earlier this month.
Judge Mark Gildea Dismisses Conspiracy Claim
Plymouth Superior Court Judge Mark Gildea allowed the town’s motion to dismiss Read’s claim that the Canton Police Department conspired with the Massachusetts State Police to steer the death investigation toward her, NBC Boston reported.
Read’s lawsuit alleged that local police conspired to direct the investigation away from the group of people inside the home where Boston police Officer John O’Keefe’s body was found outside in January 2022, according to masslive.com.
To support those allegations, Read’s complaint included text messages exchanged between former State Police Trooper Michael Proctor and former Canton police Sgt. Sean Goode, masslive.com reported. Judge Gildea determined that the conspiracy claim conflicted with the Massachusetts Tort Claims Act, which largely protects public employers from intentional wrongdoing committed by employees, masslive.com noted.
Read’s lawyers argued that carelessness by the departments, rather than a deliberate act, led them to direct the investigation toward her, masslive.com explained. Gildea rejected that reasoning in his ruling.
“Read’s argument confuses the very nature of a conspiracy,” Gildea wrote, stating that he could find no examples in state law where a civil conspiracy claim was based on negligent conduct, according to NBC Boston. “The nature of a civil conspiracy claim involves intentional acts. Therefore, the claim cannot be asserted against the Town,” Gildea wrote, according to masslive.com and police1.com.

Negligence Claims Move Forward in Canton Lawsuit
While the conspiracy count fell, Gildea upheld the portion of Read’s suit accusing the Canton Police Department of negligence, denying the town’s motion to dismiss that claim, masslive.com reported. Read accused the town of negligence in its hiring, training, supervision, and retention of officers, alongside failures in enforcing policies to safeguard evidence and prevent discrimination, according to masslive.com.
Canton argued that the three-year statute of limitations should have started on Feb. 2, 2022, the date of Read’s arraignment, masslive.com reported. The town also argued that a presentment letter received in November 2025 was untimely and failed to properly notify it of the legal bases for the claims, masslive.com stated.
Gildea dismissed both arguments, noting Read’s filing indicated she was not aware of much of the underlying evidence until after her criminal acquittal, masslive.com reported.

“The letter … makes clear that the basis of the negligence claim is the Town’s actions with respect to its employees,” Gildea wrote, according to masslive.com and police1.com. Read filed the civil lawsuit in June 2025 and amended it in March 2026, NBC Boston reported.
State Police Settlement and Legal Timeline
Earlier this month, the Massachusetts State Police accepted a judgment of $100,000 in the case while maintaining that much of what Read claimed was required to be dismissed, NBC Boston reported. “to avoid somewhat duplicative and inefficient litigation” in other courts, Read's team said, according to NBC Boston.
Under the Massachusetts Tort Claims Act, a public employer cannot pay more than $100,000 on a negligence claim, leaving that settlement at the statutory limit, masslegalresources.com noted.
The litigation against the police departments follows a criminal trial where a jury acquitted Read of charges connected to O’Keefe’s death, while convicting her on the lowest form of a drunken driving charge for which she received probation, NBC Boston reported. Additional civil litigation involving Read includes a wrongful death lawsuit filed against her by O’Keefe’s estate, according to NBC Boston.