Lawyer Hassan Kohen: Police May Enter Church Rooms for Deportations Only Under Narrow Conditions

Police may enter church rooms to seize a person slated for deportation, a German legal analysis published on Friday by Hassan Kohen, a lawyer at the Paris bar, confirms — but only under narrow conditions, and the moment officers begin searching, a judge must have ordered it, per the German constitutional court’s September 30, 2025 decision.

The piece does not report on any single case. Hassan Kohen reported that it answers a question congregations and support groups raise whenever a deportation or a transfer to another EU state is imminent: may the immigration authority and police enter church premises to pick somebody up, and when do they need a judicial order?

The word “Kirchenasyl” itself appears nowhere in the statutes, the analysis stresses, and church rooms are neither excluded from nor specially treated by them.

Here is why that distinction carries weight right now. The Federal Constitutional Court’s chamber decision of September 30, 2025 (2 BvR 460/25) established that a SEARCH without a judge — opening a room in communal accommodation to grab a resident facing an EU transfer — violated the resident’s constitutional right under Article 13 of the Basic Law.

The analysis, built on the Residence Act (Aufenthaltsgesetz) and the asylum statute, translates that ruling’s test into church basements, parish houses and monastery rooms where people in Kirchenasyl live.

Church rooms count as homes under residence act

  • Church rooms count as “homes” under § 58(5) sentence 3 of the Residence Act, which defines housing to include living and ancillary rooms, work, business and commercial premises and other fenced property — Hassan Kohen reported there is consequently “much to suggest” that a parish hall, a rectory or a monastery room counts.
  • Entry without a judge is only lawful under § 58(5) if the authority has facts indicating the sought person is present; a search under § 58(6) requires a judicial order except in cases of imminent danger.
  • The court’s 2025 ruling blocks the classic workaround: police cannot enter lawfully, fail to find the person, and then declare an emergency that justifies searching on their own authority.

Church asylum lacks special legal status

Kirchenasyl is a colloquial term, not a legal one, the analysis states: temporary shelter in church premises so a looming deportation can be examined once more. Anyone wanting to understand what actually applies must begin with the ordinary residence rules.

Under § 50(1) of the Residence Act, a foreigner must leave the country when they do not possess a required residence title and hold no right of residence under the EEC/Turkey association agreement.

Section 58(1) requires that the exit duty be enforceable, that no departure deadline has been granted or has expired, and that voluntary departure is not secured — or that monitoring appears necessary for public safety and order. Normally, deportation is preceded by a formal threat with a voluntary departure window of seven to 30 days under § 59(1), from which the authority may deviate only exceptionally.

Where a Dublin transfer to another EU member state is at stake, the procedure differs. Under § 34a(1) of the Asylum Act, the Federal Office orders deportation to the responsible state as soon as it is established that the transfer can be carried out — no prior threat or deadline-setting is required in that case, the analysis notes.

It deliberately leaves open whether and for how long another state remains responsible under Regulation (EU) 2024/1351, questions it says are decisive for many church asylums but which the article’s source basis did not cover, since the union-law rules on responsibility and transfer deadlines were not evaluated.

The word “home” now covers the parish hall

The statutory lever is the definition of housing. Section 58(5) sentence 3 reads verbatim: “Die Wohnung umfasst die Wohn- und Nebenräume, Arbeits-, Betriebs- und Geschäftsräume sowie anderes befriedetes Besitztum.” In English: housing includes living and ancillary rooms, work, business and commercial premises, and other fenced possession. Since neither the Residence Act nor the Asylum Act carves out church premises, both their restraints and their protections apply fully.

The law draws a hard line between entering and searching. Under § 58(5) sentence 1, the authority carrying out the deportation may ENTER the foreigner’s home to seize them if the purpose requires it and facts indicate the person is there; the same applies for rooms of third parties and communal spaces in shared accommodation. That entry needs no judge.

Searching, governed by § 58(6), requires more: per that provision’s second sentence, “Bei anderen Personen sind Durchsuchungen nur zur Ergreifung des abzuschiebenden Ausländers zulässig, wenn Tatsachen vorliegen, aus denen zu schließen ist, dass der Ausländer sich in den zu durchsuchenden Räumen befindet” — against other persons, searches to seize the deportee are permissible only where facts show the person is in the rooms to be searched. A mere supposition does not suffice, the analysis emphasizes.

Who orders the search? Section 58(8): only a judge, except in cases of imminent danger, when the authority conducting the deportation may act itself.

That provision’s second sentence forecloses the obvious loophole: “Die Annahme von Gefahr im Verzug kann nach Betreten der Wohnung nach Absatz 5 nicht darauf gestützt werden, dass der Ausländer nicht angetroffen wurde.” The assumption of imminent danger cannot rest, after an entry under paragraph 5, on the fact that the foreigner was not found.

Nighttime adds another layer. Under § 58(7), entry or search at night is possible only if facts show the seizure would otherwise be thwarted — and the organization of the deportation itself, such as a flight’s departure time, does not count as such a fact unless conditions exist the authority cannot influence, the analysis states.

How the constitutional court drew the search line in September 2025

The chamber decision 2 BvR 460/25 arose from communal accommodation: officers had opened a resident’s room without a judicial order to seize him for a transfer to another EU state. The court held this violated his Article 13 right.

Its test, quoted in the analysis: “Nach diesen Maßstäben liegt grundsätzlich eine Durchsuchung vor, wenn der Betroffene zum Zwecke der Abschiebung in seinem Zimmer einer Gemeinschaftsunterkunft aufgesucht wird, solange vor Beginn der Maßnahme keine sichere Kenntnis über den konkreten Aufenthaltsort der zu ergreifenden Person besteht.”

In substance: what occurs is generally a SEARCH when the person is visited for deportation purposes without prior certain knowledge of their exact whereabouts, according to Hassan KOHEN.

Three further points bear on Kirchenasyl. Second, a mere entry under § 58(5) cannot carry an operation that amounts to a search, because a search under § 58(6) may only be ordered by a judge, save in cases of imminent danger. Third, the court described the exception: where the person’s whereabouts is known from the outset or visible from outside and direct access is possible, the element of searching may be absent.

What does that mean for a community house with several rooms?

What happens when officers reach the door

The constitutional right anchoring everything is Article 13(1) of the Basic Law: “Die Wohnung ist unverletzlich.” Article 13(2) follows: “Durchsuchungen dürfen nur durch den Richter, bei Gefahr im Verzuge auch durch die in den Gesetzen vorgesehenen anderen Organe angeordnet und nur in der dort vorgeschriebenen Form durchgeführt werden.”

What the September 2025 chamber decision, which concerned a single room in a shared accommodation facility, leaves open alongside the Dublin responsibility questions is how its test maps onto a church building with chapel, office quarters and living space.

That fitting of one ruling to many rooms remains the unresolved work, as of November 2026, for the courts that hear search complaints after the next unannounced knock, since uncertainty about which room the person occupies calls for a judicially ordered search.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Gov. Mills Announces 25 New Federal Opportunity Zones Across Maine