“The decision was not taken lightly,” the Saint-Marc elementary school administration told parents in a letter dated November 18.
The school, located in the Rosemont neighborhood of Montreal, has ordered a temporary suspension of tag during recess and daycare periods for students in grades 4, 5, and 6, lapresse.ca reported.
The school said that it had to act due to a “multiplication of problematic situations” observed during the game in recent weeks. Despite established rules and supervision, staff identified “shoving, students grabbing others by their clothing, blows struck to touch participants, as well as numerous conflicts and insults,” the administration said.
This ban will remain in effect until students return from the holiday break, a period the school intends to use to “readjust certain expectations and reflect on the conditions that could allow for a possible reintroduction of the game.” Parents were invited to encourage their children to adopt “civic and safe behaviors during recesses.”
Alain Perron, a spokesperson for the Centre de services scolaire de Montréal (CSSDM), explained that under the Education Act, it is the “prerogative of a school administration to see to the safety of students, including activities on the schoolyard.”
He said that several interventions by school staff occurred before the sanction was imposed, according to Lapresse. “Physical education teachers will eventually be called upon to help model the expectations,” Perron told lapresse.ca, adding that students have continued to remain active in the schoolyard during recess.
The situation at Saint-Marc mirrors a growing trend of bans in Quebec schoolyards, a topic La Presse reported on in 2024. Previous restrictions have included strict regulations for snow hills, where the Union réciproque d’assurance scolaire du Québec (URASQ) recommended specific heights of 1.8 to 3 meters and a slope of approximately 25%.
The Canadian Paediatric Society published a report in 2024 highlighting the importance of risk in play for healthy development. “Opportunities to engage in outdoor free play, and risky play in particular, have decreased considerably in recent years, in part because safety measures have aimed to prevent all play-related injuries rather than only serious and fatal injuries,” the study said.
The office of Minister of Education Joël Arseneau did not provide a response regarding the school’s decision at the time of publication.