The Justice Department and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office have asked federal courts in two Samsung patent cases to make it easier to win injunctions — orders that can force a company to stop selling products or remove features from them — arguing in filings in 2025 and this year that even patent owners with no products of their own deserve that power.
That’s a reversal of the legal firewall that has protected the tech industry for two decades. Since the Supreme Court’s May 2006 ruling in eBay v. MercExchange, a patent holder can’t automatically shut down a rival’s product after proving infringement; it has to show “irreparable harm,” that it can’t be adequately compensated by money, that the “balance of hardships” favors the plaintiff, and that an injunction would not harm the “public interest.”
The government is now nudging courts to read those requirements more loosely, and the timing matters: the second of the two cases is currently on appeal at the Federal Circuit, the nation’s top patent court.
Who wins if the government gets its way? The beneficiaries are patent assertion entities — the companies that acquire patents to extract payments through litigation and legal threats.
“It’s unusual for the government to intervene in private patent disputes, but the current administration has done so repeatedly — and not on the side of the public,” EFF reported.
Blocking sales in SSD patent dispute
The first intervention came in June 2025, when the Justice Department and the Patent Office filed a “statement of interest” in Radian Memory Systems v. Samsung, a dispute over patents involving solid-state drives, the storage devices commonly used in modern computers.
Radian, a patent assertion company tied to Fortress Investment Group, sought a preliminary injunction that would have halted sales of Samsung’s products before any judge or jury had determined whether the patents were even infringed.
The government’s argument was that even a patent owner whose business depends entirely on patent licensing could suffer irreparable harm, since working out the proper monetary award might prove difficult. “In cases of unique assets, courts have commonly found irreparable harm when damages are difficult to calculate,” the DOJ writes in its brief.
Courts regularly resolve disagreements about patent royalty rates, a patent’s contribution, and comparable licenses. If “this math is hard” becomes a ticket to an injunction, then eBay‘s central protection — that money should be the default remedy — collapses for every pure licensing business in the country.
Radian ultimately withdrew its preliminary injunction request, but the government’s arguments remain on the record, available to the next assertion entity that wants to try.
The $445.5 million verdict that still wasn’t enough
The second case is more revealing, because the plaintiff had already won. In Collision Communications v. Samsung, a patent-licensing entity that acquired its patents from a defense contractor, a jury awarded $445.5 million in February of this year for infringement of four patents. Collision then sought an injunction.
The government stepped in regardless — after the $445.5 million jury verdict — contending that non-practicing patent owners like Collision should not be refused injunctions merely because their income comes from licensing patents, and that the challenge of computing monetary damages may itself justify an injunction.
U.S. District Court Judge Rodney Gilstrap agreed that Collision had suffered irreparable harm and that money alone would be inadequate, but he rejected the claim that ongoing patent infringement automatically establishes irreparable harm. He turned down the injunction because Collision fell short on two other elements of the eBay test: demonstrating that the balance of hardships favored an injunction and that an injunction would not damage the public interest.
Collision has appealed. The case now sits with the Federal Circuit, and the brief from the Public Interest Patent Law Institute frames what a reversal would mean.
Because the patents involve how mobile phones connect to cellular networks, PIPLI argued, “the effect on the public goes far beyond what these patents claim as improvements.” An injunction against Samsung’s phones wouldn’t remove one feature — it would cut millions of users off from the network itself.
Why the NTP settlement still haunts this fight
In 2006, NTP Inc. — a patent holding company with no products — pressured BlackBerry manufacturer Research in Motion Ltd. into a $612 million settlement while an injunction loomed. That payment reflected the value of the threat, not the value of the patents. Multiply that dynamic across every smartphone, SSD, and baseband chip on the market, and you get the economy of patent control the DOJ's filings would supercharge.
The government’s own language makes the threat the point. “The prospect of an injunction can facilitate negotiation among the parties,” the DOJ wrote. EFF’s reading is blunt: negotiation under threat of shutdown produces payments sized to the threat, not the patent.
- May 2006 — Supreme Court rules in eBay v. MercExchange that patent owners must meet a four-factor test, including the public interest, before winning a permanent injunction.
- June 2025 — DOJ and USPTO file a statement of interest in Radian Memory Systems v. Samsung, arguing hard-to-calculate damages can show irreparable harm.
- February of this year — The government repeats the argument in Collision Communications v. Samsung, after a $445.5 million jury verdict; Judge Gilstrap denies the injunction on the remaining eBay factors.
- Now — Collision’s appeal is before the Federal Circuit.
What the eBay test actually protects
It’s easy to forget, twenty years on, why eBay mattered. Patents are government-granted monopolies, justified only when they serve a public purpose: promoting scientific and technological progress. The Supreme Court held that enforcing one shouldn’t come at the cost of later innovators, free expression, or public access to technology.
EFF’s own brief in the case warned that the Patent Office had issued patents on methods for downloading video programs, publishing web pages, sending email messages, making internet telephone calls, and even online fundraising methods — and that injunctions against such technologies would chill free expression online.
Two decades later, that warning remains relevant. Software patents remain vague and widely abused, and most patent lawsuits are still filed by companies that do not make real products. The eBay framework is the structural check that keeps a patent on one feature from threatening an entire product line.
Appeal's outcome affects patent owners
The appeal’s outcome could reach well beyond Samsung. If the Federal Circuit accepts the government’s framing — that licensing-only plaintiffs deserve injunctions, and that thorny damages math proves irreparable harm — then every assertion entity gains a standing threat against any company whose products touch a poorly drafted software patent. If the court instead holds the line on the balance-of-hardships and public-interest factors, the DOJ’s filings become footnotes.
Patent owners can already collect damages and royalties. What they’re asking for — with the Justice Department’s help — is a shortcut to shutdown. The court that hears Collision’s appeal will decide, in effect, whether the threat of pulling phones off the network counts as a fair negotiating position. The briefs are in; the Federal Circuit’s answer is the only thing left to wait for.