A Wyoming jury awarded $6 million late Thursday to a former resident of the Wyoming Boys’ School after finding that facility staff subjected him to unauthorized punitive isolation and denied him due process.
The unanimous verdict in the U.S. District Court in Casper concludes an eight-day trial centered on several stretches of confinement that Blaise Chivers-King endured in 2020 and 2021 inside 7-by-10-foot cinderblock detention rooms at the state-run juvenile facility near Worland.
Jurors deliberated for approximately seven hours before determining liability against Wyoming Boys’ School Superintendent Dale Weber and Dorm Supervisor Mike Nelson. However, the panel did not rule in favor of Chivers-King’s excessive force claim against Thad Shaffer, a security manager at the institution.
“We are so proud of our client,” Allison Mahoney, an attorney for Chivers-King, told WyoFile. “This was not easy for him to sit in court and listen to testimony.”
Confinement in Cinderblock Cells
The legal action stems from a lawsuit filed more than two years ago by six former residents alleging abuse at the 38-acre residential facility, which detains delinquent boys ages 12 to 21 under the oversight of the Wyoming Department of Family Services. Chivers-King’s case marked the first of the group’s claims to reach trial.
During the proceedings, attorneys presented photographs and video footage of the facility’s isolation quarters. The white cinderblock rooms contain only a toilet and a mattress provided solely at night, lacking exterior windows. Staff members occasionally placed magnets over the door windows to block the view.
Chivers-King testified that his confinement felt completely arbitrary, noting that staff kept him isolated even after he calmed down or held him for predetermined lengths of time. Ciara Boerman, another attorney representing Chivers-King, told jurors during closing arguments that staff maintained the isolation “even when he did what he was supposed to do.”
Evidence presented at trial included footage of Chivers-King engaging in self-harm while locked in detention, such as banging his head against the wall and attempting to strangle himself. “The vast majority of that time he spent with his own thoughts, thinking about how to end his life,” Boerman told the court.
Legal Arguments and Defense Strategy
Attorneys for the state argued that staff members acted out of safety concerns during difficult operational circumstances, emphasizing that Chivers-King’s residency coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic. Defense attorney Scott Ortiz told jurors that staff did their best to maintain order despite facing severe challenges.
The witness said that based on his evaluation, Blaise Chivers-King, the former boys’ school resident suing school staff, had PTSD that was “directly caused by his isolation time at the Wyoming Boys’ School.”#wyomingboysschool #wyomingnewshttps://t.co/rsKKqNSqUU
The defense also highlighted Chivers-King’s behavioral and mental health challenges predating his time at the school, alongside instances where he suddenly acted violently toward staff—punching, kicking, head-butting, and biting employees after appearing calm. Defense lawyers attempted to pin accountability on former Superintendent Gary Gilmore, who has since died, arguing that Gilmore made the final decisions regarding disciplinary confinement.
Weber testified that Gilmore maintained an authoritarian leadership style, stating, “I don’t believe I had any authority to challenge his decisions.” Boerman countered this defense argument during closing statements by pointing out that both Weber and Nelson signed official documents concerning Chivers-King’s detention room stays. “That’s convenient, but that’s not accountability,” she said.
Verdict Spurs Calls for Solitary Confinement Legislation
The verdict brings public scrutiny to the opaque disciplinary practices of the Worland facility, where transparency has historically been limited by juvenile privacy laws. “A big piece of this was the lack of oversight,” Boerman told WyoFile. “This is a problem that needs to come to light.”
Following the jury’s decision, Mahoney expressed hope that the outcome would prompt broader policy reform. “I hope this sends a message that legislation needs to be enacted in Wyoming to address solitary confinement,” she said. Ciara Boerman added that the verdict “sent a strong message in recognizing that this is wrong.”
Worland, the Washakie County seat with about 4,773 residents, lies in the Big Horn Basin along the Big Horn River in northwestern Wyoming. The city is known as the least windy municipality in the state, its climate sheltered by surrounding mountains.
Legal proceedings involving the Wyoming Boys’ School are far from over, as Chivers-King’s case serves as the first test among several pending lawsuits brought by former residents. The next trial addressing related allegations of abuse at the facility is scheduled to begin Dec. 7.