Corbin Trent, a former communications director for Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez who now runs the super PAC A Fight Worth Having, told Today, Explained that neither Hakeem Jeffries nor Chuck Schumer should lead the party’s new majorities — and he argued the fight itself matters more than the candidates.
Democrats won historic victories in the midterm elections and must now choose leaders for their new House and Senate majorities. In the House, Jeffries is the sole declared candidate for speaker, and the race is expected to be a formality. The Senate contest is livelier: Schumer faces a challenge from Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who told the podcast that voters “called to reject the status quo.”
“The call was really to reject the status quo and to reject business as usual,” Van Hollen said. “And to do that, I think we need new leadership.”
Trent, speaking with co-host Sean Rameswaram, went further. “This moment calls for some sort of leadership that shows that we have a plan, an agenda, and a vision that’s capable of taking on and meeting this moment,” he said. “And it’s not Hakeem Jeffries. It’s not Chuck Schumer.”
Why Trent wants both out
Trent’s case against Jeffries rests on discipline and priorities. He argued that Jeffries’s style of leadership is ill-suited for this moment, that consensus-building is not enough, and thatDemocrats need new leaders who can meet the demands of the voters who delivered the majorities.
On Schumer, Trent was blunter. “Chuck Schumer is a man with a strongly worded letter in his back pocket,” he said, arguing the senator chases a couple of voters in rural Pennsylvania that are Republicans rather than building a governing coalition.
His model is historical. Trent argued the current moment resembles the era that produced the New Deal, when Democrats built a durable supermajority — and he warned that squandered hope curdles. “When it’s dashed, it calcifies and it becomes resentment and anger,” he said.
He cited his own political awakening: inspired by Barack Obama’s first campaign, he raised money through the campaign’s portal and held a watch party in Asheville, then heard “a very different thing as a president than as a candidate.”
The healthcare math behind his argument
Trent’s grievance is the fight over healthcare. With 59 or 60 Senate votes and a House majority, he argued, Democrats settled for a compromise that “gave us Romneycare” — a plan he said was rebranded as Obamacare without slowing cost increases.
He recalled how new members pressing for a public option were told that while 50,000 to 60,000 people a year die from lack of healthcare, the bill would save 4,000 to 5,000 of those lives — and asked whether they would let those people die to fight for the larger fix. His conclusion: fight for something bigger first, so the eventual compromise lands higher.
Power, taken not given
Trent rejected the idea that leadership races follow the norms both chambers expect. He invoked 2018, when Ocasio-Cortez unseated Joe Crowley — then in line to be the next speaker of the House — and said that the Congressional Progressive Caucus now counts 99 members and is growing.
The lesson he draws from Nancy Pelosi: “Power is not given, it is taken.” He wants progressives to use this moment to build a super-majoritarian party — one that can make the Republican Party, in his words, “small enough to drown in a bathtub” — rather than extract concessions from leaders who “do not fear these people.”
As for Ocasio-Cortez backing Jeffries, Trent saw a dodge: “She’s doing this weird little thread-the-needle: ‘He’s the only one. What can we do?’” He argued that kind of thinking is exactly what Democrats should rebuff.
He acknowledged why the top jobs hold little appeal. A speaker or majority leader must either deliver — difficult with Donald Trump still in the White House — or show clearly who is blocking them, and many of the blockers, he noted, would be Democratic representatives and Democratic senators.
Who he would pick instead
Trent named Rep. Ayanna Pressley and Chris Van Hollen. He conceded Van Hollen sits to his right — “not exactly a bastion of progressivism,” as Rameswaram put it — but said he could do the job.
“I am going to let good be the enemy of bad,” Trent said. “I think the fight in and of itself is worth it, and winning is worth it.”