Astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope have identified a possible black hole in a galaxy seen as it was roughly 12 billion years ago that appears far heavier relative to its stars than any similar system observed in the nearby universe.
- The black hole candidate in galaxy MARTA 3887 has an estimated mass of 3.3 million suns; its host galaxy holds about 145 million solar masses of stars.
- That ratio — roughly 2.3% of the galaxy’s stellar mass — is about 100 times higher than the relationship seen in local galaxies.
- The detection rests on a broad hydrogen-alpha line showing gas moving at 1,270 km/s, seen in hydrogen but not in calmer oxygen lines.
- Researchers caution the object remains a candidate; a supernova interacting with dense gas could mimic the signal.
Black Hole Outpaces Its Galaxy
A team led by Mirko Curti of INAF’s Astrophysics and Space Science Observatory in Bologna found the candidate by combining JWST spectroscopy with Hubble imaging and archival data from the Very Large Telescope’s MUSE instrument.
The galaxy, dubbed MARTA 3887, is clumpy and metal-poor. It contains very few heavy elements — about 10% of the Sun’s level — and is forming stars in a recent burst at five to nine solar masses per year.
The black hole’s estimated mass is 3.3 million suns. The galaxy holds roughly 145 million solar masses of stars. “approximately 2 dex above the local relation,” the team writes, meaning the black hole is about 100 times heavier relative to its host than the relationship extrapolated from nearby galaxies. “black-hole growth has outpaced the assembly of the observed stellar component,” they add.

The discovery paper, posted to the arXiv preprint server with, is titled MARTA: A ‘little’ black hole hidden in a clumpy, metal-poor galaxy at z~3.8 and lists Mirko Curti et al. as authors.
The study notes that numerous recent investigations have uncovered early black holes that relate to their host galaxies differently than those in the local universe. Early black holes are excessively massive relative to their host galaxies’ stellar masses, implying they may grow more rapidly than the stars.
Multiple Lines of Evidence
JWST spectroscopy uncovered an exceptionally broad hydrogen-alpha emission line, signaling gas moving at about 1,270 kilometers per second. The signal appeared only in hydrogen, not in oxygen lines from calmer gas, pointing toward a black hole rather than a typical galactic outflow.
The researchers also modeled different growth scenarios. If growth began very early — when the universe was about 0.1 billion years old — modest feeding rates from seeds of 100 to 100,000 solar masses could reach the measured mass. If growth started only with the recent star-formation burst, even a small seed would need an extreme, far-above-normal feeding rate.
The team calls the galaxy an indirect “leaker candidate” because about 44% of its Lyman-alpha light escapes. This suggests porous gas through which ultraviolet photons could have helped clear the neutral hydrogen fog of cosmic reionization.
New Studies Reveal Early Black Hole Growth Theories
In August, a team led by Wuhan University and Hunan Normal University stacked images of 217 such objects and detected a faint, ring-like glow around their centers. They interpreted it as tiny galaxies with actively forming stars surrounding a central black hole.
Around the same time, an MIT team analyzing one object, MoM-BH*-1, concluded it may be a black hole enshrouded in thick gas that traps energy and could allow super-Eddington growth.
In May, a group headed by Ignas Juodžbalis at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom determined the mass of a black hole that existed about 700 million years after the Big Bang. Their target was an object called “Abell2744-QSO1,” observed by the James Webb Space Telescope, which is also one of the little red dots detected in the early universe.
Together, these studies raise the possibility that black holes in the early universe grew far faster than expected, perhaps preceding the assembly of their host galaxies.
The researchers caution that MARTA 3887’s black hole remains a candidate. An interacting supernova or a compact, thick outflow could still mimic the signal, though they consider these alternatives less likely. They cannot rule them out from a single observation.