Nicolas Cage plays John Madden in a fat suit so bulky one critic compared him to a line drawing out of “Family Guy,” and the verdict on David O. Russell’s Amazon biopic “Madden” is grim: reviews arriving Wednesday, November 18, the film’s theatrical release date, describe a cartoonish biodrama that reduces one of football’s most beloved figures to a caricature.
The film is rated R and runs one hour and 50 minutes. The cast also includes John Mulaney, Shane Gillis, Simms May, Luke Klein, Joel Murray and Mark Medrano, with Russell directing.
The Guardian’s review calls the film a stinker that “can’t decide whether it’s serious or slapstick,” arguing Russell and his co-writers reduce “one of the 20th century’s most celebrated pop culture figures to a thin caricature.”
The Hollywood Reporter, noting the film “should come with a concussion warning,” says the stunt acting from both Cage and Christian Bale never lets viewers forget they are watching performances, leaving “little to no risk of forming a human emotional connection” with either man.
Cage’s method acting, according to The Guardian, “effectively stopped at the fat suit and tousled wig,” rendering Madden “a capricious oaf in the Chris Farley mold.” Variety describes the look as “Jiminy Glick playing John Candy” and the performance as “two parts impersonation, one part Nicolas Cage kabuki” — “a stunt biopic on cinematic amphetamines” that plays like an “SNL” sketch shot and edited by Scorsese.

Variety also notes what the costume cannot hide: the “wounded, sensitive puppy-dog eyes” Cage has shown audiences since “Valley Girl,” adding that “there’s an inner gentleness to Nicolas Cage, and that, ironically, is the quality John Madden had as well.”
Stumbles on and off the field
The film, co-written by Russell with Cambron Clark, opens in 1976, with Madden already a streak of winning seasons into his tenure as head coach of the Oakland Raiders but still chasing a Super Bowl title.
Bale, meanwhile, plays Raiders principal Al Davis, committing hardest to the role. The Guardian says he “more than justifies the makeup and costuming departments’ considerable efforts,” nailing Davis’s Brooklyn accent and roiling insistence on being the smartest guy in the room.
Variety calls Davis “one more stylized semi-prosthetic character,” played with “a shark mouth and slick receding hair and a Jewish goombah accent,” and notes Davis was the Raiders’ owner and Madden’s longtime friend. Sienna Miller plays Davis’s wife Carol, and Kathryn Hahn plays Virginia; The Guardian suggests Miller looks close to cracking up at the ridiculousness in early scenes.

Even the cast appears skittish about the result. The Guardian reports that John Mulaney, who plays EA Sports founder Trip Hawkins, never mentioned the film when he hosted “Saturday Night Live” last week. Shane Gillis appears as Vince McGary, a composite neighbor character The Guardian calls “thoroughly dispensable.”
The film also stumbles on its football details, stitching re-enactments to authentic NFL Films footage unconvincingly enough to draw flags from Madden-literate fans. In one glaring scene, Cage’s Madden telestrates a 1990s highlight from the booth in the 1970s. The Guardian adds that the shot is given away by the Fox Sports scorebug and by the player featured: Dallas Cowboys standout Nate Newton.
The Guardian, crediting Russell’s earlier work, says his experience tackling football fandom in “Silver Linings Playbook” made him seem particularly well suited to direct — but it finds that even the marriage between Cage’s John and Hahn’s Virginia “plays like a Drunk History re-enactment, especially when Russell gets his dreamy set pieces going.”
Variety also suggests Madden “might have been the model for Fred Willard’s deranged color commentator in ‘Best in Show,'” while noting “he also had a strangely innocent quality.”
Variety, the most charitable of the three, suspects the film “will be doomed” in its modest theatrical release but could find a streaming audience — though even that review concedes the movie “holds you at arm’s length.” The Guardian is blunter: after Russell fumbled the lead casting, “what else could Madden be but a disservice to the man?”