Nick Wright Argues Chargers Should Trade Justin Herbert for a Hard Reset

Nick Wright argued on “First Things First” Tuesday that the Los Angeles Chargers, even after their first win of the season Monday night, should trade Justin Herbert and “hard reset the whole thing” rather than run the roster back in 2027.

The debate occurred on the Tuesday edition of “First Things First,” where Wright, Chris Broussard and Kevin Wildes weighed what Los Angeles should do after beating the Baltimore Ravens 23-20 on Monday night. The win improved the Chargers to 1-8, their first victory since Week 16 of last season, and left them tied with the Tennessee Titans and Miami Dolphins for the NFL’s worst record.

Wright’s case started with an uncomfortable premise. He predicted the Chargers will win more games, but argued the franchise shouldn’t let that change its self-assessment.

“But regardless, if I were the Los Angeles Chargers, I would be honest that my roster is not good.”

The trade idea rests on Herbert’s market value. Wright said the quarterback is valued around the league more than his current play justifies, and that Los Angeles could land multiple first-round picks for him.

“I do think you could get multiple first-round picks for Justin Herbert, and if I were the Los Angeles Chargers with my own top five pick coming plus multiple first-round picks, I would hard reset the whole thing. I think it’s hard because he has a no-trade, but they are nowhere close at all, and so I’d hard reset the whole thing.”

That no-trade protection is the structural obstacle Wright flagged himself. Herbert has thrown six touchdown passes against 11 interceptions this season, and the Chargers own the league’s lowest-scoring offense.

Wright also warned that the schedule could distort the picture. The Chargers host the New York Jets on Nov. 22 and the New England Patriots on Nov. 29.

“I actually think they might go on a tiny run. They could trick themselves, and not just themselves. The media as a whole might step on this rake again.”

On Jim Harbaugh, Wright was noncommittal about the head coach’s future but tied the answer to the reset.

“Probably not, but I think I’d probably hard reset the whole thing.”

Herbert's value changes with McDaniel

  • Herbert’s 71 passer rating and 11 interceptions against six touchdown passes have soured his value this season; moving on from offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel could change his rest-of-season outlook more than the Monday win itself.
  • Ravens backers saw Los Angeles fall to 1-8 with Monday’s loss, but Wright warned that a 1-8 team hosting two winnable home games, against the Jets and then the Patriots on Nov. 29, could trick the Chargers and the media into thinking they are turning it around.

Broussard pushed back on the coaching question. He said he saw nothing in the locker room after the win suggesting Harbaugh had lost the team, and argued for patience with the staff.

“If he has the locker room still, and you got to be in that building to know the front office and all that, you keep it, because we know he’s a good coach. And this is a horrible season from hell, but we know he’s a good coach. If he has the locker room, I would lean toward keeping him.”

Broussard had no quarrel with the celebrating itself.

“I’m fine with the celebration. I have no problem with it, because it’s what you do for a living. It feels better to win than to go lose every week.”

Where Broussard did agree with the doomsday read was on the offense — specifically on offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel, whom he called the one he would move on from. He labeled Herbert’s season “abysmal,” pointing to the 71 passer rating and the six touchdown passes.

“I would get rid of McDaniel and see how Herbert plays the rest of the season. He might have a little jump. If he all of a sudden has a jump and kind of looks like the old Justin Herbert when McDaniel is gone, that tells you something.”

Broussard even left the door open on the quarterback himself, conditioned on the draft. If the Chargers fall for a prospect at the position, he said, the franchise could take that player and trade Herbert, because he believes there would still be value for Herbert on the market.

What Monday’s win actually said

The box score explains why the debate exists at all. Herbert completed 12 of 18 passes for 129 yards and ran for a touchdown in the win — a workmanlike line on a night the defense and score margin, not the passing game, carried Los Angeles.

Herbert, season Figure
Monday at Ravens (Result) 23-20 win
Completions/attempts Monday 12 of 18
Passing yards Monday 129
Season interceptions 11
Season passer rating 71

The context around those numbers is the Chargers’ 1-8 record, their tie with Tennessee and Miami at the bottom of the league, and the lowest-scoring offense in the NFL.

What neither host resolved is the front office’s actual position. Wright’s scenario requires the Chargers to acknowledge their roster is not good and to move a franchise quarterback with a no-trade clause; Broussard’s alternative requires firing McDaniel, watching Herbert for the rest of the season, and keeping Harbaugh as long as the locker room holds.

The next checkpoint comes quickly, with the Jets visiting on Nov. 22 and the Patriots on Nov. 29 — the exact stretch Wright predicted could fool the team, and the media, into believing the reset isn’t necessary.

Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.

Photo of author

Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archyde.

Poupette Kenza to Face Trial in January for Extortion Attempt

Trent: Democrats Need New Leadership, Not Jeffries or Schumer