Judge Refuses to Halt Ruling That LA Top Federal Prosecutor Is Serving Unlawfully

Federal judge J. Michael Seabright refused on Monday to halt a ruling finding that Los Angeles federal prosecutor Bill Essayli is serving unlawfully, clearing the path for his removal from two criminal cases next week.

Judge Bars Bill Essayli from Supervising Criminal Prosecutions

  • Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright ordered that Bill Essayli can no longer supervise or participate in two specific criminal prosecutions.
  • The Justice Department stated in a court filing that the legal issue potentially affects 5,000 cases in the district.
  • The Trump administration appealed the decision to the 9th Circuit and asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review a similar Nevada case.

Federal Judge Rejects Delay Request

Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright delivered his decision on Monday, declining to halt an earlier October order that found the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles is operating as a de facto U.S. attorney without proper Senate confirmation. The order is set to take effect next Monday unless a higher court intervenes, removing Essayli from overseeing two criminal prosecutions that sparked the initial challenge.

In his ruling, Seabright said that the government failed to identify any specific harm it would suffer once the order takes effect. He added that the Justice Department’s appeal to the 9th Circuit demonstrated a low likelihood of success.

The Los Angeles Times reported that the Justice Department claimed in a filing last week that the appointment dispute potentially affects 5,000 cases across the district, though Seabright dismissed that assertion as a bald assertion made without support or explanation.

Bill Essayli defiant after judge rules he is ‘unlawfully’ serving — NBCLA

Challenging Unconfirmed Prosecutors

The controversy stems from the Trump administration’s strategy to install loyalists to lead U.S. attorney’s offices without going through the mandatory Senate confirmation process. Essayli was sworn in as interim U.S. attorney in April 2025. When he reached the 120-day limit for that role, he resigned, and then-Attorney General Pam Bondi appointed him as a special attorney while designating him as first assistant.

Seabright previously ruled that Essayli was not lawfully serving as acting U.S. attorney but initially permitted him to keep supervising prosecutions through his other titles. However, a subsequent 9th Circuit ruling regarding the leadership of the U.S. attorney’s office in Nevada prompted Seabright to reconsider.

That appellate panel ruled that the Department of Justice cannot keep an unconfirmed official in charge simply by altering their title and granting them full departmental powers.

Judge Refuses to Halt Ruling That LA Top Federal Prosecutor Is Serving Unlawfully
Photo: washingtonpost.com

Broader Legal Vulnerabilities

Legal experts suggest the ruling opens the door for widespread challenges to prosecutions handled or overseen by Essayli. Laurie Levenson, a professor of law at Loyola Law School and a former federal prosecutor, highlighted the expanding legal exposure.

“There’s no downside in every lawyer saying that Essayli was not properly appointed and therefore he should not be able to sign off or supervise my case.”

“The question is, what risk does the Department of Justice want to take, that they’re leaving in place somebody that the court has already found was not properly appointed and therefore should not be supervising cases?”

The U.S. attorney’s office in Los Angeles did not immediately respond to a request for comment. “will be decided by the Supreme Court,” Essayli previously said.

Judge Rules LA's Top Prosecutor Is Serving Unlawfully — Essayli Disqualified — DC Scoop

High-Profile Cases and Supreme Court Uncertainty

While in office, Essayli utilized his authority to initiate criminal proceedings against activists, protesters, and immigrants, while simultaneously dismissing actions connected to administration supporters. His office also supported lawsuits challenging California’s transgender and environmental policies, and targeted state officials over alleged voter fraud by seeking to set aside thousands of ballots before the November 3 election.

The Trump administration has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to evaluate the Nevada-based 9th Circuit ruling, contending that federal statutes allow the attorney general to transfer a vacant office’s responsibilities and appoint a new first assistant to act as its head. The Supreme Court has not yet indicated whether it will take up the case.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Alexandra Hartman Editor-in-Chief

Editor-in-Chief Prize-winning journalist with over 20 years of international news experience. Alexandra leads the editorial team, ensuring every story meets the highest standards of accuracy and journalistic integrity.

Former Ambassadors Say Canada-U.S. Trade Deal Possible but Tariffs May Stay