A Manitoba judge has given Wab Kinew’s NDP government until Monday to disclose under oath who decided to exclude Tesla Motors Canada from the province’s EV rebate program and why — an “exceptional and unusual” remedy, according to CBC’s report of the Nov. 13 ruling, after the government refused for six months to name its decision-maker.
That refusal is now the story. Court of King’s Bench Justice Elissa Neville ordered the government to produce a “complete record” of the decision-making process that disqualified anyone who bought a Tesla after March 19, 2025, from qualifying for rebates worth up to $4,000.
Tesla Motors Canada ULC, a subsidiary of Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ: TSLA), went to court in May arguing the exclusion was unreasonable, untransparent and procedurally unfair — and, critically, that nobody has confirmed who had the legal authority to make it.
Neville was blunt about the gap in the government’s filing. “The disputed record filed with the court sheds no light whatsoever on the question of who made the Tesla exclusion decisions, how they made the decisions, why they made the decisions, and whether these decisions are reviewable,” she wrote, per CBC.
This is why she is impatient. The province filed six documents — the 2025 budget, the budget speech, program agreements with Manitoba Public Insurance and letters to the insurer. CTV News reported that Neville found that record left the court “in no better position than the applicant to discern who the decision-maker may be,” calling the government’s stance “puzzling, at best” and its suggestion that the court identify the decision-maker itself “untenable.”
Kinew government must file sworn affidavit by Monday
- The Kinew government has until Monday to file a sworn affidavit identifying who excluded Tesla, what information they considered, and any privilege claimed — and Tesla can cross-examine the person who swears it (CTV News).
- The ruling does not decide whether the exclusion was lawful or reviewable; Tesla vehicles remain ineligible, and the government’s motion to strike the case is still outstanding.
- Tesla claims the exclusion cost consumers $560,000 in forfeited rebates and caused it lost market share and customer loyalty, per its application as reported by CTV News.
“Trump-proofing” on budget day
The exclusion traces to March 20, 2025, when Finance Minister Adrien Sala unveiled the provincial budget. Removing Tesla from the rebate program, he said, was about “Trump-proofing our economy” and a “commitment to be elbows up.” Chinese-made EVs were excluded at the same time.

But the stated rationale sat uneasily beside the program’s own design. Manitoba launched the rebate in 2024, retroactive to 2023, to cut greenhouse gas emissions. The program pays $4,000 on new EVs or plug-in hybrids priced below $70,000, $2,500 on used EVs and $1,000 on leases. The province has since extended it to March 31, 2027, with Tesla still out.
Premier Wab Kinew’s own words are now Exhibit A in Tesla’s argument. During an October hearing, Tesla’s counsel cited the Premier’s 2025 remark that Tesla CEO Elon Musk should “get Donald Trump to stop the tariffs, and then we can talk about the EV rebate.”
Neville said that, absent a proper record, the company has “only media reports and public remarks from Manitoba’s Premier through which to glean the rationale” for its exclusion.
Why the affidavit order matters
The legal mechanics here are not routine. Courts do not typically force governments to explain their rationale by sworn affidavit. Neville acknowledged as much, writing that compelling the record by affidavit is “an exceptional and unusual remedy” — but justified it because “the respondents refuse to identify anyone as the decision maker.”
The government’s defence, as CTV News and Drive Tesla Canada both report, is that the exclusion was a “non-statutory policy decision made under the government’s spending power” and therefore immune from judicial review. Neville’s reply: she cannot rule on reviewability without knowing who made the decision, and “such an assessment cannot be made in a vacuum.”

That circular position is what drew the sharpest language in the order. “The respondents’ position, in effect, appears to be that the reviewability of the decision must be determined before they can identify the decision maker and produce the record,” Neville wrote, per CBC. She also found it “highly improbable” the exclusion was decided contemporaneously with the budget speech itself, CTV News reported.
Tesla wins sworn decision-maker but not rebates
Drive Tesla Canada framed the Nov. 13 order as a small victory: Tesla gets a named, sworn, cross-examinable decision-maker. It does not get its customers’ rebates back, an overturned exclusion, or a ruling on legality. The province’s motion to dismiss the case will be heard alongside the application itself, Neville directed — meaning the affidavit and the strike motion land on the same docket.
Tesla did drop one front in the fight. According to CTV News, the company dropped its case against Manitoba Public Insurance after accepting the Crown insurer’s position that it did not make the exclusion decision.
Both sides went quiet after the ruling. Tesla’s Winnipeg legal counsel declined further comment, and the NDP government declined comment as well, CBC reported.
The open question
The affidavit, due within 10 days of Nov. 13, must confirm the record is complete, identify the decision-maker, detail what information they weighed, and disclose any privilege claimed over the materials. If the name is a minister, the exclusion looks reviewable and Tesla’s case proceeds on the merits. If the province successfully argues a protected spending prerogative, the case dies — with the $560,000 in consumer rebates Tesla says was forfeited left unaddressed.
Either way, the deadline is Monday.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.