Meredith, the advice columnist behind Boston.com’s Love Letters, has told a reader worried about finding “the one” that the whole question gets easier once the myth is dropped: staying with a person is a choice, not destiny.
In her reply to a letter signed “Is he?”, published on the Love Letters advice column, she argues that fate-based thinking strips romance of agency.
If you reject the idea that there’s a “one,” the whole thing gets a bit easier to get understand, I think, Meredith writes, agreeing with a friend of the letter writer who had made the same point. I agree with your friend – that it’s a choice to continue to be with the same person. It has to be. It should be. Otherwise, it’s a passive experience.
The column, which Boston.com runs as its long-running advice franchise on love and dating, answers readers’ anonymous questions and then throws them open to the audience. In this case, Meredith closes by asking readers whether they had a “moment” they could look back on as a decision, and invites new anonymous submissions through the column’s form.
A slow burn, not fireworks
The letter behind the answer came from a reader with a familiar dating history. As the syndicated text version carried by Reader TTS shows, she described relationships from ages 18 to 26 that “ended up not working out for various reasons,” with the last breakup hard enough that she swore off dating to finish a degree and focus on herself.
Then an old acquaintance resurfaced – a man she had met three years earlier before losing touch. She admits in the letter, as Reader TTS reproduces it, that she was “looking for a rebound and someone to make my ex jealous,” but the two ended up enjoying each other’s company.
A year and four months later, most of it spent in different cities with repeated trips and one month living together, she still cannot tell whether he is the one.
Her doubt has a specific shape. He checks every box on her list of valued qualities except one. The feeling is not what she remembers from past relationships – though, she notes, she saw those exes consistently, which long distance makes impossible. “Can love feel neutral or it is supposed to be this magical spark?” she asks. “I care about this man, but I don’t love him in that wild way.”
Meredith’s answer reframes the question entirely. She suggests the writer has been so busy deciding whether this man can be her everything that she has not asked the practical ones: whether he wants to live in the same part of the world, whether they agree on what the next year holds. The distance, she says, is what makes the big questions unanswerable.
On the spark question, she pushes back against the fireworks standard. “I do think that as we mature, sparks present themselves in new – and maybe more subtle – ways,” she writes. “Sometimes the sparks come later, when you see that a relationship really works.”
She goes further, questioning what the big sparks actually measure. “Sometimes those big sparks we feel in a relationship are about fear,” she writes. “Or not having feelings reciprocated.” A relationship that lets you relax, she suggests, is not a failure of romance.
She also points to the origin story itself: the relationship began as a slow burn, something the writer expected to be meaningless that grew into something more. Her prescription is logistical, not mystical – make immediate, practical plans and work on getting to the same place.
Take the pressure off
The second letter – the one about “the one” directly – got a shorter but blunter answer. Meredith tells that writer that the moment of knowing looks different for everyone. For some, it is being 28 and meeting someone who wants the same things: kids, a house. A 50-something might describe it differently.
A 50-something might tell you, “I realized over time that this person makes me laugh, so I want to keep them around.”
Her closing advice drops the once-and-forever framing that fuels so much dating anxiety. Try to take the pressure off yourself to choose once and correctly, she writes. You’ll get to the decisions when you need to.
She also offers a reframing of commitment that is quietly romantic rather than cynical. It’s quite romantic to look at someone and think, “There could be dozens of other people out there for me, but I enjoy you so much that I’m happy to stay right here,” she writes. Choice, in her telling, is not the enemy of love – it is the proof of it.
Both columns end the same way, with the audience invited in. When you ask a question, you help others feel less lonely about their own, Meredith tells readers in the newer letter. The older one ends on its own open question: “Readers? Are sparks necessary?”
Meredith Goldstein has been with the Boston Globe since 2002 and launched Love Letters on Boston.com in 2009, where she answers letters about every kind of love alongside a crew of commenters offering crowd-sourced advice.
Beyond the column, she is an author: her first novel, The Singles, was published in 2012 and optioned for film, and her memoir about the column, “Can’t Help Myself: Lessons and Confessions From a Modern Advice Columnist,” came out in 2018. She also records the audiobook herself and hosts Love Letters, the podcast, in which people tell real stories about dating and relationships.
The full letter and reply can be read in the text version of the Love Letters column carried by Reader TTS.