Judge ruled in favor of RJ Godfrey in his 5th-year eligibility case against the Arizona Board of Regents.
RJ Godfrey is eligible to play for Arizona again — and his season debut could come Wednesday night against third-ranked UConn.
A Pima County Superior Court judge on Tuesday granted the transfer forward a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, clearing the way for the 12th-ranked Wildcats to add him to the roster for the first time this season.
Judge Jeffrey Bergin’s ruling came in the lawsuit Godfrey filed Nov. 5 against the Arizona Board of Regents, which he accused of breaching its contract with him by refusing to certify his eligibility under the NCAA’s own manual. The written order is expected to formally require the Board of Regents and the university to certify Godfrey’s eligibility, according to reporting by Yahoo Sports.
“RJ is such a good individual, and he’s deserving of this opportunity,” Arizona coach Tommy Lloyd said afterward, per Yahoo Sports. “And this is a kind of a great step forward.”

The stakes are immediate: Arizona (No. 12 in the AP rankings cited by the reports) hosts No. 3 UConn on Wednesday night at ALKEME Arena at McKale Center, and Godfrey — a Clemson transfer expected to be a starting power forward — has missed games while his case wound through courts in two states.
A contract argument, not an NCAA fight
Unlike other athletes who have challenged the NCAA directly over its new eligibility rules, Godfrey sued the Arizona Board of Regents, citing breach of contract for not following the NCAA manual on eligibility certification.
Bergin said his ruling “is not and cannot” rest on Godfrey’s value to the team but was based entirely on contract law, according to the Arizona Daily Star. The judge said the NCAA Manual “likely constitutes a contractual framework” between the university and the NCAA, and that Arizona law favors enforcing contracts according to their “plain terms.”
At the heart of the dispute is the NCAA’s “5 for 5” eligibility model, established under Bylaw 12.6 of the 2026-27 manual published in August. Bergin found nothing in that manual prevents Godfrey from being eligible.
The NCAA, however, has publicly stated the rule doesn’t apply to athletes who began college in fall 2022 and had used four years of eligibility entering 2026-27 — a position that contradicts what the manual itself says, as Yahoo Sports reported. That discrepancy has fueled a wave of similar legal wins, including many players across the Big 12 Conference.
NEWS: RJ Godfrey has been GRANTED a preliminary injunction by a judge in Pima County and is now eligible to play for Arizona, per @BrucePascoe pic.twitter.com/7HZrtZgAYp
Godfrey’s attorneys, Ryan Downton and Ali Farhang, told the court that of the 22 “5 for 5” players spread across 13 Big 12 teams, Godfrey was the only one not eligible. They also said that Arizona’s win at Auburn last Friday came against a team with multiple players eligible through their own legal victories.
Downton pressed the contract argument with a basketball analogy, asking Arizona guard Derek Dixon whether a referee could arbitrarily change the three-point line midgame. “No, it can’t,” Dixon replied, according to the Daily Star. “The NCAA’s essentially the referee for college sports… its manual is the rule book for NCAA eligibility,” Downton argued.

Teammates testify, university stands aside
Godfrey, Lloyd, Dixon and teammate Ivan Kharchenkov all testified on his behalf. Kharchenkov said he has been playing too many minutes, and out of position, in Godfrey’s absence. Lloyd told the court Godfrey would have made a “significant difference” in Arizona’s 84-75 loss to UCLA on Nov. 2, and said Godfrey was recruited to be the starting power forward rather than a player who would take opportunities from younger teammates.
The university’s own posture was notable. The Board of Regents’ two attorneys asked no questions and made only a brief statement signaling support for Godfrey’s case. Athletic director Desiree Reed-Francois, who was subpoenaed, did not appear but submitted an affidavit in support of Godfrey that was read into the record, per Yahoo Sports. Nearly the entire men’s basketball team attended the hearing.
RJ Godfrey is suing Arizona Board of Regents for his eligibility: "This action asserts a single claim, for breach of contract, against a single defendant. Godfrey does not sue the NCAA and seeks no relief against it. He seeks only an order requiring the University to perform its… pic.twitter.com/rnuG8AHvuW”
“It just reminds me of what great guys we have and what a great culture that we have in our program and just how special it is to be at Arizona basketball,” Lloyd said, per Yahoo Sports.
How Godfrey got here
Godfrey played four college seasons — three at Clemson and one at Georgia — before joining Arizona. A judge in Georgia granted an injunction clearing him and several other athletes to play this season under the NCAA’s new eligibility rules, but the Georgia Court of Appeals then granted the NCAA a stay, leaving his status in limbo. That prompted the Nov. 5 lawsuit in Tucson seeking a permanent injunction.
Even with Tuesday’s win, his availability against UConn isn’t guaranteed. The NCAA was not named in the lawsuit but could still attempt an appeal or pursue a suspension tied to Godfrey’s participation in an All-Star game during the Final Four and his signing with an agent, Yahoo Sports reported.
Godfrey testified he was not paid to play in that game or by his agent, but received advanced compensation for training as he pursued a professional career before learning of a possible fifth year; he said he has since paid that money back. His attorneys’ fallback, if the NCAA goes the suspension route: that the Lithuania exhibitions, three preseason games and four regular-season contests he missed count as time served.
“I’m excited to kind of move forward,” Godfrey said, per Yahoo Sports.
The next checkpoint is Wednesday night at McKale Center, when Arizona hosts UConn — and when Godfrey, if certified in time, could play his first game as a Wildcat.