Nashville SC Must Sprint to MLS Cup Title After Record-Breaking Marathon Season

Nashville SC opened the MLS Cup Playoffs as the biggest favorite in the league — and with the hardest history to beat.

The MLS Cup Playoffs began Thursday night with wildcard matches pairing the eighth- and ninth-place teams in each conference, with the Seattle Sounders hosting Real Salt Lake in the West and Orlando City SC hosting FC Cincinnati in the East. Nashville, the top seed in the East, waits its turn — and must now chase a double that has almost vanished from the modern MLS.

The club from Music City just completed the greatest regular season in the 31-year-old league’s history. Nashville finished 23-3-8 with 77 points, both league records, and ran away with the Eastern Conference, finishing 17 points ahead of Lionel Messi’s second-place Inter Miami CF (16-6-12). Its home record of 15-0-2 at GEODIS Park is also the best in MLS history, according to reporting carried by Yahoo Sports.

Winning the Supporters’ Shield — the trophy for most points in the regular season — has rarely led to an MLS Cup title lately. Only one team, Los Angeles FC in 2022, has completed the double in the last nine seasons, and only 11 Shield winners have lifted the Cup across three decades, a 36.6 percent success rate, per Yahoo Sports.

In the league’s opening eight seasons, by contrast, five Shield champions also won the playoffs, with D.C. United doing it twice, in 1997 and 1999.

So what should Nashville watch for? Two men who know the danger better than most. Sacha Kljestan and Dax McCarty, now analysts for MLS games on Apple TV, were members of a very good New York Red Bulls team (now called Red Bull New York) that captured the 2015 Supporters’ Shield. Neither player won an MLS Cup.

Nashville SC Must Sprint to MLS Cup Title After Record-Breaking Marathon Season
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

“First of all, be ready from the first whistle because we got scored on after nine seconds in the Eastern Conference final against Columbus Crew,” Kljestan said. “Then you get behind the eight ball, and then you’re digging and clawing to try to get yourself back into the game, which is not really a spot that Nashville has been in much this year.”

Kljestan urged the top seed to stay true to its identity. “I would say stick to who they have been and be ready from the first whistle because in a playoff series or a playoff game, if you go down early, the game changes,” he said.

He added that the pressure is different now: “We knew that Nashville was very good throughout the course of the season, but now the expectation is that you have to back it up.”

Managing emotions, not just matches

McCarty pointed to Nashville’s range as the reason he considers it the league’s best team — and to composure as its biggest test. “I think managing emotions is probably going to be the key for Nashville SC because they can play in any type of game,” he said.

“If they need to sit and see how to win and defend, they can do that. If they need to press, if they need to send numbers forward, if they need to be aggressive, counter-pressing, high line, you name it.”

He also downplayed the value of home field. “Just the fact that you have home-field advantage or you might play the last game at home, that doesn’t really mean all that much if you don’t take advantage of it,” McCarty said.

Reflecting on 2015 and 2016, he said his Red Bulls teams struggled when trailing: “I don’t think we managed going behind really well. We didn’t stay composed. We made mistakes. We missed big chances in the final third.”

The playoffs are a different animal from the 34-game grind, as Yahoo Sports laid out: even a wildcard team reaching the MLS Cup on Dec. 18 will play “only” seven contests — a sprint after the marathon.

A roster full of hardware

The individual honors keep coming for coach B.J. Callaghan’s squad. Maxwell Woledzi was named MLS Defender of the Year on Nov. 16, with teammates Jeisson Palacios and Andy Najar the only other finalists. Goalkeeper Brian Schwake was selected MLS Goalkeeper of the Year on Nov. 18.

Hany Mukhtar is one of five MVP finalists, Callaghan is a leading Coach of the Year candidate, and striker Sam Surridge — third in league scoring with 21 goals — is a contender for the MLS Best XI.

Elsewhere in the bracket, questions linger. Can Messi carry an Inter Miami side the reporting describes as defensively vulnerable deep into the postseason? Can last year’s runners-up, the Vancouver Whitecaps, return to MLS Cup, perhaps flying under the radar while Nashville and Miami absorb the spotlight?

Nashville SC’s rise has been swift. Founded in 2016 as a USL Championship franchise, the club spent two seasons in the second division before being awarded an MLS expansion team on Dec. 20, 2017, joining the league in 2020.

Its inaugural MLS match, a 2–1 loss to Atlanta United on Feb. 29, 2020, drew 59,069 spectators to Nissan Stadium — the highest attended soccer event in Tennessee history. Today the club plays at GEODIS Park, the largest soccer-specific stadium in the United States, and is principally owned by businessman John Ingram.

Nashville SC has about a month to answer the only question that matters, ending at the MLS Cup on Dec. 18. “Can Nashville stay composed?” McCarty asked. “That’s going to be where they need to handle the most pressure.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Karolinska Universitetssjukhuset söker sektionschef till medicinsk enhet neurologi