A federal jury in Los Angeles convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, on Friday of two arson charges for igniting the Lachman Fire on January 1, 2025, a blaze that smoldered underground for six days before erupting as the Palisades Fire, which killed 12 people and destroyed 6,837 structures across 23,448 acres.
The verdict followed a retrial after a jury deadlocked 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal in June, The Guardian reported. Prosecutors narrowed the indictment for the second trial, dropping a third charge of timber set afire and focusing on digital forensics and the defendant’s movements on the night of the ignition.
Jurors deliberated for two days before finding Rinderknecht guilty of destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce. The conviction carries a maximum sentence of life in prison.
Prosecutors pivot to digital evidence
In the retrial, Assistant U.S. Attorneys Mark Williams and Danbee Kim de-emphasized the “societal revenge” motive highlighted in the first proceeding, CNN reported. Instead, they presented surveillance footage of Rinderknecht’s rental car parked at the base of a trail leading to the fire’s origin, cell-tower data tracking his ascent, and fire-detection camera timestamps that eliminated other ignition sources, including fireworks.
LAPD Detective Matt Castellichio testified that a green Bic barbecue lighter found in the glove compartment of the rental car carried Rinderknecht’s DNA, NBC News reported.
“It’s not the traditional smoker’s lighter that I’m used to seeing,” Castellichio told the court.
Prosecutors also introduced evidence of Rinderknecht’s behavior after the fire started.
He placed more than a dozen 911 calls while descending the hill and screen-recorded video of the flames. During one call, he asked ChatGPT: “Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?” Williams characterized the calls and the query as a manufactured alibi.
Defense argues scene was contaminated before investigation
Defense attorney Steve Haney contended the government could not prove Rinderknecht lit the fire. He argued the origin area on Hidden Buddha Hill remained open to the public for six days before the Palisades Fire erupted, allowing hundreds of people to traverse the site. “Six days of anyone and everyone walking across the spot the government now calls a crime scene,” Haney told jurors.
Retired U.S. Forest Service investigator Ed Nordskog testified for the defense that the fire scene was compromised. “In my experience, we call it a case killer,” Nordskog said, according to NBC News.
Haney advanced an alternate theory: fireworks ignited the blaze.
He presented neighbors and a local firefighter who reported hearing a loud bang or explosion from the direction of the hill on New Year’s night. Prosecutors dismissed the theory as “baseless” in a court filing, The Guardian reported, challenging the reliability and late disclosure of a defense witness who claimed to have found firework residue at a nearby residence.
Jurors were explicitly instructed not to consider the Los Angeles Fire Department’s handling of the Lachman Fire, which critics said was not fully extinguished before high winds drove the rekindled flames into Pacific Palisades, Topanga, and Malibu.
Juror cites inconsistencies in defendant’s account
One juror, identified only as Cameron, a 30-year-old college student, told reporters outside the courthouse that gaps in Rinderknecht’s story were decisive. “Logically, things started pointing towards him,” Cameron said, according to The Guardian. He stopped short of saying Rinderknecht intended to burn down the Palisades, adding, “I believed Rinderknecht’s intent was to start a fire and that his actions resulted in the devastating blaze.”

Civil litigation and political fallout continue
The criminal verdict does not resolve consolidated civil lawsuits filed by survivors and victims’ families against the city and county of Los Angeles. “For the purpose of our civil case, the fire could have been started by lightning and would have had the same result,” said Alex Robertson, an attorney for plaintiffs, The Guardian reported. “It doesn’t matter what started the fire. It’s what happened — what didn’t happen in terms of protecting the residents of the Palisades and Malibu after the fire started.”
Mayor Karen Bass, who lost her re-election bid earlier this month and faced criticism for being abroad when the fire erupted, issued a statement Friday. “No verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain families have endured,” she said. “So many are still struggling to rebuild. For those still displaced, the devastation remains a daily reality.”
The Los Angeles Fire Department thanked the jurors. “Our first thought remains with the families of those we lost and for everyone in our community whose lives were changed by this fire,” the department said. “No verdict, however important, could ever undo that loss.”
Sentencing has not yet been scheduled.