Legal experts Akua Reindorf KC and Sarah Vine KC argued on Wednesday that the draft Conversion Practices Bill currently before parliament risks violating six articles of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The bill, presently under scrutiny by a joint committee of MPs and peers, remains in draft form, delaying the statutory compatibility statement required under the Human Rights Act.
- The proposed draft Conversion Practices Bill faces significant legal headwinds regarding its alignment with international human rights standards.
- Institutional scrutiny by the joint committee of MPs and peers indicates a prolonged legislative path, impacting regulatory certainty for affected sectors.
- The absence of ministerial compatibility declarations creates a period of operational ambiguity for stakeholders monitoring potential compliance shifts.
The critique surfaced during a panel discussion held at Gray’s Inn hall, organized by the Sex and Gender Law Association. Reindorf and Vine asserted that the draft legislation threatens Articles 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 14 of the convention. These provisions cover a spectrum of fundamental rights, including the right to a fair trial, protection against retrospective criminalization, and the preservation of freedom of thought and expression.
Joshua Rozenberg, writing for his Substack, reported that the panel featured five speakers, all of whom expressed substantial criticism of the bill’s current structure. The event organizers were unable to secure participants who supported the government’s draft, leading to a one-sided assessment of the text’s legal viability.
The draft status of the bill means that no minister has yet been mandated to confirm whether the legislation is believed to be compatible with the convention.
| Legal Provision | Significance in Human Rights Law |
|---|---|
| Article 6 | Right to a fair trial |
| Article 7 | No punishment without law |
| Article 8 | Right to respect for private and family life |
| Article 9 | Freedom of thought, conscience, and religion |
| Article 10 | Freedom of expression |
| Article 14 | Prohibition of discrimination |
The legislative tension highlights a growing divide between regulatory intent and established human rights frameworks.
Rozenberg said that the discussion provided insight into the underlying political motivations driving the bill. By examining the draft through the lens of the Human Rights Act, the panel highlighted the threshold requirements the government must meet before the bill can proceed to a formal vote. The lack of vocal support on the panel shows the contentious nature of the drafting process.
As the joint committee continues its review, the scrutiny of these six specific articles will likely form the core of the legal challenges the government faces. The timeline for the bill’s next iteration remains dependent on the committee’s findings and the subsequent ministerial response regarding human rights compatibility.
Akua Reindorf, who qualified in 1999, has established a significant legal career focused on employment, discrimination, and human rights law. Her influence in the field was marked by her recognition as Barrister of the Year at the 2023 Legal Business Awards and her inclusion in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 for 2022.
Beyond her practice, she served as a commissioner for the Equality and Human Rights Commission between 2021 and 2025 and holds a position as a visiting senior fellow in practice at the London School of Economics Law School.
Her work has included securing a landmark judgment in Puthenveettil v Alexander & George, which led to a national change in minimum wage legislation for migrant domestic workers. She has also led numerous cases defending academic freedom and freedom of speech within university settings.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.