A doctor barred from treating children over safety concerns gave expert evidence that helped convict Lucy Letby, then wrote a key report for the prosecution of two grieving parents — all while his hospital trust had stripped him of clinical duties.
The jury was never told. Neither, it emerges, were the parents of Joshua Thomas, 12, who died of diabetic ketoacidosis in December 2022.
Hindmarsh produced his expert report for the Crown Prosecution Service in August 2023, concluding that Joshua’s symptoms on the morning of 9 December 2022 were sufficient that “a medical assessment should have been sought.”
West Midlands police and the CPS relied on that opinion to secure convictions: Tamara Thomas was found guilty of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect, sentenced to three years and nine months; Damion Thomas was cleared of manslaughter but convicted of neglect and sentenced to two years and nine months.
“Both parents were aware of the signs and symptoms of diabetes and expert medical evidence showed their son’s death would have been preventable if medical attention had been sought earlier,” Detective Inspector Vicki Harris said after the verdicts.
The restriction UCLH imposed
UCLH’s medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, informed the General Medical Council in March 2023 that the trust could not “accept the level of risk Professor Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people.”
Among the concerns: Hindmarsh had independently advised two child patients to stop taking insulin at home. One subsequently suffered an episode of diabetic ketoacidosis, though Hodgson noted it was unclear whether that coincided with Hindmarsh’s advice.

A medical practitioners tribunal in January 2023 had already ordered direct supervision of Hindmarsh’s clinical work, ruling he “may pose a real risk to members of the public.” In April 2023, a second tribunal declined to suspend his registration — explicitly noting he could continue working as an expert witness — but imposed a stricter supervision order that had no practical effect because UCLH had already barred him from treating patients altogether.
Disclosure duties unmet
Expert witnesses are required under the Criminal Procedure Rules to disclose “anything that might reasonably be thought capable of undermining the expert’s opinion or detract from the credibility or impartiality of the expert,” including disciplinary proceedings. Tim Green KC, a specialist in disclosure, said that duty arises “as soon as reasonably practicable.”
Hindmarsh does not appear to have informed West Midlands police of his circumstances for more than two years after writing his report. The CPS West Midlands office only learned of the GMC investigation and restrictions in December 2025, after it independently discovered them and asked police to raise the matter with Hindmarsh. The CPS nevertheless decided it could continue to rely on him.
The Thomases, who have applied for permission to appeal, say they were unaware throughout the two-and-a-half-year investigation and trial. Their elder son Alessandro, 27, is representing them.
Ripple effects on the Letby case
Hindmarsh was a crucial prosecution witness at Letby’s trial, testifying that as little as 0.6 ml of insulin added to feed bags could cause the hypoglycaemic collapses attributed to the nurse. A report submitted to the Criminal Cases Review Commission by Professor Geoff Chase and Helen Shannon disputes that calculation, suggesting at least 10 times as much — 6 ml — would be required.
Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, has argued that the insulin evidence “contaminated the entire trial” because the jury was directed that a finding of guilt on one count could support the others. “If the foundations of the insulin cases collapse, the consequences extend to every conviction. The dominoes begin to fall,” McDonald told the CCRC.
University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust traces its origins to the Middlesex Hospital, founded in 1745 as one of London’s five 18th-century voluntary general hospitals. The modern trust was established in 1994, became one of the first NHS foundation trusts in 2004, and in 2012 was selected as one of only two English sites for Proton Beam Therapy. Today it employs roughly 11,000 staff and treats more than one million outpatient appointments annually.
The CCRC has not yet announced whether it will refer Letby’s convictions back to the Court of Appeal.
Related reading
- KooKoo Job Ad Touts ‘Established Liiga Place’ as Team Sits Last
- DEA Dismantles First U.S. Nitazene Synthesis Lab in Louisiana
- Experimental Drug Daraxonrasib With Chemo Shrinks Tumors in 61% of Metastatic Pancreatic Cancer Patients (news-usa.today)
- UGM Expert Urges Rigorous Study Before Javan Rhino Relocation (archynewsy.com)