Judges Temporarily Block Trump’s D.C. Arch and Golf Course Plans, Orders Expire in Weeks

Two federal judges in Washington have temporarily blocked President Trump’s 250-foot memorial arch at Memorial Circle and the redevelopment of the East Potomac golf course, but both courts‘ orders expire within weeks — Dec. 3 for the arch, Nov. 28 for the park — leaving opponents of the projects pressed for time.

Judge Tanya Chutkan on Wednesday extended her temporary restraining order for two more weeks. She originally stepped in to block construction on the night of Nov. 5, moments after the arch received its final sign-off from the National Capital Planning Commission and National Park Service, with the Trump administration signaling that work was set to start right away.

Both judges gave the administration nothing more than a pause. Chutkan’s five-page order bars any “construction, excavation, demolition, land-disturbance, utility-installation, or roadway-closure activity, or any other construction-related activity” at Memorial Circle through Dec. 3.

“The judge’s order recognizes that the conditions that called for emergency relief two weeks ago remain unchanged,” Nick Sansone, the Public Citizen attorney representing the original plaintiffs, said in a statement.

Chutkan blocks construction through Dec. 3; opponents rally

  • Chutkan’s arch block runs through Dec. 3; the East Potomac order expires Nov. 28, the Saturday after Thanksgiving.
  • Nine Kennedys, D.C., Virginia and a band of Vietnam War vets are all now part of the legal fight.
  • Some 700 public comments ahead of the fine arts commission review opposed the golf plan — all but three, per the commission’s secretary.

How the arch fight built its coalition

The lawsuit began earlier this year with Vietnam War veterans and an architectural historian. Toward the end of October, D.C. and Virginia brought a separate suit of their own, and the two cases were later merged. Last week, nine members of the Kennedy family joined, arguing the arch will cast shadows over the graves at Arlington National Cemetery and block historic sightlines.

Judge temporarily Blocks Trump’s DC golf course renovation — MS NOW

“This is one man who wants to build this arch. He’s violated every rule. If this is a great idea, then bring it before Congress, follow the rules and get it approved,” Max Kennedy, a son of Robert F. Kennedy, told NPR’s All Things Considered.

The administration’s legal theory leans on a century-old ghost. Congress authorized a pair of 166-foot columns at the same spot in 1925; they were never built, and the government argues the arch inherits that authorization. According to the plaintiffs, the project runs afoul of multiple statutes — among them the Commemorative Works Act and D.C.’s Height of Buildings Act — and cannot lawfully proceed without Congress signing off.

The national security wrinkle nobody planned for

Trump said in September the arch would double as a military complex. The plans approved this month contain no details to that effect. Ricky Buria, chief of staff to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, told the court that the agency is “currently in the planning process to determine how to integrate national defense uses … into the Arch without changing the existing plans for the Arch.”

Project Court order expires Key plaintiff demand
Memorial Circle arch Dec. 3 Preliminary injunction for lawsuit’s duration
East Potomac golf course Nov. 28 Extension to Dec. 12

Why the judge is under scrutiny

In the middle of October, attorneys for the government moved for Reyes to step aside from the case, alleging she harbored prejudice and animus. She denied that request on legal grounds.

The judge then launched a misconduct probe into whether officials and their attorneys had deceived the court regarding what they intended to do with the park. Government lawyers have pushed back, telling the court Thursday that such an inquiry is “not necessary.”

Federal judges have issued temporary restraining orders to block construction of Trump's arch and keep East Potomac Park
Photo: kpcw.org

Reyes wrote that “in its haste to meet an arbitrary deadline, the Government has likely violated at least the National Environmental Policy Act and the Administrative Procedure Act.”

Trump responded over the weekend on Truth Social, calling Reyes’s decision “highly destructive and political” and asking, “Why would a judge want to delay taking a terrible and very unsafe golf course, one that is mocked all over D.C.(and far beyond!), instead of quickly turning it into a great and admired one?”

Midterm results ripple through DC as judge temporarily blocks Trump arch construction — Good Morning America

The locals are improvising at East Potomac

While legal teams spar, golfers have taken things into their own hands, finding creative ways to mark the holes after the flagsticks were removed from the course.

The Interior Department presented its plan for the golf course to the Commission of Fine Arts on Thursday, one of two federal agencies needed for approval. Commission Secretary Thomas Luebke said roughly 700 people from the public weighed in with comments before the meeting, and just three of them backed the golf course proposal.

Concerns included the elimination of the park’s perimeter loop, impacts on the Marine Corps Marathon route, loss of historic cherry trees, and a $43 million deferred-maintenance figure with no total renovation cost disclosed.

What happens between Thanksgiving and December 12

The clock is the story. Reyes’s order lapses Nov. 28; plaintiffs want an extension to Dec. 12. The government said “the court already has everything it needs to promptly consider a motion for preliminary injunction” and has proposed a schedule that would enable her to issue a final ruling by Nov. 28.

White House spokesperson Davis Ingle told NPR on Thursday the administration will “continue making the case for this beautiful and fitting monument and are confident we will be fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds.”

The fight is playing out in Washington, D.C., the capital the Constitution allowed Congress to create in 1789 as a federal district outside any state. The land along the Potomac River was carved partly from Maryland and partly from Virginia, though Congress returned the Virginia portion, including Alexandria, in 1846.

The city was designed in 1791 by Pierre Charles L’Enfant and is home to many of the national monuments and museums on and around the National Mall, including the Washington Monument and the Lincoln Memorial. Its residents have no voting representation in Congress, electing only a non-voting delegate to the House.

As Max Kennedy put it, “If this is a great idea, then bring it before Congress, follow the rules and get it approved.”

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Pancreatic Cancer Incidence Doubles in Men, Triples in Women Over 30 Years in France; Rise in Young Adults and Women Unexplained, Researchers Say

Will Smith Faces Civil Lawsuit Over Alleged Sexual Assault by Former Collaborator